James Hird Vs Anthony Koutoufides

[Aussie Assault]

Hird..................Daylight....................Kouta

 

[Ando_4]

Hird by that far it's not funny.

Poll says so too.

 

[wally funk]

i can't choose between them. each of them in their prime were absolute champions. neither are still in their prime but hird probably is better than kouta now.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Hird has been better than Kouta for all but 1 or 2 seasons. Hird easily.

 

[DapperDon]

Hird has been better than Kouta for all but 1 or 2 seasons. Hird easily.

and those 2 seasons Hird was sidelined with injury.

 

[Barry Zuckercorn]

All club supporters have a to be expected bias towords their own players.
the majority of calrton supporters though take this to the extreme.

They refuse to look through the hatred they have for everyone else in the league and judge each player or club on their merits.

It would be good if there was some way to exclude supporters of the clubs involved in the poll from voting

I think Hird has Harvey covered, although both are obviously champions.

Dual premiership player, premiership captain and won more games off his own boot, just to name a few

Hi Merv... I think you must be slipping in your old age... You forgot to mention how Brendan Fevola is such a cancer to the club and that Carlton will never go anywhere while he's there etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc

 

[Barry Zuckercorn]

Who would you pick

Your next poll should be:

Fletcher v O'hailpin... Who has been the better defender?

Or something relatively similar in your favour

 

[Merv]

Hi Merv... I think you must be slipping in your old age... You forgot to mention how Brendan Fevola is such a cancer to the club and that Carlton will never go anywhere while he's there etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc

Hey Barry, not slipping mate, only post that sort of info, when the thread or a comment by a poster relates to something along the lines of fev and his cancerous effects.

This thread was about Hirdy and Kouta, with fev nowhere to be seen, so no need to mention him.

 

[_shifty_]

Is this poll for real?

thats wat i thought,
kouda can barely play now, hird dominated 2day

 

[greenlight]

Hirds injury prone...where you been what about kouta...he has life member ship at red cross buddy Hird by a long way...and you have never seen hird do nothing good....ohhh please...get out of bed

 

[Silvagnis]

Whoops, thought we were talking about who was the most overpaid

That would be Jonathan Hay who cost you more than just alot of money.

 

[Silvagnis]

and those 2 seasons Hird was sidelined with injury.

So Kouta's best seasons don't count because Hird was injured?

Kouta dragged a pretty average side to the finals in 2000 and that deserves as much respect as any of Hird's best years.

He was unstoppable that year.

 

[DapperDon]

So Kouta's best seasons don't count because Hird was injured?

Kouta dragged a pretty average side to the finals in 2000 and that deserves as much respect as any of Hird's best years.

He was unstoppable that year.

yet Woewodin won the Brownlow, Kouta's best was overshadowed by a guy who cares more about his sun bed than football.

 

[greenlight]

So Kouta's best seasons don't count because Hird was injured?

Kouta dragged a pretty average side to the finals in 2000 and that deserves as much respect as any of Hird's best years.

He was unstoppable that year.

how can you say that flint...essendon won the flag that year with hird as captain and norm smith med....shows how good kouta was huh...hird by the lenth of a marathone...i think kouta is good but not any where near hird

 

[RED AND BLACK SOLDIER]

football ability Hird

dancing ability Kouta

Agreed, theirs not many players that are better than Kouta in the dancing department.

Hirdy by a a mile!