Judd -wtf?

[Mario Speedwagon]

How the **** do you get BOG when your team loses by 9 goals? How the **** do you still get votes when a hack like McPhee towels you up? Whatever little credibility this stupid & pointless award had left was well and truly erased once and for all tonight. Disgraceful.

The only thing good about the result was the look on Eddie's face...and the hope that it's an omen for raging favourites from Collingwood....

 

[RichoRox12]

Couldn't agree more.

I have never been so angry watching the Brownlow, but tonights was a joke. Once again shows how incompetent the umpires have been all season.

And Rebecca, eat a donut FFS - in fact, have Coxy shove it down your throat.

 

[Simmonds2Hislop]

Apparently you don't need good foot skills to poll well.

Just look at Tuck getting the 3 vs the Crows.




This was worse than the Cooney debacle.

 

[ELWOOD1980]

Couldn't agree more.

I have never been so angry watching the Brownlow, but tonights was a joke. Once again shows how incompetent the umpires have been all season.

And Rebecca, eat a donut FFS - in fact, have Coxy shove it down your throat.

bahahahaha very fuuny

 

[ata33cro]

Couldn't agree more.

I have never been so angry watching the Brownlow, but tonights was a joke. Once again shows how incompetent the umpires have been all season.

And Rebecca, eat a donut FFS - in fact, have Coxy shove it down your throat.

Rebecca could barely move in that corset. She probably didn't eat anything tonight.

 

[L_J_T]

Abomination of a count, so ****ing pissed off I turned it off as soon as he got the lead and couldn't lose. **** listening to his ****ing suck arse speech.

 

[Richm0ndrule]

Swan not winning and Eddies face =

 

[nufan_tigers]

I'd rather have had Swan win...

Judd is the AFL's golden child tho... he probably got three votes for that elbow on pav in the dockers game... he also gets votes for having a good pre-game dump... oh and that shit game he played was worthy of votes coz he tore through the banner really well...

Brownlow is now a joke, the players MVP award has more prestige these days

 

[jihg]

I got home from work after the count was over and my 8 year old son informed that Judd didn't deserve to win funny an eight year old could see it but the umpires couldn't.

 

[Tassie27]

I started watching from Round 12 onwards. When I switched it on I couldn't believe the leaderboard.

 

[TIAGRA]

I see it more as Swan and colonwood copping the first of two major reamings in a week.

 

[Wally Matera]

I see it more as Swan and colonwood copping the first of two major reamings in a week.

Funny how much we think alike. When l saw the result, l almost laughed my head off, purely because l just didnt want Swan to win it.

Gold, pure gold. I didnt care who won it, so long as Swan and that make-up wearing p oofda didnt.

 

[TIAGRA]

OER

Like Bart Simpson once said,"You can see the moment his heart actually breaks"

****in gold

 

[smasha]

..and people have a go at me for bagging the umps.

Swan deserved it.

Judd just plays in a team full of spuds.

Made me spew up him and his trophy girl.

Pass me the bucket please.

 

[_RT_]

In an unrelated story, the Umpires Association announced that they are going green with Visy Recycling replacing OPSM as their sponsor.

 

[captain blood 17]

..and people have a go at me for bagging the umps.

Swan deserved it.

Judd just plays in a team full of spuds.

Made me spew up him and his trophy girl.

Pass me the bucket please.

Agree. The prick smashes Pavlic in the face, and gets nothing. Swan can feel ripped off. Best player this year by the length of the street. Are they making up for the year when Deisel should have won the medal and Wanganeen got it??

 

[Heisenberg_]

How Swan was deemed to only have two BOG games is beyond me.

 

[JRD_312]

The Brownlow award was definitely the midfielders' award. I didn't see any forwards or defenders in the top ten. Also, reputation and fame is more important towards winning a Brownlow than hard consistent effort. On the other hand, seeing Ed's disappointed and round face was golden.

 

[wart101]

The Brownlow award was definitely the midfielders' award. I didn't see any forwards or defenders in the top ten. Also, reputation and fame is more important towards winning a Brownlow than hard consistent effort. On the other hand, seeing Ed's disappointed and round face was golden.

HAHA - exactly, this is why i don't care about the award, it is probably tainted aswell, how easy would it be to rig the award, TBH IMO it's a joke!!!

And eddie is a piece of shit, woul dlove to see him in a dark ally, i wouldn't kill him but i would def give him a black eye for the tv cameras LOL

 

[Googstar]

To be fair Judd deserved it more. He & Bec were the ones prepared to "help" the Umps out in the changerooms after the game, where as Swannie wasn't.

 

[Final Siren]

Swan not winning and Eddies face =

I wouldn't have minded Swan winning it, but Eddie's HULK SMASH face was awesome.

 

[the ranger]

Positives:
The gutless thug didn't win
Eddie's face
Hopefully the start of a disappointing week for the maggots
Judd's speech

Negatives:
Carlton supporters with something to boast about
Voting made little sense
MRP decided the award by not giving Judd weeks for smashing Pavlich's face

 

[Barnzy]

Worst winner since Wowodein and Cooney (in front of Ablett in 2008).

Swan and Ablett clearly the best 2 players for the year. I would've had Goddard and Hodge 3rd and 4th and neither did that well in the voting either.

Judd is just an umpires love child, similar to Goodes who was quietly racking up the votes too. Does every year. No influence on the Freo match, 2 votes. Team loses by nearly 10 goals, 3 votes. How did he off for elbowing Pavlich in the face and splitting him open too?

Hate Swan or not he was jibbed. Don't think he will ever win a brownlow after the last 2 years. Was very good last year, this year it was one of the most dominant individual years I've ever seen.

 

[RichoRox12]

Worst winner since Wowodein and Cooney (in front of Ablett in 2008).

Swan and Ablett clearly the best 2 players for the year. I would've had Goddard and Hodge 3rd and 4th and neither did that well in the voting either.

Judd is just an umpires love child, similar to Goodes who was quietly racking up the votes too. Does every year. No influence on the Freo match, 2 votes. Team loses by nearly 10 goals, 3 votes. How did he off for elbowing Pavlich in the face and splitting him open too?

Hate Swan or not he was jibbed. Don't think he will ever win a brownlow after the last 2 years. Was very good last year, this year it was one of the most dominant individual years I've ever seen.

Spot on, my thoughts exactly. And Matthew Boyd.

Gahhh I am still SO angry!! I'm p1ssed off because I have lost so much faith in our game recently, it's actually quite depressing.

The game is supposed to evolve in a good way but it just doesn't seem to be happening.

 

[Spielvogel]

until this year i had forgotten why i hated collingwood so much.

i was happy as long as someone from collingwood didnt get it.