James Aish

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Think we were really happy with the 3 defenders lever Goddard and marchbank then also laverde who slid from top 10 projection and then a smoky Dan McKenzie who looks the goods from the saints and we were maybe hoping for him 2nd round also .... Can see why they weren't too worried sliding from 10 to 14 despite it being high risk

They also said you wouldn't consider that most years but last year you could as even until pick 25

I thought Campbell's Chunky said Mckenzie was right up there with our next option?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

"IF" we lost Douglas and picked up Aish .....have we won on that deal?

 

[Bicks]

I thought Campbell's Chunky said Mckenzie was right up there with our next option?

I think he said we had hoped to pick McKenzie up with the pick we eventually used on Harrison Wigg??

 

[Houston]

"IF" we lost Douglas and picked up Aish .....have we won on that deal?

like for like except Aish is younger, making it a decent win.

 

[pjcrows]

"IF" we lost Douglas and picked up Aish .....have we won on that deal?

Huge win.

 

[Bicks]

Huge win.

Only on age, the rest is only that big word "potential" at this stage.

 

[lincsPJ]

"IF" we lost Douglas and picked up Aish .....have we won on that deal?

Where do I sign?

 

[pjcrows]

Only on age, the rest is only that big word "potential" at this stage.

Aish is going to be at least as good as Douglas. It's a no brainer.

 

[Crowbots are dead]

Aish is going to be at least as good as Douglas. It's a no brainer.

it is likely but potential is not always realized. Look at Bryce Gibbs at the moment.

 

[hey shorty]

it is likely but potential is not always realized. Look at Bryce Gibbs at the moment.

Bryce would be as good as Dougy at the same age. Mind you 1 was drafted at 16 in the draft and the other at 1.

 

[pjcrows]

it is likely but potential is not always realized. Look at Bryce Gibbs at the moment.

Well yeah. But if it was a matter of Douglas or Aish right now I don't know how you could pick Douglas. Aish has 10+ years left.

 

[FR0GGY]

"IF" we lost Douglas and picked up Aish .....have we won on that deal?

Probably more like what would you rather give up a first rounder or dougy to get aish

 

[pjcrows]

This board is insane.

If the deal was Douglas out and Aish in, would anybody seriously think we lose on that deal?!

 

[Bicks]

This board is insane.

If the deal was Douglas out and Aish in, would anybody seriously think we lose on that deal?!

I wasn't aware anyone was suggesting we lose on the deal just merely it came down to the relevant ages and that word potential which can't be banked on with certainty.

 

[adelaidecrows]

This board is insane.

If the deal was Douglas out and Aish in, would anybody seriously think we lose on that deal?!

I don't think we lose but we don't gain. I think that would be an unlikely trade. Aish wants to go so it should mean we don't have to give up a Douglas for him.

 

[pjcrows]

I don't think we lose but we don't gain. I think that would be an unlikely trade. Aish wants to go so it should mean we don't have to give up a Douglas for him.

I'm not saying it would happen. Others are suggesting it.

How do we lose if we trade Douglas for Aish!!

 

[hey shorty]

This board is insane.

If the deal was Douglas out and Aish in, would anybody seriously think we lose on that deal?!

Whats that ikea ad again......

START THE CAR !!!!!

 

[pjcrows]

I wasn't aware anyone was suggesting we lose on the deal just merely it came down to the relevant ages and that word potential which can't be banked on with certainty.

The fact that it comes down to age is my precise point. Aish has 200+ games left. So we win on the trade bigtime.

 

[adelaidecrows]

I'm not saying it would happen. Others are suggesting it.

How do we lose if we trade Douglas for Aish!!

I said we don't lose. We just don't gain. We do lose a hard gut running player though.

 

[pjcrows]

I said we don't lose. We just don't gain. We do lose a hard gut running player though.

Of course we gain!

 

[Bicks]

The fact that it comes down to age is my precise point. Aish has 200+ games left. So we win on the trade bigtime.

POTENTIALLY we win big time.......

Unlike you some of us just don't take everything for granted.

That is my last word on the subject.

 

[adelaidecrows]

Of course we gain!

You are arguing age. Fair point. What if Aish spends the next 4 years doing his knee. By your argument we might as well trade Dangerfield for the number 1 pick and be done with it. Then in 5 years time, trade in that number 1 pick for the number 1 pick and so on. We win, we get age!

 

[lunacy]

So he's a slightly poor mans Brad Crouch ?

No his kicking skills are much better than Brad's. Brad has a lot of great traits, but kicking is not a strength of his.

 

[FR0GGY]

I'm not saying it would happen. Others are suggesting it.

How do we lose if we trade Douglas for Aish!!

Aish bombs and Dougy continues his normal form?

 

[lincsPJ]

I said we don't lose. We just don't gain. We do lose a hard gut running player though.

I've had a few reds so can someone help me with this?