JUDD will return to the EAGLES after Carlton

[Bluebear]

Look at Melbourne Forum they have a Zero Troll thats what we need here someone to clean out all the troll threads give em one condition no saying nasty things about the blues this would be a better place to post messages with out crap from trolls (Oposition supporters)

Here lies the answer.

It's not that they have a tought stance on trolls........it's because no-one cares enough about them to bother.

In some ways the high percentage of trolls on our board should be viewed as a sign of respect.......that they so oppenly want to disrespect us........if you get what I mean.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Look at Melbourne Forum they have a Zero Troll thats what we need here someone to clean out all the troll threads give em one condition no saying nasty things about the blues this would be a better place to post messages with out crap from trolls (Oposition supporters)

Where do you think that forum got their zero tolerance policy from? The Carlton forum has more infractions than any other team forum because we have been trolled more. Sure our on and off field performances have provided much ammunition but we have needed to be diligent.

If you haven't noticed the moderating around here despite the massive amount of infractions then I guess we are always doing our job with a minimum of fuss.

We do leave trolling posts up even after infracting on most occasions. Gives all of you would-be-dogs a pussy to toy with.

 

[Dramoth]

Are you stupid? He said he came back to Melbourne to be closer to his family/friends. What happens if he does something which makes everyone start hating him? Or he does something which the media crucifies him over and he wants to leave Melbourne? How many players in other sports have said I'll never leave the club then 1 year later they're gone? And this is 5 years we're talking about. Yes the person who started the thread has given no reasons as to why Judd will return to WC in 2009 but to say it wont happen 100% must mean your name is Chris Judd.

The only thing that could make the media crucify him in Melbourne would be if he was caught knocking off one of his team mates wives... but then again... he has twigg's and I think that he might be more worried about the rest of the team trying to knock her off

As for your comment about the seagull players... we dont have them at Carlton... They come, fall in love with the place and want to stay forever...

 

[audas]

Where do you think that forum got their zero tolerance policy from? The Carlton forum has more infractions than any other team forum because we have been trolled more. Sure our on and off field performances have provided much ammunition but we have needed to be diligent.

If you haven't noticed the moderating around here despite the massive amount of infractions then I guess we are always doing our job with a minimum of fuss.

We do leave trolling posts up even after infracting on most occasions. Gives all of you would-be-dogs a pussy to toy with.

I enjoy the trolls, its the suckers fishing on the bridge that get me.

 

[Dramoth]

haha on the way to the top ...whos the one dreamin now?

well... I'll keep dreaming and thinking of flag number 17...

what a pity that you can only dream of flag #2 and spoon #27 (isnt it?)

 

[parrot]

...., you wont know every single detail of ALL the reasons why he left...

The MAIN reason Judd left was to escape the Weagles rampant Drug Culture. That was very very obvious, and many people were talking about him leaving for that very reason at the start of Season 2007. When a premiership Captain refuses to re-commit to his Club and the start of the season, right in the middle of the exposure of a massive drug-scandal cover-up at Weagleland, the writing is on the wall. Your soul-less regional franchise is a pathetic mess, and has tarnished the reputation of our great game. We should think twice about allowing such regional Tack-on-Clubs into our competition in the future. In hindsight one Freagle team was enough.

 

[parrot]

haha on the way to the top..

26 spoons, decade and decades of AFL/VFL handouts, former Saints administrators slugging it out in court, and now selling your heart and soul in search of the Frankston Poker Machine Dollar. I guess you view that as "success".

 

[sydney eagle]

The MAIN reason Judd left was to escape the Weagles rampant Drug Culture. That was very very obvious, and many people were talking about him leaving for that very reason at the start of Season 2007. When a premiership Captain refuses to re-commit to his Club and the start of the season, right in the middle of the exposure of a massive drug-scandal cover-up at Weagleland, the writing is on the wall. Your soul-less regional franchise is a pathetic mess, and has tarnished the reputation of our great game. We should think twice about allowing such regional Tack-on-Clubs into our competition in the future. In hindsight one Freagle team was enough.

Do you have any evidence of this, or is it just what you would like to think ? Has anyone come out and said that that was why Judd left ? The fact that Carlton offerred him a lot of money wouldn't have had anything to do with it would it ? It is easy for you to convince yourself of any untruth that you might like, but the rest of us would like some evidence.

