Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

[dlanod]

So Boyd rec 1.6 mill of a 10.6 mill salary cap last year? 9 million left for the other 40 players?

It's better than that.

Using his figures:

2015 - ~$100k due to the rookie wage.
2018 to 2021 - $550k pa works out to $2.2m total.

$7m over seven years minus $2.3m over five of those years leaves Boyd earning $2.35m pa in 2016 and 2017.

Except:

"Annual salary figures released by the AFL show only six players were paid more than $1 million a year — up from four in 2016 — and none as much as Gillon McLachlan’s $1.7 million pay packet."

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...d/news-story/68d4d266b7631535d12e49b224d1df02

It still doesn't add up.

Edit: As much as I hate Barrett's "journalism", this seems more reasonable - https://www.triplem.com.au/sport/afl/news/damian-barrett-reveals-tom-boyds-extraordinary-2016-salary.

$1.7m last year leaves it at an average of $1.04m a year over 2017-2021. Even if this year was frontloaded at between $1.2m and $1.6m it still leaves it at an average of $900k-$1m a year for the rest of the deal.

 

[Wild Bill]

It's better than that.

Using his figures:

2015 - ~$100k due to the rookie wage.
2018 to 2021 - $550k pa works out to $2.2m total.

$7m over seven years minus $2.3m over five of those years leaves Boyd earning $2.35m pa in 2016 and 2017.

Except:

"Annual salary figures released by the AFL show only six players were paid more than $1 million a year — up from four in 2016 — and none as much as Gillon McLachlan’s $1.7 million pay packet."

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...d/news-story/68d4d266b7631535d12e49b224d1df02

It still doesn't add up.

End of the day posters on here wouldn't know how much is front or back ended. Its guess work and most likely wrong - most also try and portray the contacts in the most beneficial light.

They have 4 of their best 10 players out of contract next year. Can't see them is the ball park for Kelly or Lever.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Out of contract next year - Stringer, Macrae, Libba, Dahl, Wallis and Roughead. There goes your treasure chest.

Bont the year after

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Tug of war between Roos & Saints I believe.

Why would he pick Saints over North?

 

[Colonial]

Why would he pick Saints over North?

He may think he has a better opportunity playing finals as well as the big cash.

Before you get aggressive remember Treloar thought he was on a winner with the pies over the tigers.

In his opinion it might be the case.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[Roughies Boys]

Why would he pick Saints over North?

Don't have to play in Tasmania.

 

[Roughies Boys]

One team is gonna miss out & not hit any big fish they chase.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

He may think he has a better opportunity playing finals as well as the big cash.

Before you get aggressive remember Treloar thought he was on a winner with the pies over the tigers.

In his opinion it might be the case.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

No aggression here. Just asking the question.
Treloar still might be right too, both team haven't played finals yet.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Don't have to play in Tasmania.

Really? Thats the best you could come up with?
Didnt stop O'Meara and Mitchell.

 

[Roughies Boys]

Really? Thats the best you could come up with?
Didnt stop O'Meara and Mitchell.

Yeah well Hawthorn play their home games on the MCG not Etihad. Also Hawks are a very successful club. Kelly won't be at Hawthorn though

 

[Wild Bill]

He may think he has a better opportunity playing finals as well as the big cash.

Before you get aggressive remember Treloar thought he was on a winner with the pies over the tigers.

In his opinion it might be the case.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

After Boyd won a flag last year the opportunity to play finals would no longer be a major factor. The dogs went from basket case to premiers very quickly.

Also not so sure the Saints are a better chance to play finals this year or going forward anyway.

 

[Roughies Boys]

After Boyd won a flag last year the opportunity to play finals would no longer be a major factor. The dogs went from basket case to premiers very quickly.

Also not so sure the Saints are a better chance to play finals this year or going forward anyway.

I like Saints list on paper more than I do the Roos.

 

[Colonial]

After Boyd won a flag last year the opportunity to play finals would no longer be a major factor. The dogs went from basket case to premiers very quickly.

Also not so sure the Saints are a better chance to play finals this year or going forward anyway.

Im not saying its definate either (though personally i think they are on the up while north are heading down after a long period of being there abouts)

But kelly (if he even decides to go) may think they are and if the money is there then he may chose them.


Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

I like Saints list on paper more than I do the Roos.

Hawks offer you $1m a year over 9 years, Saints over you $1m over 6 years, where are you signing?

 

[Colonial]

Hawks offer you $1m a year over 9 years, Saints over you $1m over 6 years, where are you signing?

Depends on the fine print.



Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Im not saying its definate either (though personally i think they are on the up while north are heading down after a long period of being there abouts)

But kelly (if he even decides to go) may think they are and if the money is there then he may chose them.

Based on what?

 

[Donkey Chop]

I like Saints list on paper more than I do the Roos.

Mate the Saints just got smashed by the Dogs, who aren't exactly flying. They're still rebuilding. As was evident on the weekend their best players are still their oldies.

McCartin can't get a kick, Bruce is not a true forward. Half their backline will need replacing in the next 3 years.

And they don't have a decent ruck.

They're pretenders. They'll get found out very soon.

 

[JG22]

Mate the Saints just got smashed by the Dogs, who aren't exactly flying. They're still rebuilding. As was evident on the weekend their best players are still their oldies.

McCartin can't get a kick, Bruce is not a true forward. Half their backline will need replacing in the next 3 years.

And they don't have a decent ruck.

They're pretenders. They'll get found out very soon.

How are the best players the oldies? That being 2 players

 

[Roughies Boys]

I prefer Saints list...

