Jarryd Roughead vs Daniel Bradshaw

[GrandBlue]

At their peak performance, who's a better player out of these two?

 

[Bigness]

I think they are equally good shots on Goal but I would take Rough nuts. I think he's overall as good as Bradshaw when both are firing, with the added upside that Roughnuts may get even better.

 

[GrandBlue]

I'll argue Daniel Bradshaw is better. IMO, he uses his body better, he knows how to beat his opponents and puts himself in the right position a lot of the time. When I watch Roughead play, it looks like he's just leading and leaping.

 

[a_fighting_fury]

I'd rather have Bradshaw on my team

 

[BluesMan]

ill go roughranga

 

[half_back_flank]

Bradshaw

 

[jiphoc]

I'll argue Daniel Bradshaw is better. IMO, he uses his body better, he knows how to beat his opponents and puts himself in the right position a lot of the time. When I watch Roughead play, it looks like he's just leading and leaping.

That was true last season. Remember the boy is only 22 years old. Over the summer he spent a lot of time trying to learn how to better use his body. In the first game at least and in the NAB cup it really showed how much he has improved with his body use.

Last year I would have said Bradshaw. Now however Roughy is a head comfortably and imo will be the CLEAR best forward in the comp in 2 year.... Yes including Franklin and Fev and that lot.

 

[hellfire]

Bradshaw comfortably for me when both are at their best.

Difference is, Roughead probably has his best in front of him... so that could definitely change.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Looking for someone at their peak, Go Bradshaw, but Good signs when Roughead is only 21

 

[markr]

I'd say Bradshaw at the moment, but I'm very excited about Roughead for this year and the future. He's had a great pre-season and is in excellent shape, but most importantly he seems to have worked very hard on his goal kicking. He had a shocker in the NAB challenge game against the Eagles, but appart from that his goal kicking has been superb. In our two NAB cup games and two real games this year he's kicked 18.3.

 

[Pocket Aces]

I'd rather have Bradshaw on my team

Only beacuse Bradshaw is 2cm shorter I am sure, aligns well with your clubs policy.

 

[SunKing]

If you were looking to the future you'd choose Roughhead of course because of his age.

But at both their peaks or for the next couple of years Bradshaw.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

hahaha, Grandblue, do you have a Hawthorn membership yet??

What's this your tenth thread involving a Hawthorn player....surely it gets boring after a while.

 

[pacman]

Your obsession continues, which other teams did you support before the Dogs?
On topic Rough turned 22 this year not yet at his peak and Bradshaw turns 31 at or past his peak. Both great players and would walk into any AFL side.

 

[GrandBlue]

hahaha, Grandblue, do you have a Hawthorn membership yet??

What's this your tenth thread involving a Hawthorn player....surely it gets boring after a while.

Sooner or later, something must be done about your whinging and trolling. I got the idea for this poll because some other Hawthorn supporter mentioned it somewhere else and if your eyes weren't only keeping an eye, exclusivly on Hawthorn polls, then you'd be able to see I make Polls involving other players too. So stop crying, ya little whinger.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Actually you're right, I come to the Polls board and see there as a Hawthron player being compared to someone else, then I look at who started the thread...surprise surprise, it's you again.

You need a new hobby.

 

[GrandBlue]

Actually you're right, I come to the Polls board and see there as a Hawthron player being compared to someone else, then I look at who started the thread...surprise surprise, it's you again.

You need a new hobby.

WHINGER ALERT. Haven't you read the new Poll rules? Quit crying about my Polls and find yourself a corner to cry in.

Anyway, on-topic. After round 3, things should be easier to decide. You just wait, I got money on Bradshaw for the Coleman!