Recommitted James Aish

[Crowstar]

already off to north for pick 45

I'm not sure Aish would even stoop that low

 

[DrMike]

already off to north for pick 45

Damnit

 

[Bicks]

I think you missed his point

Yeah but you are talking about SANFL. Scharenberg was regularly getting 30+ touches in the VFL. Anyway, we would prefer him to stay here. It’s a relief to know you won’t be in his ear to return Home.

His analogy was Scharenberg must be a superior player because he plays in the VFL and Doedee has been playing in the SANFL, do you think in all honesty Scharenberg would force Jake Lever out if Lever was playing for the Pies this year........I think we both know the answer to that one.

 

[nahnah]

His analogy was Scharenberg must be a superior player because he plays in the VFL and Doedee has been playing in the SANFL, do you think in all honesty Scharenberg would force Jake Lever out if Lever was playing for the Pies this year........I think we both know the answer to that one.

Well no I dont think he would push Lever out but one can only assume he would be ahead of Doedee, I was responding to your SAFL > VFL because of state team results comment anyways

 

[BPikkers]

His analogy was Scharenberg must be a superior player because he plays in the VFL and Doedee has been playing in the SANFL, do you think in all honesty Scharenberg would force Jake Lever out if Lever was playing for the Pies this year........I think we both know the answer to that one.

Mate totally incorrect. Go back and read the posts. Anyway, let’s not get into it as this is the Aish thread and to be honest, I couldn’t be stuffed explaining it to you.

 

[Pykie]

You do realise the SANFL is widely regarded as the best comp outside the AFL?

In 2017 the VFL State Team went down to the WAFL State team
In 2016 the VFL State Team went down to theSANFL State Team

The VFL's batting average the last 2 years is 0 - 2

An AFL listed player won the Liston this year. The best VFL side didn't play, the metro comps of Victoria aren't much weaker than some VFL sides, completely different to the SA local leagues.

There's 5 x the amount of AFL players in the VFL than SANFL.

The end.

 

[Bicks]

Well no I dont think he would push Lever out but one can only assume he would be ahead of Doedee, I was responding to your SAFL > VFL because of state team results comment anyways

Fair enough but with Lever gone now Doedee will finally get his chance to translate his good SANFL form into the AFL which wasn't going to happen whilst Lever was the incumbent.

 

[Pack Specialist]

Future 5th rounder.

What an absolute gentleman.

 

[perplexed]

Damnit

We are happy to ontrade him if you can sweeten the deal.

 

[DrMike]

We are happy to ontrade him if you can sweeten the deal.

Sure Pick 53

 

[perplexed]

Sure Pick 53

Throw in that inky bloke with all those medals and it's a deal.

 

[TradeDraft]

Love how Threads turn into a Bash Collingwood Thread

 

[Pack Specialist]

I'm not sure Aish would even stoop that low

For a million a season he would!

 

[Deep]

All the potential in the world but seems like an absolute flog of a bloke. Surely there's some upside from a bloke who was considered one of the best talents of a draft the quality of 2013? He must have some improvement left.

Agree. Would suit Adelaide with Tex and Jenkins.

 

[Deep]

Love how Threads turn into a Bash Collingwood Thread

Let's turn it into a Roman Reigns bashing thread

Am I rite

 

[TradeDraft]

Let's turn it into a Roman Reigns bashing thread

Am I rite

Just Showing why this Thread has been a Waste of Time

 

[Deep]

Just Showing why this Thread has been a Waste of Time

On the real, are Collingwood actually shopping Aish around?

 

[Checkered]

Just Showing why this Thread has been a Waste of Time

Yeah we didn't need it when we had your Collingwood wrap thread to use lol

 

[NZ_Tiger]

On the real, are Collingwood actually shopping Aish around?

Waste of time, no one will pick up the $ on his contract and then give them a pick as well.

 

[Schachattak]

Waste of time, no one will pick up the $ on his contract and then give them a pick as well.

Seeing as it's all to land Schache I hope we keep him.

 

[Darkyprotector]

You do realise the SANFL is widely regarded as the best comp outside the AFL?

In 2017 the VFL State Team went down to the WAFL State team
In 2016 the VFL State Team went down to theSANFL State Team

The VFL's batting average the last 2 years is 0 - 2

Great observation
You do realise that isn't correct
No afl players in those teams
Means the talent pool is much thinner
2 afl teams in wa

 

[adammania9]

He's ******* sh*t

Always has been, always will be

 

[Bicks]

An AFL listed player won the Liston this year. The best VFL side didn't play, the metro comps of Victoria aren't much weaker than some VFL sides, completely different to the SA local leagues.

There's 5 x the amount of AFL players in the VFL than SANFL.

The end.

Which one of these sides chock-a-block full of current AFL listed players won the 2017 VFL Premiership...

Oh wait....

 

[rainwizard39]

He's ******* sh*t

Always has been, always will be

Wasn't always sh*t, at Brisbane he looked to be a very good player. At Collingwood he went down hill so fast. Then again Collingwood have to many good mids for him to get touches, so a team like west coast would suit him or Gold Coast (highly doubt he'd go back to Queensland).

 

[bird_man]

Wasn't always sh*t, at Brisbane he looked to be a very good player. At Collingwood he went down hill so fast. Then again Collingwood have to many good mids for him to get touches, so a team like west coast would suit him or Gold Coast (highly doubt he'd go back to Queensland).

He was very good in his first year st Brisbane