Recommitted Josh Kelly [will be a GIANT for life, has signed 8 year extension]

[Gigantic]

Check up on your Norf mates

 

[Lore]

Restricted free agent this year. He has a trigger for a long deal or something though doesn't he?

 

[Giant Pete]

Gone.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Kelly to north take 2

last chance to come home

 

[La Dispute]

Handy stack of players becoming FA's in 2021: Bont, Cripps, Merrett and Kelly. Underscores the quality of the 2013 draft.

A lot will come down to how GWS rebound this year. If they can launch into the top 4 I can see Kelly re-signing another short term deal, but the more likely scenario is they scrape into the 8 and he seeks greater pastures.

Going to be a hell of a lot of interest with a number of Vic clubs opening up a fair bit of cap space over the off-season. Also keen to see if he or Merrett receives the largest offer. Stylistically pretty similar players, of similar quality. (Kelly slightly better, Merrett much more durable)

 

[PMBangers]

Gone.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

For some reason I think J Kelly is damaged goods, and I hope Carlton stay away from throwing bundles of cash at him.
Think is body is not as durable as many think tBh

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

Will win a Brownlow next year.

 

[Orange Agent]

For some reason I think J Kelly is damaged goods, and I hope Carlton stay away from throwing bundles of cash at him.
Think is body is not as durable as many think tBh

Lol. The irony...

 

[Orange Agent]

Restricted free agent this year. He has a trigger for a long deal or something though doesn't he?

8 years and supposedly his option.

 

[Ash1337]

He'll be matched at any price so the RFA will be mute. Expect if north finish last and he nominates them. Pick 1 will be the price for sure. However I think he will probably go for a team contending.

 

[AFLOnline]

I’d love Kelly but realistically we probably don’t have the draft picks to offer for GWS for him.

 

[Colonial]

We will know early as supposedly the Giants need to be notified around mid season according to Matthews.

 

[Giant Pete]

We will know early as supposedly the Giants need to be notified around mid season according to Matthews.

When did he say that?

 

[Colonial]

When did he say that?

I can remember an interview before trade week.

Was either Matthews or McCartney on a podcast.
They said the deal was that Chook would advise the club either way fairly early.

Edit

Was McCartney

15min mark

‎AFL Trade Radio on Apple Podcasts

‎Sport · 2023

podcasts.apple.com

 

[Pykie]

He'll be matched at any price so the RFA will be mute. Expect if north finish last and he nominates them. Pick 1 will be the price for sure. However I think he will probably go for a team contending.

No he wont.

This isn't the Cameron situation.

The deal is $1m P.A for the next 8 years...….. GWS want that noose removed from their neck.

We are also far more likely to have an early pick in the PSD draft compared to Geelong this year with 16 other clubs ahead of them.


I think this is far more similar to the Treloar/Crouch situation than the Cameron one.


GWS probably have about 4-5 of the worst 10 contracts in the AFL on their books at the minute.


Depending how low GWS finish, Band 1 compo might be sufficient if they finish next season worse than this season. Especially in a stronger draft.

 

[Orange Agent]

No he wont.

This isn't the Cameron situation.

The deal is $1m P.A for the next 8 years...….. GWS want that noose removed from their neck.

We are also far more likely to have an early pick in the PSD draft compared to Geelong this year with 16 other clubs ahead of them.


I think this is far more similar to the Treloar/Crouch situation than the Cameron one.


GWS probably have about 4-5 of the worst 10 contracts in the AFL on their books at the minute.


Depending how low GWS finish, Band 1 compo might be sufficient if they finish next season worse than this season. Especially in a stronger draft.

Garbage, we have the money to pay him.

 

[Colonial]

No he wont.

This isn't the Cameron situation.

The deal is $1m P.A for the next 8 years...….. GWS want that noose removed from their neck.

We are also far more likely to have an early pick in the PSD draft compared to Geelong this year with 16 other clubs ahead of them.


I think this is far more similar to the Treloar/Crouch situation than the Cameron one.


GWS probably have about 4-5 of the worst 10 contracts in the AFL on their books at the minute.


Depending how low GWS finish, Band 1 compo might be sufficient if they finish next season worse than this season. Especially in a stronger draft.

What absolute rot.

 

[HirdsTheWord]

No he wont.

This isn't the Cameron situation.

The deal is $1m P.A for the next 8 years...….. GWS want that noose removed from their neck.

We are also far more likely to have an early pick in the PSD draft compared to Geelong this year with 16 other clubs ahead of them.


I think this is far more similar to the Treloar/Crouch situation than the Cameron one.


GWS probably have about 4-5 of the worst 10 contracts in the AFL on their books at the minute.


Depending how low GWS finish, Band 1 compo might be sufficient if they finish next season worse than this season. Especially in a stronger draft.

i very very VERY much doubt Kelly wants to go to North....

He will go to someone on the up or is already contending.

 

[Pykie]

i very very VERY much doubt Kelly wants to go to Norf....

He will go to someone on the up or is already contending.

More than likely.

But I very very VERY much doubt GWS wants Kelly for 8yrs @ $1m per season.

2028 is a long way away.

 

[Pykie]

Garbage, we have the money to pay him.

You might have it, but do you want the 8 years @ $1m?

 

[Colonial]

More than likely.

But I very very VERY much doubt GWS wants Kelly for 8yrs @ $1m per season.

2028 is a long way away.

You have no idea what the contract is.

 

[Pykie]

You have no idea what the contract is.

Are we playing this game now?

Because we don't have the contract in front of us we can't talk and speculate on it?

It's been widely reported by multiple journo's:

 

[Colonial]

Are we playing this game now?

Because we don't have the contract in front of us we can't talk and speculate on it?

It's been widely reported by multiple journo's:

View attachment 1016875


View attachment 1016876

Can speculate as much as you and we can want.

Saying it’s definitely a certain figure for a certain length says otherwise.

Journos yeah they are always in the ball. I have no doubt there is a sizeable contract sitting awaiting his signing.
Do I think it’s what you are saying? No.
Probably long term but closer to what he is on now (850k) than a million.

 

[Pykie]

Can speculate as much as you and we can want.

Saying it’s definitely a certain figure for a certain length says otherwise.

Journos yeah they are always in the ball. I have no doubt there is a sizeable contract sitting awaiting his signing.
Do I think it’s what you are saying? No.
Probably long term but closer to what he is on now (850k) than a million.

I don't think the money difference is necessary a huge factor.

It's the length of contract.

Are you disputing the 2029 contract end?

 

[Colonial]

I don't think the money difference is necessary a huge factor.

It's the length of contract.

Are you disputing the 2029 contract end?

I’m saying no one knows for sure.
Lots of talk. Have no doubt it’s long term but I can’t see another 8 years starting from ‘22.