Josh Caddy

[vinum coupe]

i agree that he should be traded, bit of a nothing player

slow, makes bad decisions, his overhead marking is good at times

seems to just be a b grade player

i'd be happy with a pick in the 30's

Ha ha ha ha

 

[Spazz Cat]

I said this a few years ago that he is not a mid. Doesn't have that mentality. He can play, though. Should we really be turfing out players when we spend so much time playing them in the wrong spot? Seems a great waste of player resources.

It would be a waste. He may not want to be a full time forward though, if not I'd trade.
Would want a lot better than a mid 30's pick though.

 

[Cursed Cat]

I remember debating Turbocat in round 1 as to Caddy's impact in that game; Turbo said he wanted to see more from Caddy, I thought he played pretty well with a couple of clearances and a couple of goals. Unfortunately that game probably represented his best effort for the year.
Doesn't win enough of the ball as a mid, doesn't kick enough goals as a forward.
Just needs to do a lot more.

 

[dazbroncos]

In need of a 06 type review IMO.

And he's not alone. Seems to not be able to run out games and lacks good decision making at times.

Can play - no doubt - but IMO is underperforming.

He, and his mates in that 50+ game category need a good bit of self review and personal WTFing to get back better next year.

Trading him is stupid - make him work harder and better - along with his pals.

Go Catters