Slobbo says in The Tackle that Aish was tagging Scully:
"
2. Match-up winners.Tagging has returned to the game and Collingwood took it to the extreme which, combined with pressure and intensity, had too many Giants being non-factors. Grundy disposed of Mumford after quarter-time continuing a rich run of scalps for the Collingwood ruckman.
Other winners were Brent Macaffer on Heath Shaw, Ben Sinclair on Toby Greeneand James Aish on Tom Scully, a player in every third of the ground. Taylor Adams was a huge in the midfield, which Mick McGuane would be happy with, and we will say it again, when Jack Crisp is a factor with his aggression, the Pies are a far better team."