Remove this Banner Ad

Josh Caddy

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Kimbo said:
Meaning they get Caddy, Kelly (both North connected :mad: ), and H?! :oops:
Click to expand...

Who knows. I'd have thought they'd need to add their own first rounder to the compo pick to get into the mini draft, the same way Adelaide did last year.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Kimbo said:
Interesting... Geelong possibly interested in mini-draft, with their compo pick the likely bait. Hmmm.

From the AFL website...
Click to expand...
Is there anything or anyone that hasn't been linked to Geelong? Rivers, Hamish, Caddy and now they want to buy into the mini-draft, how many bloody draft picks do they have?
 
"The Lions hold pick No.8 in the draft, while Fremantle, who currently enters the draft at pick No.16, would need to package players with its first selection, with the Giants seeking a ruckman and strong-bodied key defender."

.....Hello....
 
*chemist flashback*

Delany, McIntosh & pick 14 to GWS for their minidraft first pick.

McIntosh ontraded to Geelong, pick 15 to GWS.

Delaney stays at GWS & fulfils their strong key back, McIntosh gets to Geelong, we ignore Caddy and pick up Hogan/Martin/Kelly

*face explodes*

Seriously what, do we trade Mac or Keys to GWS to try to get a minidraft pick? 14 won't get it done. 14 & Mac probably won't. 14 & Delaney won't. 14, Mac and Delaney might do. They'd probably end up on-trading McIntosh for the Ablett compo & trade away their other minidraft pick.

What am I even talking about anymore?
 
Flawed Genius said:
*chemist flashback*

Delany, McIntosh & pick 14 to GWS for their minidraft first pick.

McIntosh ontraded to Geelong, pick 15 to GWS.

Delaney stays at GWS & fulfils their strong key back, McIntosh gets to Geelong, we ignore Caddy and pick up Hogan/Martin/Kelly

*face explodes*

Seriously what, do we trade Mac or Keys to GWS to try to get a minidraft pick? 14 won't get it done. 14 & Mac probably won't. 14 & Delaney won't. 14, Mac and Delaney might do. They'd probably end up on-trading McIntosh for the Ablett compo & trade away their other minidraft pick.

What am I even talking about anymore?
Click to expand...
Living up to your name tag!!:thumbsu:
 
Flawed Genius said:
*chemist flashback*

Delany, McIntosh & pick 14 to GWS for their minidraft first pick.

McIntosh ontraded to Geelong, pick 15 to GWS.

Delaney stays at GWS & fulfils their strong key back, McIntosh gets to Geelong, we ignore Caddy and pick up Hogan/Martin/Kelly

*face explodes*

Seriously what, do we trade Mac or Keys to GWS to try to get a minidraft pick? 14 won't get it done. 14 & Mac probably won't. 14 & Delaney won't. 14, Mac and Delaney might do. They'd probably end up on-trading McIntosh for the Ablett compo & trade away their other minidraft pick.

What am I even talking about anymore?
Click to expand...

Pictures please.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I don't even want a mini-draft pick, I was some instant gratification. Having to wait this long for the Duke is bad enough.
 
Would not mind picking up Kelly in the MD, it goes against logical thinking and in theory drafting for a skinny midfielder that we can't play until 2014 and might not hit his straps till around 2019 is the opposite of what we should be doing...

but imagine Round 1 2014, with McDonald and Kelly lining up as two BFNAAK's and two potential Elite players stepping into a (hopefully) top 4 side.. it's definitely a much better story then hiring a mercenary who is a shit bloke as displayed by his choosing Essendon :p
 
McIntosh, Delaney and pick 14 might get a mini draft pick but its a lot to give up for unproven talent.
 
Why are we giving up Delaney again?
 
Gee I'll be glad when Caddy gets to understand the layout of Arden Street and we can stop showing him around the joint every week.

Is he in for the CEO's position?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Tas said:
Why are we giving up Delaney again?
Click to expand...

A very valid question Tas, I will try and answer it. I feel that people felt that Delaney lacked feel for the game, and that he was being felt up by his opponents. I like the guy, has played f/all senior footy and is an aggressive S.O.B. I will be mighty pissed if he leaves, HMac I couldn't careless about. But Delaney should have played against the Eagles we needed his big body, Brad Scott ****ed up big time that day.
 
Horace said:
Gee I'll be glad when Caddy gets to understand the layout of Arden Street and we can stop showing him around the joint every week.

Is he in for the CEO's position?
Click to expand...

'Make it happen, Shack' has a nice ring to it.
 
naturally north said:
A very valid question Tas, I will try and answer it. I feel that people felt that Delaney lacked feel for the game, and that he was being felt up by his opponents. I like the guy, has played f/all senior footy and is an aggressive S.O.B. I will be mighty pissed if he leaves, HMac I couldn't careless about. But Delaney should have played against the Eagles we needed his big body, Brad Scott screwed up big time that day.
Click to expand...

Delaney would have been pants by the eagles as well. Defenders need the midfield to at least put up some token resistance so they have a hope in hell to contest.

I feel he is important to us, we should stop using Grima or Thompson as a full back. The other two are good enough to play on mediums if the opposition are lacking talls.
 
Tas said:
Delaney would have been pants by the eagles as well. Defenders need the midfield to at least put up some token resistance so they have a hope in hell to contest.

I feel he is important to us, we should stop using Grima or Thompson as a full back. The other two are good enough to play on mediums if the opposition are lacking talls.
Click to expand...


Dead right the midfield sets the tone.The Italians gave more resistence during the war than our mids at times during the year. I reckon Hawthorn will be sniffing around. Imagine if he ends up at a better side than ours?:mad:
 
naturally north said:
Dead right the midfield sets the tone.The Italians gave more resistence during the war than our mids at times during the year. I reckon Hawthorn will be sniffing around. Imagine if he ends up at a better side than ours?:mad:
Click to expand...

I think they picked up an impressive looking irish lad who they are probably hopeful of stepping up. They have been cursed with the Hay karma, since shafting us with Hay they have had dire problems with their key defenders, either constantly breaking down or not developing properly at their club.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom