hello fellow freo fans, i must say you've got to love the port and wcoast supporters that come in for a dig. The honest truth about j carr is he aint as good as port made out. He is basically a scraggy tagger that uses questionable tactics to negate his opponent. It was clear he was going last yr, thats why M williams made him a deputy VC to everyones surprise. The club also used dodgy tactics to try and keep him. When it was clear that none of this was going to work they boosted his image up, with m williams coming out saying what a champ he is, for no reason whatsoever.
Port fans always go on about the hard ball he would win, but if you take a look at ports final series last yr it was r james that was winning the hard ball not j carr. With r james out and struggling this yr, then port have also struggled.
And I aslo wouldnt worry about how you club has gone. The afl screwed up with you its pretty simple. After wcoast had too many concessions and dominated, they did the opposite with you and you've had to pick players up via the draft. Although, over the history your trading person whoever that is should be sacked. Port were given heaps of concessions, and if you take them out of the side like r james, tredrea, lade, dew, wilson etc theres a ton of them, they'd be struggling as well. The honest reality is if anyone is incompetent, its port they have had the players given to them and took four finals series to win after being easily the best home and away side. They have lost their opportunities, unlike brisbane. It is their culture of losing finals and choking under pressure that makes them criticise your side.
I would say whoever started the questioning of j carr in this thread is exactly right, i've seen quite a few games this yr and geelong esp was a terrible game by him. CC should go and j carr needs to get in there and be dirty like he was at port, it’s the only way he knows.