- Joined
- Jul 24, 2003
- Posts
- 574
- Likes
- 0
- Location
- Perth
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Anything from WA
Thread starter
#1
I don't think i have seen a player more dissapointing this year than josh Carr. In my mind he is the new Mcmanus, Carr just can't kick and he has so many brain freezes a match it's scary. What has happened to him.
I reckon Josh is liable for more turnovers in the back half than any other player this year. I can't doubt his handpassing really, he hasn't had a chance to be really tested, although if you remember the Geelong game he handed the ball directly to ablett for their first goal. His kicking has been shocking, resulting in about 5-6 goals from kicking out from full back.
I think the problem is he is playing differently to how he played at port, at port he was the in and under player, and at freo he seems to be more of a reciever which he isn't.
Sadely, my list of 2 players i least want to get the ball is now 3.
In order of players i look away at when they get the ball is.
1. Mcmanus
2. Headland
3. Josh Carr
Am I the only person that thinks this?
I reckon Josh is liable for more turnovers in the back half than any other player this year. I can't doubt his handpassing really, he hasn't had a chance to be really tested, although if you remember the Geelong game he handed the ball directly to ablett for their first goal. His kicking has been shocking, resulting in about 5-6 goals from kicking out from full back.
I think the problem is he is playing differently to how he played at port, at port he was the in and under player, and at freo he seems to be more of a reciever which he isn't.
Sadely, my list of 2 players i least want to get the ball is now 3.
In order of players i look away at when they get the ball is.
1. Mcmanus
2. Headland
3. Josh Carr
Am I the only person that thinks this?
