Judd or Ablett?

[Hodgepodge]

Hodge 22 disposals, 8 inside 50s, 3 goals, 60% gametime
Judd 30 touches

Let's not even argue this shit, judd's underdone i know but that doesn't change the fact that at the moment he isn't ablett's lower intestine.

 

[Monkeyboy]

Hodge 22 disposals, 8 inside 50s, 3 goals, 60% gametime
Judd 30 touches

Let's not even argue this shit, judd's underdone i know but that doesn't change the fact that at the moment he isn't ablett's lower intestine.

An underdone Judd is about Ablett at present. 2 standout mids in the comp, with Judd showing us last week why he is number 1. Hawks supporters always seem hassled by the Juddmeister. Be happy with Hodgey! He has been a solid contributor.

 

[Skeppersap]

An underdone Judd is about Ablett at present. 2 standout mids in the comp, with Judd showing us last week why he is number 1. Hawks supporters always seem hassled by the Juddmeister. Be happy with Hodgey! He has been a solid contributor.

Hahahahahahhahaha,

If you are saying that Current Judd = Current Ablett, you lose all credibility.

Ablett is currently MUCH ore valuable than Judd.

 

[Power King]

They're both ridiculously skilled.

I'd happily swap thurstans for ablett, and lonie for judd, with both clubs.

Who is better? Really there is no difference to me. Outcome is biased toward ablett over the past season due to judd's injury, but it's obvious judd is getting back to his once supreme level.

It's like arguing over what's better - $100.00 and $100.10

____all difference when you're at the top

 

[Mean Muggin]

They're both ridiculously skilled.

I'd happily swap thurstans for ablett, and lonie for judd, with both clubs.

Who is better? Really there is no difference to me. Outcome is biased toward ablett over the past season due to judd's injury, but it's obvious judd is getting back to his once supreme level.

It's like arguing over what's better -$100.00 and $100.10

____all difference when you're at the top

I would go the $100.10 as opposed to -$100.

 

[Hodgepodge]

Hahahahahahhahaha,

If you are saying that Current Judd = Current Ablett, you lose all credibility.

Ablett is currently MUCH ore valuable than Judd.

it took the media 5 years to figure out Kouta was shit after his knee injuries, it'll take them 10 years to figure out that 08 judd might not be as good as 08 ablett.

 

[Claude Balls]

An underdone Judd is about Ablett at present. 2 standout mids in the comp, with Judd showing us last week why he is number 1. Hawks supporters always seem hassled by the Juddmeister. Be happy with Hodgey! He has been a solid contributor.

Geez you are such a loser! Change your damn profile to display who you really barrack for...

 

[Hodgepodge]

Geez you are such a loser! Change your damn profile to display who you really barrack for...

It's all too obvious, isn't it?

 

[walken79]

I can't believe this is even worth pondering for some.... Judd would barely make the top 20 at the minute- Gazza on the other hand is easily the best player in the league. Easily.

 

[Claude Balls]

It's all too obvious, isn't it?

Blatant... he must think it's a well concieved running gag or something. I'm not sure anyone finds it remotely funny though...

 

[Juddernaut08]

Blatant... he must think it's a well concieved running gag or something. I'm not sure anyone finds it remotely funny though...

I find it funny

 

[year of the cat]

Has Judd ever taken an overhead mark? Ablett has more strings to his bow.

 

[wce4premiership]

Has Judd ever taken an overhead mark? Ablett has more strings to his bow.

He has.

You're displaying your lack of knowledge about judd.

 

[Big Nasty]

He has.

You're displaying your lack of knowledge about judd.

And your displaying your obsession with Judd, and you need to get over the past.

 

[RhEF JC]

And your displaying your obsession with Judd, and you need to get over the past.

hahahahaha! yeah, you're right. That was a completely irrational post, based only on unrestricted passion.

 

[Hodgepodge]

He has.

You're displaying your lack of knowledge about judd.

I think i saw him take one, but it might have been a chest mark . . .

 

[DTHitman]

Present:
Ablett

Past (last 5 years when the player hit there prime, ablett is 2008):
I would take Cousins before Ablett and Judd ...
1. Cousins
2. Judd
3. Ablett

 

[DK#8]

Has Judd ever taken an overhead mark? Ablett has more strings to his bow.

Well it makes it hard when you struggle getting your hands above your head

 

[SA HAWK]

Over their careers so far - Judd.
Over the last 2 years - Ablett.

 

[Mean Muggin]

Can I change my vote to Ablett?

Wow.

 

[Makka]

After being at the game tonight and seeing Ablett in action I'd have to say Ablett. The guy is a freak and an amazing player! Absolutely took us apart!

 

[THE_GUN]

carreer thus far...........judd
last 2 years.......ablett
end of their carreers......................ablett

he is a more damageing player.

 

[kingyubbo]

Judd but if Ablett keeps growing like he does.... he'll surpass him in no time.

 

[TredreaWilbur]

Ablett at the moment. Judd for career sofar. Over their whole careers - way to early to tell, there both still young. Especially Judd, everyone seems to think he is past his prime. I still rate Judd over Ablett because Judd gets more contested possessions, has a huge engine and was playing and got awards before all this uncontested, backwards chipping, holding possession @#*! soft footy came along. Stats don't count for much these days honestly. I'm not taking anything away from Ablett - He should win the Bronwlow if he keeps up the way he is. But we should wait and see, Ablett has only broken out last year and this year.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Ablett now > Eagles Judd