I don't want to derail the thread because Selwood has been one of my favourite players of all time. Absolute champion almost from his first game and the longevity factor is a big one.I'm similar in thinking
No doubting the talent of GAJ, but does he drop down a spot for the 110 games played at GC and not playing his entire career with Geelong?
However, from 2007-2009:
GAJ won three coaches association awards, three players MVPs, two best and fairest awards, and one Brownlow (should've been 3 IMO) between 2007-2009 when the team played arguably it's greatest ever football and won two flags.
It's as good a run as any player in the history of the game and for me, was the biggest factor in what will undoubtedly be my favourite period as a Geelong supporter.
His return as a half forward flanker was a key impetus in us being contenders across 2019-2020 (2018 we simply misused him).
Selwood of course has him covered for longevity and loyalty as a Cat, but I think sometimes GAJ is still underappreciated for what he gave us simply because of the defection.