JLT2 - Crows v Cats

[dogs105]

CEY needs another run.

Out: Sauce, Beech, Mackay, Talia, Betts maybe

In: Knight, Greenwood, Galluci, Keath, ....

Dear to get a bigger run.

 

[GreyCrow]

Dear to get a bigger run.

Agreed

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

about what I would do as well although if CEY is fit I'd try him again
How midget is our on ball brigade ? Milera > M Crouch the second tallest > Cameron > Douglas/Knight

Greenwood?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I liked that Poholke kid, looked like a footballer out there.

Give him another run and see if he adapts further

 

[GreyCrow]

Give him another run and see if he adapts further

I would play him all 3 if his season has been mostly penciled in as SANFL. Though 2 games would be the most either of the 2 first draftees can expect

 

[BRL121]

Grabs em whenever he has the chance

Nice try, Grey! Unfortunately, if we go down this path, we'll probably get into severe trouble with a couple of posters.

 

[GreyCrow]

Nice try, Grey! Unfortunately, if we go down this path, we'll probably get into severe trouble with a couple of posters.

Oh I don't know, pretty sure Bicks doesn't mind a few Trump jokes

 

[Danger in Texas]

Give him another run and see if he adapts further

Lot of 1st year players that played the last two weeks did a lot better in the 2nd week than in the 1st, same could happen with Myles

 

[TexForPM]

if Knight doesn't play I don't know if I'll be more stunned or disappointed. Greenwood would be a lovely bonus.

want to see Milera, Hampton, Menzel and Poholke again, and why the hell not when Sloane and Brad can't play. Has there been any more info on Doedee's little (supposedly?) injury? Desperate to see him out there too. Hunter's not a bad idea either, Jacobs and ROB didn't exactly fill me with confidence on Friday night.

Wigg too.
His DE was around 60. Reckon he can perform much better

 

[Carmo]

Very hard to tell what will happen this week until we know something about the injury situation.

They'll want to look at CEY, Beech and Dear cos of SANFL form last year.
They've said they'll look at Gallucci, Knight, Greenwood and Hunter this week.

There are people who look fringe 22 who will want more time to push a case again such as Hampton, Menzel, Milera and Mackay.

After that it gets tough to work out what's going on.

I would assume we'd try and keep a bit of experience around which to keep structures etc intact, otherwise we don't get enough from the game. Below is what happened in Game 2 last year. I couldn't remember how much experience we rested, I didn't realise it was as much as shown here(that is there was more experience in the stands in that match than I recall). I have bolded the people that played who I consider experienced:

IN
Rory Sloane
Troy Menzel
Sam Shaw
Jake Kelly
Reilly O’Brien


OUT
Scott Thompson
Daniel Talia
Taylor Walker
Eddie Betts
Sam Jacobs

The team is:
4. Josh Jenkins
6. Jake Lever
7. Nathan van Berlo
8. Mitch Grigg
9. Rory Sloane
11. Paul Seedsman
14. David Mackay
15. Kyle Hartigan
16. Luke Brown
21. Rory Atkins
25. Kyle Cheney
26. Richard Douglas
27. Tom Lynch
28. Cam Ellis-Yolmen
29. Rory Laird
30. Wayne Milera
31. Jarryd Lyons
32. Troy Menzel
33. Brodie Smith
34. Sam Shaw
36. Dean Gore
38. Harry Dear
41. Mitch McGovern
43. Reilly O’Brien
44. Matt Crouch
47. Jake Kell

For comparison Jack is Back's team from the OP has the following experience (bolded):

Wigg Hartigan Otten

Smith Talia Laird

Atkins M Crouch Milera

Cameron McGovern Knight

Menzel Jenkins Lynch

O'Brien

Hampton

Douglas

Greenwood, Gallucci, Kelly, Mackay, Poholke, Gore, Dear, Hunter.

