-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Judd or Ablett?
- Thread starter Hodgepodge
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Ablett Jnr has reached Judd's level of dominance circa 2005-early 2007. Fantastic to watch, hopefully we can see Judd unrestricted and back in full flight next year.
ZosoCat
All Australian
ablett in current form.. judd over whole career
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
eaglechick79
Senior List
I think Judd in the early days was great, Judd of now still great, but showing signs of tiredness and of course injuries cause of how hard he has been at it over the years, BUT now, abett by far is def the best going around, actually his showing signs of being better then Judd long term, players cant even tackle abett!!
BUT with a father like his l guess you would expect greatness, l wonder if little baby abett (if he comes back!) will be as good!!
BUT with a father like his l guess you would expect greatness, l wonder if little baby abett (if he comes back!) will be as good!!
NewBabyBombaz
Debutant
Judd's lightyears ahead of the next best player in the AFL. The guy is a machine. Opposition routinely need to rotate 3-4 players off him, because there is just no one in the AFL that can go with Judd for 4 quarters. Selwood went with Judd for about 60% of the game V Weagles and almost collapsed with exhaustion in the last quarter. Remember also judd is only at about 70% of his usual fitness level at the moment, and it terms of midfielder development has a lot more unfulfilled potential, which we'll no doubt see after some coaching from Ratten, Bradley and Greg Williams. A Superstar.
Welsh played on him all game, absolutely killed him, yeh boy
Xsess
Norm Smith Medallist
Cousins was(is?) better than both of them.
Because he maintained a level of excellence at or about Ablett's last two years for over a decade.
Judd maintained a similar level for about 4-5 seasons.
Cousins 13 great years,
Judd 4-5 great years,
Ablett 2 great years (but the most potential to add to that indefinately..)
Because he maintained a level of excellence at or about Ablett's last two years for over a decade.
Judd maintained a similar level for about 4-5 seasons.
Cousins 13 great years,
Judd 4-5 great years,
Ablett 2 great years (but the most potential to add to that indefinately..)
mate you can't count that. judd was clearly not himself after the headclash, in fact even an hour after the game he was still very groggy. had that incident not happened, he would have torn you blokes a new one just like he did last time, except this time we would have won.
eaglechick79
Senior List
So are you saying that Judd is the different btn you winning and lossing? last i check carlton had more then one player
Ablett is playing some unbelievable football, might actually have to go with him.
Never thought I would see a midfielder better than Judd come around so quickly, the amount of clearances he wins, amount of goals he kicks and sets up and the amount of times he sidesteps his way past tackles is unbelievable.
Never thought I would see a midfielder better than Judd come around so quickly, the amount of clearances he wins, amount of goals he kicks and sets up and the amount of times he sidesteps his way past tackles is unbelievable.
So are you saying that Judd is the different btn you winning and lossing? last i check carlton had more then one player
i'm quite happy to admit we would only have won 2 or 3 games this year without judd.
and against essendon when we hit the led in the last quarter judd would have helped us big time to keep the lead, especially considering how well he played agaisnt you blokes last time when he was less match fit than he is now.
eaglechick79
Senior List
WOW l have to admit im shocked anyone would admit to their team being a one man band, but what is more shocking to me here, is Carlton (as much as it kills me to say!) actually have some good younger players coming through, you'd expert that being down the bottom for many years, but your list isn't bad, and l go back to saying again there is not just one player out there winning games for you!
How many other Carlton supporters believe Judd is the only reasons your winning again?
WOW l have to admit im shocked anyone would admit to their team being a one man band, but what is more shocking to me here, is Carlton (as much as it kills me to say!) actually have some good younger players coming through, you'd expert that being down the bottom for many years, but your list isn't bad, and l go back to saying again there is not just one player out there winning games for you!
How many other Carlton supporters believe Judd is the only reasons your winning again?
you're misinterpreting what i am saying. i never took any credit away from the rest of the players. against port adelaide, there were probably 10 players who if they weren't playing we wouldn't have won. but judd has been the ost important this year. when we were losing to melbourne, he brought us back into the game and dominated there onwards i don't know if someone else could have done that. against port, he was our best player and probably kept us in it untl 3/4 time. against west coast, when they came to within 3 points fromt hat point on he willed himself like i've never seen before and won every contested ball or aat least was involved in them and then passed off the winning goal to bryce gibbs. that's 3 games i don't think we would have won if he hadn't have played in. and don't forget, him getting most of the attention frees up the rest of our onballers to play better, if he wasn't there they'd all be getting much closer attention and wouldn't be playing as well as they have. i don't mean to take any credit away from our younger players who have been fantastic this year, but judd has been the difference in at least 3 games this year imo.
can not blame them really, just trying to get their million and a half dollars worth of value out of him in every possible way.
ha ha ha I said this last year and every1 laughed and said no way!!!
now you are saying ablett is much better like i said!!!
look here
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=351974
now you are saying ablett is much better like i said!!!
look here
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=351974
that's not true. i can admit that ablett at geelong is better than ablett at carlton. but i still think judd at west coast was better than ablett, why would i even care? what judd did at west coast did nothing for me all i care about is what he's done at carlton, and i think it's pretty obvious he hasn't done as much as ablett has for geelong. going forward, i would still prefer judd because i think if he can ever get full power back in his body he will again be head and shoulders above the rest of the comp.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Ablett easily... in rare form, surely it has to subside a bit for a few weeks, but geez he is exciting.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #96
Judd is now on
$2495 per possession
$84898 per goal
I doubt Ablett would be on that much, mostly because his output is much more.
$2495 per possession
$84898 per goal
I doubt Ablett would be on that much, mostly because his output is much more.
hawks_legends
Club Legend
Ablett for me by a bit.
Should add that Judd's been an outstanding captain this year. Leads from the front and is a brilliant role model for the Blues very large developing top-shelf talent pool.
He lead West Coast that well
but I do agree his on field leadership is great.
dylan_mike
Team Captain
Yep, Abblett at the moment. Abblett is a star. But probably a little unfair comparison at the moment. The 2 in form Midfileders at the moment are Cooney and Abblett.
Hodge shits on both of them!
