James Sellar

[daics cousin]

This could be the guy to take over from Leigh brown.

Only 22 would come cheap and he is an aggresive solid lad.
I think he got picked up in one of drafts at pick 14.

Just didn't get the opportunities at Adealide.He has just been delisted by the crows would be ideal,similar to the way we picked up Leigh Brown from North.

He can ruck and play up forward.

 

[PieBeast]

not sure if srs

 

[Shade]

How he was on Adelaide's list for so long amazes me.

No.

 

[HFF]

Oh, brother!

 

[TradeDraft]

Not 100% Sure about him. Would not be against it but still the question would be why is a 1st Round pick playing in the SANFL all the time?

 

[standingroomonly]

I'll take him but check if Guy Richards doesn't want to come back first.

 

[mwj81]

Hmmm thank god supporters dont do the selecting for our team, so far every other teams delisted players would be picked up.

 

[blaze036]

Adelaide will prob be forced to delist some real talent with the abundence of it on their list, aka Sellar. His gonna be big

 

[daics cousin]

Yeah but everyone said the same about Leigh Brown before we drafted him .

I know that Sellar would be good if given the chance.He wasn't given that at Adelaide,they had biglands,then Maric.

The guy had a few injuries early on,but then was discarded was originally recruited as a forward they tried to make him a ruckman he is more of a pinch hitter,why not he ois big bodied and would not cost us anything

 

[Beary17]

Lol needed a good laugh today. Aggressive? No. Solid? No. Ability? No. Get a kick in SANFL? No. Tall skinny and a waste of space, will be chasing money in the bush in 2 years time.

 

[Paranoid]

Would rather Setanta!

 

[jackster83]

His problem is that he is a bit too small for ruck (196 cm) and lacks the footy smarts to play KPP. Classic tweener. His tapwork is actually very good and he usually taps it too advantage. He goes okay as a big gorilla defender but gets outsmarted too easily by leading forwards.

Would probably be an alright rookie list selection as a backup player but the reality is he's had 5 years and is still to show signs of being an AFL player.

 

[Takahashi Tank]

Was going to start a new thread but may as well add it here. Last year I mentioned we should go after him but didn't as was not required.

Now we may need him. He is playing up in Darwin to resurrect his career.

Forget about Sellar. Go for C.Cloke.

196cm 100kg. Worthy of a low selection IMO. If anything would make it even harder for Trav to ever leave which is almost worth the selection in itself.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Was going to start a new thread but may as well add it here. Last year I mentioned we should go after him but didn't as was not required.

Now we may need him. He is playing up in Darwin to resurrect his career.

Forget about Sellar. Go for C.Cloke.

196cm 100kg. Worthy of a low selection IMO. If anything would make it even harder for Trav to ever leave which is almost worth the selection in itself.

Leigh Brown was in the 190s and was handy in the ruck.. we could do worse as a backup getting Sellar.. Cameron Cloke is the worst footballer i have ever seen!!! No chance of picking up that *******.

 

[Optimax]

We are not drafting Sellar, collingwood don't rate him.

So next

 

[Frankie23]

Looks good on paper, former high draft pick, good height and weight...and then you watch him play.

No thanks.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Sometimes I just cry.

How is it that every failed player delisted by a bottom ranked club suddenly becomes a good fit for Collingwood?

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Sellar looks like Tarzan and plays like Jane

 

[ash84]

Nope. Need to stop going after players who are going to be in our top 25-30...

 

[Ed D]

To be honest I'd rather him than Setanta, but I wouldn't want either at the club.

 

[Giant Sphinx]

I was waiting for this to come up.

My father in law a crows supporter couldn't wait for the news yesterday. Ive never seen him do happy when I told him Sellar had been delisted. He couldnt get a kick at Glenelg so why on earth would we want him.