Judd

[Brad Pearce]

 

[parrot]

Murph, Gibbs and Judd in the midfield?

 

[RTBB]

Ohh, as I clicked the reply tab, the pic froze on the carlton jumper, looked great

But Judd will play atleast the next 5 years for West Coast.

 

[btdg]

You'd at least be putting the feelers out now if you were a Carlton recruiting manager. Until he signs on the dotted line, he's a chance to come home.

Great idea, whoever started that 'Judd wants to come home' rumour in the newspapers. Even if its untrue, it might just put the thought into his mind. If 2007 doesn't quite go as planned for the Eagles, and the offers are on the table, and Cousins and Hunter and all the other Eagles nobs are pissing him off, and his family start saying how nice it would be to see more of him etc... you never know.

Unlikely, but it would be worth every shot IMO

 

[AndyWalkersGirl]

Well, he is a distant cousin to one Bryce Gibbs....

 

[HBF]

Ohh, as I clicked the reply tab, the pic froze on the carlton jumper, looked great

But Judd will play atleast the next 5 years for West Coast.

Hmmm, me too.
Looked bloody nice, but I suspect he'll end up playing out his career with the Eagles.

 

[Johnny_3]

You'd at least be putting the feelers out now if you were a Carlton recruiting manager. Until he signs on the dotted line, he's a chance to come home.

Great idea, whoever started that 'Judd wants to come home' rumour in the newspapers. Even if its untrue, it might just put the thought into his mind. If 2007 doesn't quite go as planned for the Eagles, and the offers are on the table, and Cousins and Hunter and all the other Eagles nobs are pissing him off, and his family start saying how nice it would be to see more of him etc... you never know.

Unlikely, but it would be worth every shot IMO

Hawthorn, Melbourne, St Kilda.
Doubt it will be carlton.
But a midfield of Murph,Judd and Gibbs is just so good!

 

[Brad Pearce]

Here's a still, no more teasing you

 

[K.Simpson]

Sorry, no room in our midfield for Judd.
who you gunna take out.. Murphy Gibbs Stevens?

Might have to play on the wing or in the back pocket, no room for him.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Sorry, no room in our midfield for Judd.
who you gunna take out.. Murphy Gibbs Stevens?

Might have to play on the wing or in the back pocket, no room for him.

HAHAHAHA like that 1.

But seriously guys, what would we need to give up to get him. There was word from 2005 that West Coast offered Judd for Fevola & Draft pick 4 (Kennedy - Western Australian). Is that what they will ask for??? Is that what its goona take to get him here. If so they can have him in my point of view.

 

[Jeremias]

Sorry, no room in our midfield for Judd.
who you gunna take out.. Murphy Gibbs Stevens?

Might have to play on the wing or in the back pocket, no room for him.

Maybe we could turn him into a tagger?

 

[Jeremias]

HAHAHAHA like that 1.

But seriously guys, what would we need to give up to get him. There was word from 2005 that West Coast offered Judd for Fevola & Draft pick 4 (Kennedy - Western Australian). Is that what they will ask for??? Is that what its goona take to get him here. If so they can have him in my point of view.

We'd have to give up something ridiculous which we wouldn't do.

Something like Murph, Kennedy and a 1st round pick or 2 would do it.

 

[one_twelve112]

Hawthorn, Melbourne, St Kilda.
Doubt it will be carlton.
But a midfield of Murph,Judd and Gibbs is just so good!

Why?

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

Trade Walker and our first round draft pick for Judd.

 

[Jeremias]

Trade Walker and our first round draft pick for Judd.

The Eagles wouldn't take that.

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

The Eagles wouldn't take that.

They would if he was going to walk for nothing.

 

[Jeremias]

They would if he was going to walk for nothing.

That's not going to happen, I highly doubt Judd would do that to them. Anyway, clubs would offer a lot more than Walker and a pick or 2 for Judd, so I highly doubt the Eagles would take it.

 

[Blues_Man]

Judd is not the player we need ...think about it ..if we took Judd for a million a year..a couple of years down the track when all our young guns are superstars we would lose some of them due to salary cap pressure .
Not worth the risk ..we are developing our own Judd's thank you very much

 

[as0l0]

probably played his best footy already. forget about it.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Judd is not the player we need ...think about it ..if we took Judd for a million a year..a couple of years down the track when all our young guns are superstars we would lose some of them due to salary cap pressure .
Not worth the risk ..we are developing our own Judd's thank you very much

Yeah but I think the salary cup will be going up by about 2 million dollars over the next 5 years.

 

[David_Brent]

probably played his best footy already. forget about it.

He is 23!


Even if he doesnt improve, you still have the best player in the leage.

 

[btdg]

Judd is not the player we need ...think about it ..if we took Judd for a million a year..a couple of years down the track when all our young guns are superstars we would lose some of them due to salary cap pressure .
Not worth the risk ..we are developing our own Judd's thank you very much

Right... so you wouldn't take the best player in the competition now, because possibly at some stage down the track you might need the salary to re-sign players who may possibly be nearly but not quite as good.

Um, yep, that makes sense...

 

[The Grover]

If Cousins & co keep stuffing up, & Weagles drop from top 4 you never know.

We could offer Kennedy,Bower & Ist round pick, would depend on how those 2performed this year on whether you would offer that.

 

[Rocky Rambo]

The Eagles wouldn't take that.

LoL no way.

 

[TorresIsGod]

Surely, as soon as we mentioned the name Kennedy to WCE, they'll realise that we are offering the single greatest AFL player ever (Kennedy), for a nobody like Judd, they'll be silly not to accept that offer