Judd Vs Chapman

[Murph is baby Judd]

Judd has done nothing off his own boot, or on his own back.

Is there an end of season award for worst comment of the year on bigfooty?
I'm willing to chip in for a giant wooden spoon

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Done nothing off his own boot???? You know nothing. One of the most idiotic comment imaginable. We all have our bias's but please don't talk shit.

What I'm saying, for the simple of us out there, is that he is not the only bloke out there doing any work. He has a raft of performing high draft picks helping him out, Gibbs/Murphy/Walker is 3 premium picks playing like them alone.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Today was the aboriginal stars, but if you bothered to take your head out of your rear end and actually watch the blues play then maybe you could talk.

Ah the classic 'watch a game' response.

Judd won the game in sydney earlier this year off his own boot

Murphy, Scotlnd and Curnow all had less touches but were as or more effective. Betts 4 goals probably helped, did Judd provide them all on a platter? It's nice to say 'x won it off his own boot' but as I said before, it's an over simplification of the game.

games against the swans in the final last year would have been a blowout if judd didnt play.

Prevented blowout, nice.

He has been the difference in many carlton games since he has come on board the last 3 years.

And Ablett's efforts went a long way to winning Geelong games many times as well. Plenty of times he was the only one who looked like he was switched on. Judd is not alone in these things.

 

[Bring back Moloney]

Is there an end of season award for worst comment of the year on bigfooty?
I'm willing to chip in for a giant wooden spoon

He's trying to point out that it's not JUST Chris Judd that has improved Carlton. They have numerous quality players that have evolved since 06-07!

He's actually saying that Carlton have a decent list. I find it weird how many Carlton fans are basically calling themselves a 1 man team!!??

 

[bluepride]

Why is this thread dragging on.

Chapman is a class below Judd, its pretty simple.

 

[pharoah]

Ah the classic 'watch a game' response.

well do you bother to watch the games these days or just sit on big footy all day talking dribble??

Murphy, Scotlnd and Curnow all had less touches but were as or more effective. Betts 4 goals probably helped, did Judd provide them all on a platter? It's nice to say 'x won it off his own boot' but as I said before, it's an over simplification of the game.

I never implied judd won every game off his own boot, rather his influence with the blues is far greater than abletts at geelong or gold coast.

Prevented blowout, nice.



And Ablett's efforts went a long way to winning Geelong games many times as well. Plenty of times he was the only one who looked like he was switched on. Judd is not alone in these things.

Funny thing ablett couldnt win a norm smith from 3 grand final outings, but go back to abletts first couple of seasons and you wont see him breaking packs open the way judd has.
By the way the thread is judd or chapman in the preferred team.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Funny thing ablett couldnt win a norm smith from 3 grand final outings

Meaningless. Judd won one that he didn't deserve.

but go back to abletts first couple of seasons and you wont see him breaking packs open the way judd has.

All Ablett's are late developers, he was a small forward with great skills and agility who drifted in and out of games like all young small forwards do. Now he does everything Judd can do and more.

By the way the thread is judd or chapman in the preferred team.

I'll take that as a backpedal.

 

[pharoah]

Thats your opinion, the umpires viewed judd best on ground.
He did deserve it.

Meaningless. Judd won one that he didn't deserve.

Ablett is not as fast or adaptable as judd, secondly judd has been hampered by injury more so than not, ablett hasnt had the injuries just yet.

All Ablett's are late developers, he was a small forward with great skills and agility who drifted in and out of games like all young small forwards do. Now he does everything Judd can do and more.



I'll take that as a backpedal.

Take it as you like.