Player Watch Jonathon Marsh (Retired 2016)

[Saintly Viewed]

Why do people continue to perpetuate idle gossip.

Maybe it’s as simple as he had issues he felt holding him back from being an AFL footballer.
He moved back home.

Now he lives in Melbourne again taking up a VFL opportunity.

He’s no longer on our list, wish him well.

 

[jmac70]

Why do people continue to perpetuate idle gossip.

Maybe it’s as simple as he had issues he felt holding him back from being an AFL footballer.
He moved back home.

Now he lives in Melbourne again taking up a VFL opportunity.

He’s no longer on our list, wish him well.

I bumped the thread because there is still a chance he could return to the Black & White.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

I bumped the thread because there is still a chance he could return to the Black & White.

Do we want or need him now? We just recruited Roughead as a tall defender.

 

[jmac70]

Do we want or need him now? We just recruited Roughead as a tall defender.

I guess that will depend on injuries. All going well we don’t need him as we march relentlessly to our 16th flag.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Do we want or need him now? We just recruited Roughead as a tall defender.

Fair point.
If we re-picked him, do we see him as legitimate best 22 or even thereabouts?
Probably not.

Would you take over Madgen? That kind of depth.
I think that is what we’re talking about.

 

[Jelly Bean]

Was disappointed he left. He would have made us better the last two years, no question. He would have been a premiership player last year for instance having silenced Darling in the GF.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Fair point.
If we re-picked him, do we see him as legitimate best 22 or even thereabouts?
Probably not.

Would you take over Madgen? That kind of depth.
I think that is what we’re talking about.

Actually on what I have seen of Madgen, I would probably take Marsh ahead of him, though I would now prefer not to have either of them.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Was disappointed he left. He would have made us better the last two years, no question. He would have been a premiership player last year for instance having silenced Darling in the GF.

Not for mind.

Hill.
Over.

Injuries cruelled him.

 

[Kappa]

I guess that will depend on injuries. All going well we don’t need him as we march relentlessly to our 16th flag.

I think if he gets picked up it won't be with us, I don't think he has too many good memories at Collingwood. I hope he gets an opportunity somewhere though

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Actually on what I have seen of Madgen, I would probably take Marsh ahead of him, though I would now prefer not to have either of them.

Always need players in bottom group of your 45 or so players.

We moved on a couple of those last season.