 

[parrot]

... Has anyone come out and said that that was why Judd left ? The fact that Carlton offerred him a lot of money wouldn't have had anything to do with it would it ? It is easy for you to convince yourself of any untruth that you might like, but the rest of us would like some evidence.

Everyone knows why he left your pathetic drug-infested mess of a Club. He hated the Drug Culture. He wasn't going to say that publicly of course, for obvious reasons, but everyone knows that was the true reason, in unofficial circles at least. This drug problem has been going on for a long time at Weagleland, as has the cover-up, and that is the real issue. The Judd departure should be a wake-up-call for the Weagles. You only have yourselves to blame.

 

[Bluebear]

Do you have any evidence of this, or is it just what you would like to think ? Has anyone come out and said that that was why Judd left ? The fact that Carlton offerred him a lot of money wouldn't have had anything to do with it would it ? It is easy for you to convince yourself of any untruth that you might like, but the rest of us would like some evidence.

Speaking of which, you have some evidence that money was the issue?

Evidence he signed for money - your opinion.
Evidence he left due to culture - Kerr drunken assaults on taxis, Ben Cousins - all of it, Flecther "tired and emotional" in Las Vegas, Gardiner and the underworld connections................geez......can't see why he'd want to distance himself from that.........yep, you're right......silly of us to suggest it really.

I'll take our "lack of evidence" about your club culture, and Judd's timing, vs your assertions about his reasons for leaving anyday.

BTW, how's the inquiry into your clubs disgraceful drug culture going?

 

[SS_Fury]

norman, angwin....pot kettle black

We can to and fro all day like kids: but the fact remains we are all speculating...my OPINION is that we are ALL right and it ALL had a bit to do with it. Money, 'culture' etc etc.
Tack on club eh parrot? keyboard warrior on your own board arent you

 

[parrot]

...
Evidence he left due to culture - Kerr drunken assaults on taxis, Ben Cousins - all of it, Flecther "tired and emotional" in Las Vegas, Gardiner and the underworld connections................geez......can't see why he'd want to distance himself from that.........yep, you're right......silly of us to suggest it really...

You forgot to add in the Weagles players caught on Fed Police tape, making deals with their drug dealer. One player actually expressed concern that drugs he might purchase would get stolen from the Weagles change rooms. It was unbelievable stuff. I still can't believe Cousins played in 2007, without any penalty, and his drug problem clearly not being addressed properly. It was a disgrace.

 

[Bluebear]

norman, angwin....pot kettle black

We can to and fro all day like kids: but the fact remains we are all speculating...my OPINION is that we are ALL right and it ALL had a bit to do with it. Money, 'culture' etc etc.
Tack on club eh parrot? keyboard warrior on your own board arent you

Norman and Angwin?

Yep......good comparison.

You may as well compare the money I owe my brother to the National deficit.

Yes........they are both drug related..........but as for a culture?

Tell me, how much did Judd get offerred by us, and how did that compare to what the other "suitors" or even yourself offerred?

 

[parrot]

norman, angwin....pot kettle black.

Um. Angwin was booted straight away. ONE strike and out. Norman was given one more chance, and didn't re-offend. The Blues own drug policy, is much much harsher than the AFL's. The Weagles seem to have a 20+ strike and we'll still ignore policy for the past 5 years. Just incredible.

 

[SS_Fury]

we actually never offered him nor paid him what any suitors were asking

tell me do you know the culture of WCE or are you going by media-fed stories that somehow all the players are crackheads? If you listen to the vic parents of our kids they openly come out and defend the wce saying the media is beating it up out of proportion. Just look at Hansens and Selwoods parents. Mrs selwood is exstatic that Scott was drafted there.....if our culture is so bad, why is she so happy?

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

we actually never offered him nor paid him what any suitors were asking

tell me do you know the culture of WCE or are you going by media-fed stories that somehow all the players are crackheads? If you listen to the vic parents of our kids they openly come out and defend the wce saying the media is beating it up out of proportion. Just look at Hansens and Selwoods parents. Mrs selwood is exstatic that Scott was drafted there.....if our culture is so bad, why is she so happy?

how much more evidence is needed. do you live under a rock or something...

