Jeremy Cameron

[The Prosecutor]

Would happily make up a package that includes

Jameson (selling him as their answer in defence)
Watson (another defender)
Kruezer
Garlett
Our first round pick

Obviously not all of that, but I think Jameson + our first pick with some steak knives could be sold as a good answer to their defence issues

Carlton could then play Henderson in defence and Cameron forward

LOL, Jamison is 28 in a couple of weeks, Giants would want someone for 10+ years...

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Pick 2/3 and Jack Steven, bang.

Cameron would have to want to go for another side in the bottom 6 (and I have been kind). Unlikely. If he is to leave I still believe it will be one of Collingwood, Hawthorn or Geelong. Essendon/Saints on the next rung.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

LOL, Jamison is 28 in a couple of weeks, Giants would want someone for 10+ years...

Watson is lets just say average. It would be like us wanting a Pears trade. Not happening. The currency in Carlton are Henderson, Yarran, Gibbs, Menzel, Murphy.

 

[manboob]

Gibbs might be your ticket as well, Gibbs + (pick 5-7) could be around the top mark.

Yep. I'd let squibs go. Pick up picks 6 and 7 and profit.

 

[TigersMan4]

Grigg, Pettard, Edwards and Vickery should get it done

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Yep. I'd let squibs go. Pick up picks 6 and 7 and profit.

Exactly....so basically let Gibbs go...and then GWS gets two picks in the top 10 for Cameron. Burgoyne trade type. Melbourne are a chance to get that too with Frawley.

 

[E Shed]

well according to one of the hacks over here GWS are going to go very very hard at Fyfe so maybe they will ship him over here.
It would be about the one trade that wouldn't break my heart if Fyfe left.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

well according to one of the hacks over here GWS are going to go very very hard at Fyfe so maybe they will ship him over here.
It would be about the one trade that wouldn't break my heart if Fyfe left.

Can't see it but out of all the player/player deals this is the fairest.

 

[PTizzle]

Pick two of a top-line young key defender, a top-line young inside midfielder and a top 5 pick.

Yep, basically reckons it comes down to this.

While the Lions would kill for him (I know it says Victorian, but as a hypothetical) there's little we could give up that wouldn't destroy our list or not be enough to get a deal done.

Would be a bloody tough choice. The Pies could probably do something like Beams + their first pick and get close. Carlton I'm really not sure what they could do. The Doggies might be able to work something out but you'd be giving up something so good. If it's true (which I'm doubtful of) then it'd be a real 'no guts no glory' type of deal I reckon for a club going forward.

 

[E Shed]

Can't see it but out of all the player/player deals this is the fairest.

yeah its win win if it did happen. I don't want it to and I don't expect it too but its about right.

 

[Scotland]

Can't see it but out of all the player/player deals this is the fairest.

Can't see it at all.

Fyfe would only leave Freo for GWS for huge coin. If Freo can't afford him they are unlikely to be able to afford Cameron who may want to return to Victoria.

 

[Faysals Swans]

We dont have enough fowards. Well get him

 

[tropicaltiger]

He will nominate a club, the deal will get done, doubt you would be involving a Bruest type though. GWS need some more class in the middle. They sort of have Devon Smith that plays a similar role to Bruest. I do rate Devon Smith actually.

dustin martin come on down, the old man lives just down the road too.

 

[MaddAdam]

For that to have any chance, Bastinac would have to cement his spot in the starting 18 and Swallow would need to prove he can reach his pre-achilles standards.

I think for North, you'd almost have to package up Ziebell or Thompson with an Atley/Mullet.

I reckon they'd ask for Cunnington plus X myself, and Ben10 is simply untradeable. I'd trade Swallow. I'd even think about trading Ziebell. But not Ben.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I reckon they'd ask for Cunnington plus X myself, and Ben10 is simply untradeable. I'd trade Swallow. I'd even think about trading Ziebell. But not Ben.

Ziebell or possibly Daniel Wells although not sure on the latter with his injuries. Hansen might be an option too.

 

[MaddAdam]

Ziebell or possibly Daniel Wells although not sure on the latter with his injuries. Hansen might be an option too.

If they wanted Wells at 29 with his his injury history, I would have him up there as quick as possible.

Not Lachy though, put too much time into him and it would kind of defeat the purpose.

 

[jackess]

They are going to ask for the world probably start with Carlisle/First pick or Heppell/First pick.

Essendon's first pick is a third rounder next year isn't it?

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Essendon's first pick is a third rounder next year isn't it?

They have a 'compensation' pick for their penalties between the first and second round.

 

[Rusty22]

beams, pendlebury grundy and elliot, would that be enough?

 

[t_bond_legend]

Would happily make up a package that includes

Jameson (selling him as their answer in defence)
Watson (another defender)
Kruezer
Garlett
Our first round pick

Obviously not all of that, but I think Jameson + our first pick with some steak knives could be sold as a good answer to their defence issues

Carlton could then play Henderson in defence and Cameron forward

You could offer all 4 players + your first round draft pick and GWS would still lose out on that deal. No chance.
Yarran + Gibbs + draft pick will get it done.

 

[MaddAdam]

North send Aaron Black and Andrew Swallow to Freo.

Freo send Nat Fyfe to GWS.

GWS send Jeremy Carey to North.

(Not going to happen, but I'd do it)

 

[manboob]

Throw a few sexy draft picks around and you might get it done. I've seen worse deals.

 

[MaddAdam]

Throw a few sexy draft picks around and you might get it done. I've seen worse deals.

Black playing 2nd fiddle to Pav would be very good for Freo and Swallow doesn't have Fyfe's all around class, but he plugs the gap enough.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Black playing 2nd fiddle to Pav would be very good for Freo and Swallow doesn't have Fyfe's all around class, but he plugs the gap enough.

Would take a bit more from North though i.e. your first rounder. Fyfe is still just 22, he has near Judd-like value (not as decorated but he'll be a year younger than Judd was when he left). No way do Freo give him up for just Black and Swallow.

This deal is moot though - if Swallow is traded I'll eat my hat. When was the last time a club traded its captain voluntarily (i.e. not including Judd in 2007)?

 

[Croweater]

People are forgetting a club like Port. They have no problem acquiring and retaining kids from country Victoria. Ollie Wines springs to mind.

Port are about to go on a rampage, they pull good crowds and would be able to offer him some handy cash.

Plus, Cameron's a bit of a country lad. Might enjoy the calm waters of Henley Beach rather than the hustle and bustle of St. Kilda beach.