Jesse hogan

[Northworth]

dont need Dawes

 

[Trav 20]

Michael Quinn was from Ireland, didn't grow up playing the game and couldn't kick a goal from the goal square in the AFL.

So yeah well done on the B&F. Means jack sh*t though.

It didn't to anyone with remotely astute eyes, who had an understanding of what they were seeing unfold before them.

 

[Demonic Ascent]

Just hope for Melbourne's sake he does not head of to Fremantle in the coming years.

If we ever lose this kid I think I'll cry.

 

[Demonic Ascent]

Why are melbourne going on about boyd contract.

Where has this happened?

 

[SBYM]

No need for a Rising Star thread this weekend. Hogan has it sewn up.

Fantastic game against one of the best KPBs in the league. That mark and goal in the fourth was brilliant

 

[Sweetback]

Home is where the heart is:

 

[Topkent]

Home is where the heart is:

View attachment 128534

Ah yeah, taken before you blokes lost a grand final

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

I couldn't believe the maturity and assurance from such a young player, is going to be a star.

 

[Sweetback]

Ah yeah, taken before you blokes lost a grand final

Taken just before the grand final, actually. Just another kid barracking for his team.

 

[Topkent]

Taken just before the grand final, actually. Just another kid barracking for his team.

Which is what I said

 

[Sweetback]

Which is what I said

Apologies. It seems it is what you said.

 

[HARKER]

Saw Hogan in a VFL game against Carlton 2 years ago, and the term Super-Star came to mind.

The trick for Jesse will be to stay on the park and along with Cameron, he'll will be the KPF that brings people through the gates.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Like a blue engram turning yellow at the Cryptarch

Er, sorry....

 

[carnthedons]

Watched a bit of the kid Friday night, sploosh. Can't imagine the feeling I'd have if he played for my team.

 

[Yellow Feathers]

Hogan will be the KPF that brings people through the gates.

 

[Tulip]

Taken just before the grand final, actually. Just another kid barracking for his team.

Can't wait for Judd, Pendles and Buddy to head back to the Deeeeees

 

[incubi]

These boyd vs hogan comparisons are a bit premature. At boyds age Hogan had yet to play a game.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

These boyd vs hogan comparisons are a bit premature. At boyds age Hogan had yet to play a game.

Six months age difference, gotta love these types of posts

 

[incubi]

Six months age difference, gotta love these types of posts

And a whole extra year on an afl list, a much longer time with his team and gameplan...i'd say they are all fairly relevant, especially seeing that just two weeks ago Boyd kicked 3 goals, had 14 touches and 6 marks against the hawks.
But ultimately the issue is why is everyone obsessed with comparing young players? they are very different players and both have plenty of time to improve

 

[Demonic Ascent]

These boyd vs hogan comparisons are a bit premature. At boyds age Hogan had yet to play a game.

If both can live up to the potential/hype who gives a crap who is "better"? Both sets of long suffering supporters would be happy.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

And a whole extra year on an afl list, a much longer time with his team and gameplan...i'd say they are all fairly relevant, especially seeing that just two weeks ago Boyd kicked 3 goals, had 14 touches and 6 marks against the hawks.
But ultimately the issue is why is everyone obsessed with comparing young players? they are very different players and both have plenty of time to improve

You're doing a pretty good job trying to compare the two so why don't you tell us why people have an obsession with it.

Here's another one for you, Boyd didn't miss the whole of last year because of injury.

 

[Milanista28]

Why does Lethal hate Boyd?

Anyone catch last Friday night when they were comparing the 2 and Leigh quickly jumped in with "He's better than Boyd" Why does he dislike Boyd so much?

 

[Marc_Remillard]

Why does Lethal hate Boyd?

Anyone catch last Friday night when they were comparing the 2 and Leigh quickly jumped in with "He's better than Boyd" Why does he dislike Boyd so much?

It's really strange because normally he hates anything that has to do with Melbourne. Personally I think he's just going senile, I wouldn't take notice of anything he says. Boyd will be a great player

 

[incubi]

You're doing a pretty good job trying to compare the two so why don't you tell us why people have an obsession with it.

Here's another one for you, Boyd didn't miss the whole of last year because of injury.

I was trying to show that comparisons are ridiculous, you have a tiny sample size and a lot of variables....when your comparing based on a handful of inconsistent games it never works.

 

[Headless]

Why does Lethal hate Boyd?

Anyone catch last Friday night when they were comparing the 2 and Leigh quickly jumped in with "He's better than Boyd" Why does he dislike Boyd so much?

Is there any other history? It seems a bit of a stretch to say that he hates Boyd based solely on that.