 

[Bluebear]

we actually never offered him nor paid him what any suitors were asking

Which was? Put a number to it.

tell me do you know the culture of WCE or are you going by media-fed stories that somehow all the players are crackheads?

Yes......the inquiry led by a former judge that is currently going on is a "media beat up".
The police tapes were a "beat up"
Cousins running from a booze bus is a "beat up"
Cousins being sacked by the club and Chad Flecthers near death experience are all "beat ups".

If you listen to the vic parents of our kids they openly come out and defend the wce saying the media is beating it up out of proportion. Just look at Hansens and Selwoods parents. Mrs selwood is exstatic that Scott was drafted there.....if our culture is so bad, why is she so happy?

Yes......because parents are always the first to know what their late teen/early 20 y.o. sons are doing.

When Judd signed with the club he said:

“I’m not big into pizzazz,” Judd said. “I think there was an article calling me and Bec the Posh and Becks [Victoria and David Beckham] of Melbourne, and that’s really not us.

“I want to play my footy, I want to train hard, contribute as much as I can to the footy club and other than that, you know, I don’t want to be a rock star.”

Pizzaz and Rock stars? Who would he be talking about?
Any ideas? Hmmmm.....not referring to the "rock star" status of WCE players in Perth is it?

and now at a club function he has said

He basically said he was really glad to get out of WCE, especially now that the investigation is going down over there. I stood next to him during the speeches...and he kept shifting his feet, and doing groin stretches, and at one point had to sit down. Let's hope the groin gets itself settled! He said he'd be right to play at around the 4th practice match.

Are we done?

 

[SS_Fury]

hahaha..you guys really are reaching with your arguments....i think you need to take your eyepatch off and take a look from both eyes
But alas im done trying to reason with carlton supporters on their board...its like trying to tell the rest of the clubs your a premiership threat: a bit of a joke really....a dead argument...till 2008

 

[Bluebear]

hahaha..you guys really are reaching with your arguments....i think you need to take your eyepatch off and take a look from both eyes

Wow, our arguements were so bad that you completely fail to make one?

You've been owned here - it's been two months since he signed with us......get over it.

 

[parrot]

hahaha..you guys really are reaching with your arguments....i think you need ...

Here's the deal. You've lost Judd and Cousins because of a your rampant endemic drug culture, and are left with a one-paced, mid-range-talent midfield group, overflowing with defensive midfielders. Suck it up, and move on.

 

[SS_Fury]

owned? dont make me laugh...i could make zillions of arguments against your train of thought but like i said...your board, thus not wasting my time.

 

[Sainters08]

At least we know what it's like to be at the top. What was that about dreaming?

its ok u wont be there anytime soon..let alone the top8

 

[Bluebear]

owned? dont make me laugh...i could make zillions of arguments against your train of thought but like i said...your board, thus not wasting my time.

Pfft.......pathetic.

"I could make a really good arguement if I wanted to"............

This is more embarrassing than the WCE poster who put this thread up............

You claim he left for money - provide some evidence (as you asked for)

I have provided Judd's own words as evidence, and instead of addressing these points you walk out with:
"I could make zillions of arguements but don't want to"..............
credibility zero
Owned - 100%

 

[SS_Fury]

if that helps you sleep at night mate
Ill give you an argument without bias...just come to the WC board and all will be fair i swear
were you hugged as a child? too much perhaps?

 

[Bluebear]

if that helps you sleep at night mate
Ill give you an argument without bias...just come to the WC board and all will be fair i swear
were you hugged as a child? too much perhaps?

Start a thread and I'll have a look.

I expect you to tell me, with evidence, the details of Chriss Judd leaving for Money, and how his leaving had nothing to do with the current state of play at the WCE despite his own comments indicating that this is the case.

Honestly, you can post it all here mate. Keep it civil and stick to the points there won't be an issue.

As for the personal comments about being hugged too much.........not sure what you're on, but if that's an example of the intelligence of your responses then maybe you shouldn't reply.

Your choice. Reply here with intelligence and we can talk.
Run to your own board and start a thread (post here to let me know you have), or just continue to post like you have.......all bark and no bite.