Toast John Nicholls Medal 2021 - Congratulations Sam Walsh

[bluerooster]

Plowmans form is reflective of this forum. Some people love him as some of the form he shows when he's great. Others hate him as some of the mistakes he has, that can be very costly at crucial times. I'm still not sure where I stand because his great is awesome but his brain fades kill me.

 

[Donnini]

Stats become even more interesting when you put games played and minutes played next to their votes.

Injuries really sent us to hell. Cunners got 17 votes from four games for example

 

[Aramari]

Something I knocked together, a little hurriedly I must say, so please forgive any errors!

Hope the formatting is OK here...

01 183 Walsh
02 172 Weitering
03 118 McKay
04 112 Cripps
05 100 Curnow, E
06 97 Saad
07 86 Plowman
08 80 Jones
09 75 Betts
10 71 Silvagni
11 69 Fogarty
12 65 Docherty
13 63 Newman
14 59 Williams
15 56 Newnes
16 53 Kennedy
17 50 Martin
18 44 Pittonet
19 42 Owies
20 35 Stocker
21 34 Cottrell
22 34 Dow
23 28 Fisher
24 27 De Koning
25 27 Petrevski-Seton
26 26 Gibbons
27 23 Casboult
28 20 Murphy
29 17 Cuningham
30 15 Williamson
31 14 McGovern
32 13 Honey
33 13 O'Brien
34 10 Curnow, C
35 8 Setterfield
36 5 Parks
37 4 McDonald
38 2 Kemp
39 1 Durdin

Votes / Games Average
w/60% TOG+ votes

Walsh 183/22 8.31
Weiter 172 / 22 7.81
McKay 118/19 6.2
Cripps 112/19 5.89
Silvagni 70 / 13 5.38

Kennedy 53 / 11 4.81
Doch 65 / 14 4.64
Cuners 17 / 3 4.64
Martin 50 / 11 4.54
Ed 100/22 4.54
Williams 59 / 13 4.53
Plow 86 / 19 4.52
Newman 63 / 14 4.5

Saad 97 / 22 4.41
Fogarty 69 / 16 4.31
Jones 80 / 19 4.21
OMac 4 / 0 4*

Pitt 44/13 3.38
Betts 75/19 3.94
Newnes 56 / 17 3.29
Honey 13 / 4 3.25
Owies 42 / 13 3.23

Cottrell 34 / 12 2.83
Gov 14 / 5 2.8
Fish 28 / 10 2.8
Gibbons 26 / 10 2.6
LOB 13 / 5 2.6
Charlie 10 / 4 2.5

SPS 27 / 11 2.45
Dow 34 / 14 2.43
TDK 27 / 12 2.25
Stocker 35 / 17 2.05
Murphy 20 / 10 2

Cas 23 / 13 1.77
Willo 15 / 11 1.36
Setters 8 / 8 1
Kemp 2 / 2 1
Parks 5 / 6 0.83
Durdin 1/2 0.5

Kennedy, Cuners OMac big value when played
Betts, Martin, Doch, Cottrell surprisingly high
Saad, Stocker surprisingly low

Only included games with 60% + TOG to avoid diluting average votes with sub and injury-ruined games. OMac broke this with 4 votes from his 49% TOG game

formatting is ****ed and gets *eder every time I try to fix it

 

[4thchicken]

IMO, Stocker should been top 10 (or at least very close to)

 

[MissBlueBagger93]

Big shout out to Pitto too for winning Best Clubman, awarded to "the player who lives Carlton’s values and goes above and beyond for his teammates and club".

Last year he won the Spirit of Carlton Award, for "the player who embodies the spirit of the Carlton Football Club on and off the field".

Played just 13 games each season, but is 2/2 for club awards in his first two years wearing the navy!

Love it!!

 

[Lace_Out]

Jones was in top 5 for me

Spot on.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[Ruckus]

Apologies if this gets compressed and looks a bit rough:

 

[CsBlue]

Did Larkey's game cost Weiters AA and B&F?

No. He had multiple games where he was off with the fairy’s. AA fullbacks don’t do that. Jones is our number one defender. Just without the hype.

 

[King Rupert]

Apologies if this gets compressed and looks a bit rough:

Brilliant thanks Ruckus

 

[gab213]

Big shout out to Pitto too for winning Best Clubman, awarded to "the player who lives Carlton’s values and goes above and beyond for his teammates and club".

Last year he won the Spirit of Carlton Award, for "the player who embodies the spirit of the Carlton Football Club on and off the field".

Played just 13 games each season, but is 2/2 for club awards in his first two years wearing the navy!

Love it!!

I really love the way he has embraced being a part of our Club, he shows a lot of enthusiasm and gives it everything he has. Expecting him to improve further next year as he gets more games under his belt when injury free . It's easy to forget that he is still a developing young player himself.

 

[Bletch]

I really love the way he has embraced being a part of our Club, he shows a lot of enthusiasm and gives it everything he has. Expecting him to improve further next year as he gets more games under his belt when injury free . It's easy to forget that he is still a developing young player himself.

Would love it if Pitto and TDK could function together. But at the moment it seems like it is one or the other. They are very different types, but as things stand, I don't see us playing both in the same team. Pitto is great at contested ball-ups. TDK is better at centre bounces. Neither particularly good around the ground. If that can improve, they could be a dynamic partnership.

 

[gab213]

Would love it if Pitto and TDK could function together. But at the moment it seems like it is one or the other. They are very different types, but as things stand, I don't see us playing both in the same team. Pitto is great at contested ball-ups. TDK is better at centre bounces. Neither particularly good around the ground. If that can improve, they could be a dynamic partnership.

I think they will end up playing in the same team more times than not. They haven't had much chance to develop a partnership due to one or the other being injured up to now.

 

[Aphrodite]

 

[BigBreakfast]

I think they will end up playing in the same team more times than not. They haven't had much chance to develop a partnership due to one or the other being injured up to now.

They can’t, surely. H, Charlie and two talls back make us too big to play both.