Toast John Nicholls Medal 2021 - Congratulations Sam Walsh

[ferrisb]

I thought Plowman would finish higher

Too much love for Plowman...

 

[LanceRomance]

Too much love for Plowman...

To be fair... some where in between too much love, and not enough love, is just the right amount of love

 

[Blue and Blue]

Congratulations Sam. The sky is the limit young man.

 

[ferrisb]

To be fair... some where in between too much love, and not enough love, is just the right amount of love

Aw... shucks, Lance.

I feel the same way about you too.

 

[iAsbestos]

Did Larkey's game cost Weiters AA and B&F?

AA yes BNF no chance

 

[LanceRomance]

Did Larkey's game cost Weiters AA and B&F?

And I blame that Larkey game on our midfield.

Weiters was a lamb to the slaughter. Larkey isn't even that great relative to the other strong forwards in the comp.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

5 players in the history of the club have won the B&F by the age of 21. Two of them are currently on the list. Time to start achieving something with this squad!

Well done to Walshy and all the others who won awards.
Favourites were SOS winning the Spirit of Carlton award and Stocker winning Best Young Player.
Also love that our two bookend KPPs rounded out the top 3 in the B&F.

 

[FRUMPY]

Except the people that know a lot more than you and me and all of us didnt agree with you. And they give the votes.

And no longer have jobs

Sent from my CPH2005 using Tapatalk

 

[FRUMPY]

And I blame that Larkey game on our midfield.

Weiters was a lamb to the slaughter. Larkey isn't even that great relative to the other strong forwards in the comp.

Yeah the midfield got flogged, but he got torn a new one. It was in the midst of a couple of down weeks for weitering.

Sent from my CPH2005 using Tapatalk

 

[Bletch]

Yeah the midfield got flogged, but he got torn a new one. It was in the midst of a couple of down weeks for weitering.

Sent from my CPH2005 using Tapatalk

Weiters was minding 3 tall forwards that day. We had no-one else. Kemp playing his first game was our next tall.

 

[Monkey King]

This kid is like Coldstone ice cream. Looks vanilla ... until you add a whole bunch of extra s**t to it.

 

[GordonBlue]

Forget negativity.

Positives-a-plenty.

Our top 3 are great. Top level stuff.

I loved each speech from Pres down.

There is a really unity and belief in this group that I haven't seen for a long time.

I think even without the additions, we would have been one of the better teams next year. With the additions, there are no limits set.

 

[TwiggleyFanClub]

I thought Plowman would finish higher

Not enough lovevotes for Plowman.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Surprised Betts finished so high (9th).

 

[motleyblues]

Is there a list with all votes on it.just interested to see how some others polled.thanks

 

[Ruckus]

Is there a list with all votes on it.just interested to see how some others polled.thanks

Something I knocked together, a little hurriedly I must say, so please forgive any errors!

Hope the formatting is OK here...

01 183 Walsh
02 172 Weitering
03 118 McKay
04 112 Cripps
05 100 Curnow, E
06 97 Saad
07 86 Plowman
08 80 Jones
09 75 Betts
10 71 Silvagni
11 69 Fogarty
12 65 Docherty
13 63 Newman
14 59 Williams
15 56 Newnes
16 53 Kennedy
17 50 Martin
18 44 Pittonet
19 42 Owies
20 35 Stocker
21 34 Cottrell
22 34 Dow
23 28 Fisher
24 27 De Koning
25 27 Petrevski-Seton
26 26 Gibbons
27 23 Casboult
28 20 Murphy
29 17 Cuningham
30 15 Williamson
31 14 McGovern
32 13 Honey
33 13 O'Brien
34 10 Curnow, C
35 8 Setterfield
36 5 Parks
37 4 McDonald
38 2 Kemp
39 1 Durdin

 

[BlueTongue]

To be fair... some where in between too much love, and not enough love, is just the right amount of love

More than a pat on the back but don't boof him

 

[Ruckus]

Not exactly hard-hitting statistical analysis here, but if we draw a line at the bye, and tally the votes from the period following the announcement of the review, the top 10 looks like this:

86 Walsh
79 Weitering
53 Kennedy
51 Saad
48 Newman
47 McKay
47 Cripps
46 Silvagni
44 Martin
41 Curnow, E

 

[thylacine60]

Something I knocked together, a little hurriedly I must say, so please forgive any errors!

Hope the formatting is OK here...

