Jason Cloke

[Da Shag On Fire]

Great, another recycled DUD.
I thought rebuilding was the key, not short term gain. It comes to bite you on the arse every time. Look at our current recycled players. That have done such a great job havent they.

 

[Galla]

That is probably the most stupid idea I have heard all year. Cloke cannot play football. Never in his life has he been able to play football. There were 21 other players in his Eastern Ranges side who would've made better AFL players if given the chance. The only reason he got a chance is cos his name is cloke. We want to rebuild and maybe one day again soon win a flag. If cloke so much as breathes on the club we can pencil in another wooden spoon. Livinstone, Thornton, Prendergast, Norman, Morrell - 5 talls who are already 5 times the player that cloke will ever be and would all be much better in defence. We have no room for him, We do not want him.

 

[bibi01]

he can't ruck, is not a KPP, not quick enough to play as a flanker, doesn't have the tank to play onball

carlton are not in a position to a pick another player with limited ability

MM summed it up pretty well a couple of years back- he played better in last years GF

 

[BarraKouta]

Pagan wants Cloke, but the rumours are bull******** and Jason doesnt want to go anywhere

 

[Andyt30]

love to take players of under eddies nose and turn them into champion pLayers
and give the Pies dud players

 

[mushda]

I'd take a punt on him for a late draft pick.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

I'd take a punt on him for a late draft pick.

Collingwood won't trade him and if they do it would be for at least a second round pick or a fringe player.