Nathan Brown - Scott Thompson - ergh on both. Hugh Goddard seems like a better prospect than Hansen.
Jake Carlisle - Robbie Tarrant (atm Robbie Tarrant, but Jake is younger)
Seb Ross - Jack Ziebell - I like Seb Ross, but Ziebell has his own strengths.
Luke Dunstan - Ben Cunnington - Cunnington reminds me of Brad Sewell, Dunstan could do Cunningtons role & is younger.
Jack Steven - Trent Dumont - I'd take Steven any day of the weak.
Tom Hickey/Billy Longer - Todd Goldstein - Both Saints ruckman are younger & them verse Preuss is more a breakeven in my eyes.

Mason Wood, Jarrad Waite & Ben Brown vs
Josh Bruce, Tim Membrey & Paddy McCartin - Wood will be a very good footballer, but i have Saints infront.

Overall I think Kelly should pick Saints over Roos, as it's not about urgency to get that Premiership as he'll possibly get one this year, but he could join a very young Saint group & provide class & be with them for awhile with the midfield group which would be insane for years to come.

 

[Roughies Boys]

Mate the Saints just got smashed by the Dogs, who aren't exactly flying. They're still rebuilding. As was evident on the weekend their best players are still their oldies.

McCartin can't get a kick, Bruce is not a true forward. Half their backline will need replacing in the next 3 years.

And they don't have a decent ruck.

They're pretenders. They'll get found out very soon.

It's abit cute when Robbie Tarrant is 28, Lachie Hansen, Todd Goldstein all 28 also, Scott Thompson is 31 & Jarrad Waite 34.

Your spine is gonna lose some Key Defenders that hurts more than a HBF.

 

[JG22]

I prefer Saints list...

Nathan Brown - Scott Thompson - ergh on both. Hugh Goddard seems like a better prospect than Hansen.
Jake Carlisle - Robbie Tarrant (atm Robbie Tarrant, but Jake is younger)
Seb Ross - Jack Ziebell - I like Seb Ross, but Ziebell has his own strengths.
Luke Dunstan - Ben Cunnington - Cunnington reminds me of Brad Sewell, Dunstan could do Cunningtons role & is younger.
Jack Steven - Trent Dumont - I'd take Steven any day of the weak.
Tom Hickey/Billy Longer - Todd Goldstein - Both Saints ruckman are younger & them verse Preuss is more a breakeven in my eyes.

Mason Wood, Jarrad Waite & Ben Brown vs
Josh Bruce, Tim Membrey & Paddy McCartin - Wood will be a very good footballer, but i have Saints infront.

Overall I think Kelly should pick Saints over Roos, as it's not about urgency to get that Premiership as he'll possibly get one this year, but he could join a very young Saint group & provide class & be with them for awhile with the midfield group which would be insane for years to come.

This will go down well with the Roos fans

 

[Roughies Boys]

This will go down well with the Roos fans

I'm waiting for their offended responses. Completely laughable their ignorance of their own list.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

I prefer Saints list...

Nathan Brown - Scott Thompson - ergh on both. Hugh Goddard seems like a better prospect than Hansen. You forgot about Durdin.
Jake Carlisle - Robbie Tarrant (atm Robbie Tarrant, but Jake is younger)
Seb Ross - Jack Ziebell - I like Seb Ross, but Ziebell has his own strengths.
Luke Dunstan - Ben Cunnington - Cunnington reminds me of Brad Sewell, Dunstan could do Cunningtons role & is younger. Dunstan? the bloke who got dropped?
Jack Steven - Trent Dumont - I'd take Steven any day of the weak.
Tom Hickey/Billy Longer - Todd Goldstein - Both Saints ruckman are younger & them verse Preuss is more a breakeven in my eyes.

Mason Wood, Jarrad Waite & Ben Brown vs
Josh Bruce, Tim Membrey & Paddy McCartin - Wood will be a very good footballer, but i have Saints infront. Bruce cant get a game.

Overall I think Kelly should pick Saints over Roos, as it's not about urgency to get that Premiership as he'll possibly get one this year, but he could join a very young Saint group & provide class & be with them for awhile with the midfield group which would be insane for years to come.

Good effort though....

 

[Roughies Boys]

Good effort though....

Durdin? Who is that?

Dunstan for now can't get a game. They also have Nathan Freeman.

Bruce can't get a game for now.

 

[Donkey Chop]

I prefer Saints list...

Nathan Brown - Scott Thompson - ergh on both. Hugh Goddard seems like a better prospect than Hansen.
Jake Carlisle - Robbie Tarrant (atm Robbie Tarrant, but Jake is younger)
Seb Ross - Jack Ziebell - I like Seb Ross, but Ziebell has his own strengths.
Luke Dunstan - Ben Cunnington - Cunnington reminds me of Brad Sewell, Dunstan could do Cunningtons role & is younger.
Jack Steven - Trent Dumont - I'd take Steven any day of the weak.
Tom Hickey/Billy Longer - Todd Goldstein - Both Saints ruckman are younger & them verse Preuss is more a breakeven in my eyes.

Mason Wood, Jarrad Waite & Ben Brown vs
Josh Bruce, Tim Membrey & Paddy McCartin - Wood will be a very good footballer, but i have Saints infront.

Overall I think Kelly should pick Saints over Roos, as it's not about urgency to get that Premiership as he'll possibly get one this year, but he could join a very young Saint group & provide class & be with them for awhile with the midfield group which would be insane for years to come.

Hugh Goddard should be compared to Sam Durdin

Luke Dunston should be compared to Dumont

And you left out Daw, Garner, McDonald, Preuss, Higgins, Williams, Hrovat, Turner,
Vickers-Willis, Ryan Clarke, Jy Simpkin, Paul Ahern, Ben McKay

These are guys that Kelly would be playing with.

Probably even put Tarren Thomas into that conversation too.

s**t, don't forget Martin