01 183 Walsh
02 172 Weitering
03 118 McKay
04 112 Cripps
05 100 Curnow, E
06 97 Saad
07 86 Plowman
08 80 Jones
09 75 Betts
10 71 Silvagni
11 69 Fogarty
12 65 Docherty
13 63 Newman
14 59 Williams
15 56 Newnes
16 53 Kennedy
17 50 Martin
18 44 Pittonet
19 42 Owies
20 35 Stocker
21 34 Cottrell
22 34 Dow
23 28 Fisher
24 27 De Koning
25 27 Petrevski-Seton
26 26 Gibbons
27 23 Casboult
28 20 Murphy
29 17 Cuningham
30 15 Williamson
31 14 McGovern
32 13 Honey
33 13 O'Brien
34 10 Curnow, C
35 8 Setterfield
36 5 Parks
37 4 McDonald
38 2 Kemp
39 1 Durdin

found it King Rupert ........

 

[Ricky Mott]

Congratulations Sam and Jacob

 

[GordonBlue]

Something I knocked together, a little hurriedly I must say, so please forgive any errors!

Hope the formatting is OK here...

01 183 Walsh
02 172 Weitering
03 118 McKay
04 112 Cripps
05 100 Curnow, E
06 97 Saad
07 86 Plowman
08 80 Jones
09 75 Betts
10 71 Silvagni
11 69 Fogarty
12 65 Docherty
13 63 Newman
14 59 Williams
15 56 Newnes
16 53 Kennedy
17 50 Martin
18 44 Pittonet
19 42 Owies
20 35 Stocker
21 34 Cottrell
22 34 Dow
23 28 Fisher
24 27 De Koning
25 27 Petrevski-Seton
26 26 Gibbons
27 23 Casboult
28 20 Murphy
29 17 Cuningham
30 15 Williamson
31 14 McGovern
32 13 Honey
33 13 O'Brien
34 10 Curnow, C
35 8 Setterfield
36 5 Parks
37 4 McDonald
38 2 Kemp
39 1 Durdin

Surprising Stocker is so low.

 

[Ruckus]

Some interesting (?) tidbits from the count:

- our best performance of the year, based on the total number of votes awarded, was the round 20 win over the Saints (closely followed by the round 3 win against Freo)

- the worst was, perhaps not surprisingly, the round 22 thrashing at the hands of Port; the week earlier against the Suns came in a close second

- no player was awarded with a 'perfect' match score (a total of 16 votes from the four coaches) - Walsh came closest, with 15 awarded for his round 18 effort against the Pies.

- Walsh polled votes in all but one of the 22 games, the only to do so (missed out only for his 6 kick, 20 disposal game against the Giants in round 14); Weitering and Saad hit the scoreboard in all but two matches each.

- a special mention for Sam Docherty

15

Sam Docherty

Age

30

Ht

187cm

Wt

87kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

22.3

5star

K

15.1

5star

HB

7.2

4star

M

6.6

5star

T

2.4

4star

CL

1.1

3star

D

22.6

5star

K

16.0

5star

HB

6.6

4star

M

7.0

5star

T

0.6

1star

CL

0.4

3star

D

11.2

3star

K

6.0

3star

HB

5.2

4star

M

2.4

3star

T

1.4

4star

CL

0.6

3star

, who polled in every match he played this year

 

[jj1978]

That sole bad half Weiters played was during the period he temporarily switch to Windows OS and during that half bloody Windows decided it wanted to do a software update. After they took him back to the shop post that game he got reverted back to Linux and all began to function as normal.

 

[motleyblues]

Something I knocked together, a little hurriedly I must say, so please forgive any errors!

Hope the formatting is OK here...

01 183 Walsh
02 172 Weitering
03 118 McKay
04 112 Cripps
05 100 Curnow, E
06 97 Saad
07 86 Plowman
08 80 Jones
09 75 Betts
10 71 Silvagni
11 69 Fogarty
12 65 Docherty
13 63 Newman
14 59 Williams
15 56 Newnes
16 53 Kennedy
17 50 Martin
18 44 Pittonet
19 42 Owies
20 35 Stocker
21 34 Cottrell
22 34 Dow
23 28 Fisher
24 27 De Koning
25 27 Petrevski-Seton
26 26 Gibbons
27 23 Casboult
28 20 Murphy
29 17 Cuningham
30 15 Williamson
31 14 McGovern
32 13 Honey
33 13 O'Brien
34 10 Curnow, C
35 8 Setterfield
36 5 Parks
37 4 McDonald
38 2 Kemp
39 1 Durdin

Thanks for that

 

[bluerooster]

No it shows Ed is much better than some care to believe.

Spot on, some of the criticism of him is very unwarranted. He's a gun imo, also very happy for A Saad, some of his critics should watch his game and not listen to outside bs.