- Oct 31, 2016
- 3,077
- 2,265
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Other Teams
- qpr
He hasn't resigned yet. Are other clubs interested in him?
Traded James Peatling traded to Adelaide with F3 & F4 (both tied to GWS) for F2 (tied to Adelaide)
- Thread starter sydney_gws
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Rookie listed still isn't he? I think it's a wait and see. He can play another 2 years as a rookie with the 5 year change. Probably hoping for a rookie elevation. Will get that if he shops around as he's quite a decent role player. If he wants to go to another club unless GWS is offering him a main list spot he can go for free like Ambrosio did. I feel like he's waiting and seeing if they can squeeze him on the main list but will stay on another year as a rookie.
- Oct 11, 2012
- 4,584
- 7,173
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
We should be interested, got a few holes to plug and every time I watch GWS and he's playing, I end up wondering why he gets dropped the following week.
Maybe there's something I'm not seeing?
Maybe there's something I'm not seeing?
He sits behind Coniglio, Kelly, Green, Ward and Callaghan from what I've seen. Rightfully behind them all.
If 4 of them are playing then Peatling seems to be the one to cop a vest or being dropped or something
100% would take him at the dees. Smashed Oliver around the stoppages a fortnight ago.
The fact he was dropped a couple of times was mind boggling at the time and still is now, particularly when he was dropped despite being from memory their best player in the first Sydney Derby.
Big fan. Would love him at Collingwood
Big fan. Would love him at Collingwood
- Oct 31, 2016
- 3,077
- 2,265
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Other Teams
- qpr
- Thread starter
- #12
We should resign him, has he been delisted before? We need to be mature enough to accept Cumming is leaving, give he and Perryman a deadline to resign, but we don't want this stuff to derail our season.
No. GWS selected him in the 2021 MSD and he signed a contract extension [2 years] in 2022.
You would like to think we can keep the New South Welshmen. But our record in keeping New South Welshmen is patchy.
- May 11, 2019
- 6,589
- 11,875
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Would be picked every week at the saints and would be highly valued.
Starting three of Steele, Phillipou and Peatling for 2025 would give the fans something to look forward to in the middle.
Would love him at the Crows, but with ANB likely on the way it probably isn’t realistic
From Toongabbie in Western Sydney, played his junior footy with Kieran Briggs at Pennant Hills. Played NEAFL for us before being taken in the mid-season draft a few years ago. Has played back, forward and mid, which means his versatility makes him an ideal sub which can be seen as a problem for career progression.
I hope we re-sign him soon
WCE offered 4 years and plenty of midfield time
GWS now offering him 2 years still low money though
GWS now offering him 2 years still low money though
- Mar 19, 2020
- 16,631
- 46,808
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Eagles offer is high. Collingwood walked away once they saw our offer by the sounds of things so its between us and GWS.
If it is us I dont know what a trade offer would look like to be honest. Id imagine it would be say Hawthorns pick 30 + 59 for Peatilng + 49 so valuing Peatling at like the pick 35-40 range
Eagles have a big incentive to get away from pick 59 and into a pick below the 50 range for bidding for Malaki Champion so thats why Eagles would want that
If it is us I dont know what a trade offer would look like to be honest. Id imagine it would be say Hawthorns pick 30 + 59 for Peatilng + 49 so valuing Peatling at like the pick 35-40 range
Eagles have a big incentive to get away from pick 59 and into a pick below the 50 range for bidding for Malaki Champion so thats why Eagles would want that
- Mar 19, 2020
- 16,631
- 46,808
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Not sure why its seen as a bad move for Eagles.
Who else do people propose we spend our salary cap room on?
Who else do people propose we spend our salary cap room on?
It's the Eagles only current advantage.
List spots and cap space.
We should easily be able to outbid GWS.
4 Years averaging $600k. AFL average wage is nearly $500k now. With the cap going up again.
Giants should up their offer seeing as how he's in such demand.
I think theyre still fighting for Perryman and Cumming. Might up it if either commit to another club
Besides, can they offer him regular midfield minutes? Theyve got a few first round picks yet to get games too.
Hes been pushed out every time GWS have their first choice midfield in the side
Similar threads
