James Aish

[Glenno23]

Nick Maxwell, that former bogan captain of collingwood has stated Aish might go back to Melbourne, maybe Collingwood or Carlton.

Back to Melbourne? When was he ever there?

 

[little graham]

Back to Melbourne? When was he ever there?

Collingwood are always right.

 

[Captain Morgan]

Nick Maxwell, that former bogan captain of collingwood has stated Aish might go back to Melbourne, maybe Collingwood or Carlton.

Forgot to add "talentless" to that statement

 

[billy fragos]

CEY>Aish

 

[Pdub]

CEY>Aish

It took CEY three years in an AFL club to get where he is, wait and see Aish after the same amount of time.

 

[billy fragos]

It took CEY three years in an AFL club to get where he is, wait and see Aish after the same amount of time.

3 years of sanfl...

 

[Pdub]

3 years of sanfl...

4 AFL pre-seasons

 

[Mckaye17]

Aish had a ripper first season for a draftee, and has had 1 bad AFL game this season. Bloke will be star in the coming years, thinking it'll start next year in the number 5 after Thommo hangs up the boots.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Aish had a ripper first season for a draftee, and has had 1 bad AFL game this season. Bloke will be star in the coming years, thinking it'll start next year in the number 5 after Thommo hangs up the boots.

Is it fair to say he plays like and may be an improvement on Vince?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

It took CEY three years in an AFL club to get where he is, wait and see Aish after the same amount of time.

It would have been so easy for the club to turn CEY over ......so much patience for a midfielder is unusual ....glad the club did.

Aish though is just footy smart that you can't teach .....only question is body durability

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

Is it fair to say he plays like and may be an improvement on Vince?

More like a much better upgrade of Mackay.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

More like a much better upgrade of Mackay.

What you say Alex !

 

[Pdub]

It would have been so easy for the club to turn CEY over ......so much patience for a midfielder is unusual ....glad the club did.

Aish though is just footy smart that you can't teach .....only question is body durability

I'd imagine if we had 2 more draft picks in 2012 and 2013 he would have been pushed out.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

More like a much better upgrade of Mackay.

No seriously Mackay and Aish completely different playing types ....Aish more like Vince

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I'd imagine if we had 2 more draft picks in 2012 and 2013 he would have been pushed out.

Maybe if we didn't have the Draft restrictions it may have been a different story ...you are correct

 

[Pdub]

Maybe if we didn't have the Draft restrictions it may have been a different story ...you are correct

The same goes for Atkins, we'll see if Atkins also can make it.

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

No seriously Mackay and Aish completely different playing types ....Aish more like Vince

fine - hes an outside quick wing type. You say Vince, I say Mackay.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

The same goes for Atkins, we'll see if Atkins also can make it.

Seems to be good leaks coming out of the club on Atkins ......he was highly respected in underage with maybe a ? on his personality

Atkins = Jaensh?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

fine - hes an outside quick wing type. You say Vince, I say Mackay.

I say midfielder ...you say wingman

 

[Roo Lives Again]

Forgot to add "talentless" to that statement

What an absolute flog is Maxwell. Typical Victorian footballer doesn't have a clue about anything outside the Vic border.

 

[Houston]

Seems to be good leaks coming out of the club on Atkins ......he was highly respected in underage with maybe a ? on his personality

Atkins = Jaensh?

Was it him that was busted eating a bucket of KFC in his car before a TAC game?

 

[King Elvis]

1 - Danger
2 - Sloane
3 - B Crouch
4 - B Smith
5 - Aish
6 - Douglas
7 - M Crouch
8 - VB
9 - CEY
10 - Mackay
11 - Lyon
12 - Grigg

Plus Kerridge, in there somewhere.

VB
CEY
Mackay
Lyons
Grigg

They'd be the ones who might struggle with that many; although Wright isn't demanding a spot, nor is Hendo, so we could shuffle things a bit.

If we can get Aish, we must.

 

[latinoheat]

Aish had a ripper first season for a draftee, and has had 1 bad AFL game this season. Bloke will be star in the coming years, thinking it'll start next year in the number 5 after Thommo hangs up the boots.

Should be the number 8, grigg to number 5

 

[Sloane4pm]

Listening to swan (bris CEO not collingwood player) on 3AW seems pretty much aish is gone and he almost expects him to leave. Hopefully the new Adelaide regeme under Fagan and roo are silently doing their thing like with Walsh and tex

 

[pjcrows]

Listening to swan (bris CEO not collingwood player) on 3AW seems pretty much aish is gone and he almost expects him to leave. Hopefully the new Adelaide regeme under Fagan and roo are silently doing their thing like with Walsh and tex

What did he actually say?