11 experienced v 12 experienced. So J.I.B is pretty close to on the money. If it were me I'd want to look at CEY and Beech, so I'd drop Dougie and Poholke. I know people are making a case to keep Poholke in but if he was going to get 3 games surely Gallucci was going to as well and had to feature in the first game too. I think they might get two at most, we could always drop a Lynch, Laird or Smith (ones for which we have like for likes waiting or in the team already) to all this to happen (Poholke to play).

 

[Coopers]

I don't think we'll play Sloane. Not a week out from glueing/screwing eye socket surgery.
Would be disappointing not to get games into Gallucci, Knight, Greenwood.

 

[Murray2503]

Would like to see what knight, gallucci, doedee and greenwood can do another game into rob, menzel, hampton, dear, polke, wigg, and milera.

 

[jackster83]

OUT: Jacobs (rest/inj), CEY (rest/inj), Lynch (rest), Mackay ("general soreness")
IN: Hunter, Knight, Greenwood, Gallucci

 

[ad victoriam]

Thought Brown was going to be available. If so, rest Laird as he had a good hit out.

Agree the fit guys who missed must come in, particularly Knight, Gallucci & Greenwood who may be in the mix for round 1.

I would play Tex for at least a half as needs to find some form. Rest JJ instead as was on song.

I would keep Laird in the side and push him into the mid-field for a Half, I would also look at bringing in brown for MacKay

 

[rubbers0ul]

I think we already know Brown is best 22.

For the sanfl team?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

When/where is the game?

Yeah I could probably look it up somewhere I guess

 

[GrommoT]

... and then tell us

 

[Elite Crow]

When/where is the game?

Yeah I could probably look it up somewhere I guess

Sunday arvo at Richmond.

 

[the universal]

For the sanfl team?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Don't be silly.

 

[Thylacinus]

I'm looking forward to another hit out and in contrast to some on this board, am looking forward to both what out team as a whole and our midfield might produce this year. I believe we are building more depth and a good group of top end talent overall. All going well I expect us to be there abouts for the four and certainly top eight. As the Doggies showed anything can happen from there. Of course every other team is spending itself improving also. I love the look of our indigenous boys (Cameron, Milera, Hampton, Betts) infusing pace and x factor through the middle and up forward. He only had limited minutes on the ground but we looked much better when Mitch McGovern was out there. Plenty of x factor there. Another with only a few minutes was Beech, but showed in that time we need to see more of him. Hopefully this weekend with any luck.

 

[Geoffa32]

At some stage during the game would love to see a few midfield bounces with the set up of Atkins M Crouch ROB Hampton just to see how they go.

Inclusions I would like to see would be Greenwood, Galluci and Knight.

I would leave out Tex, Sauce, Eddie McGovern and Jenkins. Rest up and have a decent hit out against the Brians the following week.

Have Dear play Jenkins role.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[beartoo]

When/where is the game?

Yeah I could probably look it up somewhere I guess

Sun 1335 Richmond Oval

 

[Squiba]

Dear too the midfield?

Kidding not kidding... Don't think it'll work at all, but hell, what is 1 1/4 of jlt too put into a potential monster mid? Roughead like.

 

[Donkey Magoo]

I just hope we test people and systems as much as possible.
GWS rd 1 is going to be massive, we need everything humming nicely.
Mackay is humming at Mackay level he can rest, so can Talia , Betts and Laird.
Menzel needs all 3 games, he was a little off on Friday but still produced a great couple plays IMO not done enough yet for rd1 but I'm a believer.
Hampton was impressive and needs to back it up.
CC gets better with every minute that he plays.
ROB needs to play out the rest of the series. We need him.
Love to see Doedee and Greenwood as well they've had time in the system now they need a run.
Poholke will be a draft gem, another run please.
Milera looks that bit better.
And show us the Gooch!

 

[MRB37]

Beech and Gov out for the game against Geelong. Jacobs will play and Brown will get a run.

Seedsman likely to return via the SANFL when the season starts.