Not sure if anyone heard the Alan Richardson interview on SEN, he pretty much said Carlisle was worth a first rounder, 10 year player, he had met with him. I can't see Carlisle going to Carlton in the PSD as he has also said that he wants Essendon to get fairly compensated. I don't think it will be Saints pick 5 for Carlisle directly, maybe swap later picks as well. But Essendon and Carlisle would surely be happier with that then just sending him into the PSD rubbish you are continuing with.