Prediction Jenkins' Trade Value: 2 first rounders or a half-eaten sandwich?

[Deaneus!]

Jenkins wondering where his career will take him - hence the worried look​

Jenkins is going to try to find a new club!

News - Gone: Josh Jenkins and 2020 3rd traded for pick 37

"Adelaide has mutually agreed with Josh Jenkins and his manager Paul Connors that the key forward will explore a move to another club during the upcoming trade period."

www.bigfooty.com

In the meantime, this thread exists only to host a poll...

What's he worth?

Eventually this trade will be done. Select above what you think he'll eventually trade for.

​

 

[scoota10]

Probably 3 rd Rounder

 

[Madmunza]

 

[Morning_Fog]

Pick 1 or GAGF’d.

 

[jackster83]

Melbourne's 3rd rounder sounds about right.

 

[Crow till I die]

Melbourne's 3rd rounder sounds about right.

I's rather go Jenkins + 26 for 20. Then we have 2 picks right at the start of the 2nd round and we saw what happened last year when clubs were keen to live pick trade if players had slipped out of the 1st round that they wanted

 

[Scorpus]

Depends how much salary we're paying.

I mean Hawthorn traded a much better player in Jordan Lewis at the exact same age for a 9 position upgrade in the 3rd round. Travis Cloke was pick 76.

So I voted Jenkins value to be lower than pick 50

 

[GROTTO]

Its so dependent on the Club who is going after him and if they have a 2nd rounder available.

Getting the Dogs 2nd rounder for JJ would be a massive win for the Club, Pick ~30.

 

[relapse]

I always question the validity of polls especially when they're anonymous.

 

[GROTTO]

I always question the validity of polls especially when they're anonymous.

You can fix the poll so we can see who is picking what.

 

[relapse]

You can fix the poll so we can see who is picking what.

I've tried once before to do it, but I am pretty sure that once the poll has been created that it can't be changed from anonymous.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Late 2nd rounder / early 3rd rounder.

 

[GROTTO]

I've tried once before to do it, but I am pretty sure that once the poll has been created that it can't be changed from anonymous.

Its a long trade period and the poll began today, hopefully deaneus may make the poll visible?

Ie. Take it down and set up a new one.

 

[Footypie32]

Not expecting much. Don't want much.

Getting rid of his contract is plenty enough.

 

[Golumless]

3rd rounder. The main value is a bit of extra salary cap space, and getting Fogarty 22 games. If a replacement like Frampton/HH explode, then also a bonus.

 

[Deaneus!]

Its a long trade period and the poll began today, hopefully deaneus may make the poll visible?

Ie. Take it down and set up a new one.

Okay, had to scrub it and start again

All good now, visible voting

 

[Dewy006]

Just getting his salary off our books is enough compensation. Getting a mid to late 3rd rounder would be a cherry on top.

 

[Smoooothy]

what kind of sandwich we talking? this is important

 

[John Who]

A chicken/lamb combo yiros..

Oops. Thought this was the “favourite snacks” thread.

 

[John Who]

I hope somewhere between pick 30-40. JJ would definitely be useful in a team lacking forward potency.

 

[relapse]

Okay, had to scrub it and start again

All good now, visible voting

Nice work

 

[GROTTO]

Okay, had to scrub it and start again

All good now, visible voting

Nice work

Thanks guys great work.

Seeing that we have become Carlton now and where our off-season is where we can beat our chests and brag about our picks, this next 8 weeks or so will be the highlight of the year for us posters.

Would be good if any future polls are put up, if the poster's selection choice is visible. Just adds a bit of fun and novelty to the thread.

 

[Shaz2012]

He is worth pretty much zero. A salary dump. His trade value will be related to whatever amount of his salary we agree to pay. If a club with a TPP squeeze wants to give up a high second then we can give them some TPP relief in exchange.

 

[relapse]

Thanks guys great work.

Seeing that we have become Carlton now and where our off-season is where we can beat our chests and brag about our picks, this next 8 weeks or so will be the highlight of the year for us posters.

Would be good if any future polls are put up, if the poster's selection choice is visible. Just adds a bit of fun and novelty to the thread.

I agree

Anonymous polls just encourage trolls to influence the vote.

I've noticed that the 2 votes for Jerka being worth a Top 10 haven't reappeared since the voting is now public, what a surprise.

 

[Vhaluus]

I'm going to use Gibbs as a benchmark for player value and say a first and second rounder