Remove this Banner Ad

Judd

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ashb23
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

A

Ashb23

Club Legend
Veteran
Joined
Oct 4, 2006
Posts
1,165
Reaction score
320
Location
Vermont
AFL Club
Geelong
Ok, other teams are talking, so just wondered: what you give up for Chris Judd? I think its a tough one. At first I though we could do a Collingwood (name our top 10 and give them two players outside that), but I found it difficult to fit all the players I wanted into 10.

So anyway, what do you guys think we should offer (if anything)?
 
Ashb23 said:
Ok, other teams are talking, so just wondered: what you give up for Chris Judd? I think its a tough one. At first I though we could do a Collingwood (name our top 10 and give them two players outside that), but I found it difficult to fit all the players I wanted into 10.

So anyway, what do you guys think we should offer (if anything)?
Click to expand...

I doubt WC would give Judd away for two players outside any clubs top ten.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Ashb23 said:
Unfortunately they may not have a choice. Doubtful, but if he says I want to go back to VIC, what can they do?
Click to expand...

Would certainly be very interesting to see what clubs would offer. No doubt a couple of clubs would offer players that we supporters would think of as untradable.
 
marcmurphy3 said:
I doubt WC would give Judd away for two players outside any clubs top ten.
Click to expand...
ash didnt say that, it was an idea.. read it properly.. and the answer to ash's question, i think the ONLY chance they would give him away, would be for a yound midfielder, chosen in the top 5, and a good forward, someone like Scott Welsh.. not the too flashy ones, but ones that get the job done
 
I would give up hawkins for judd in a second..

Love hawkins but I would always swap potential for actual...

Not going to happen but only a fool would not give the house and sink for the king of football.
 
Maximus76 said:
I would give up hawkins for judd in a second..

Love hawkins but I would always swap potential for actual...

Not going to happen but only a fool would not give the house and sink for the king of football.
Click to expand...

I have waited 18 years for this kid....and you are not going to get rid of him no matter how good Judd is!!!!:p
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Bartel and our first pick would seem reasonable to me... Especially for a guy (Judd) who looks as if he wants out.
 
I'd want your best midfielder [Bartel or Chapman] + yourfirst round pick - Remeber to get qaulity you have to give qaulity. 3 average players + draft picks just doesn't cut it + we would have to delist players to fit them in

IMO out of any club in the AFL Judd would help yours the most - you need that quick, line breaking midfielder who kicks goals and breaks matches apart - most of yours appear one pased and lack match winning capabilities. That doesnt meen they aren't good [because some of your midfielders are guns]
 
mudgeathon said:
I'd want your best midfielder [Bartel or Chapman] + yourfirst round pick - Remeber to get qaulity you have to give qaulity. 3 average players + draft picks just doesn't cut it + we would have to delist players to fit them in

IMO out of any club in the AFL Judd would help yours the most - you need that quick, line breaking midfielder who kicks goals and breaks matches apart - most of yours appear one pased and lack match winning capabilities. That doesnt meen they aren't good [because some of your midfielders are guns]
Click to expand...

Corey and our first pick wouldn't be enough. I agree that we would need to give up either Chapman, G.Ablett or Bartel and our first pick to be a chance. We did very well in last years draft, I wouldn't hesitate to trade any one of those mentioned and our first pick for Judd.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

martyk said:
Corey and our first pick wouldn't be enough. I agree that we would need to give up either Chapman, G.Ablett or Bartel and our first pick to be a chance. We did very well in last years draft, I wouldn't hesitate to trade any one of those mentioned and our first pick for Judd.
Click to expand...

As much as it would pain me I'd also trade Chappy or Bartel plus a pick for Judd. I'd try and get away with trading Ling and Corey and a pick first though ;)
 
Judd is an awesome player, but i cant think of anyone I'd want to let go. This team has been building for a few years, we don't need a ring in to go all the way. Have faith and save some cash!
 
Well said. My heart agrees with you but this is what my head agrees with

B: D Johnson Scarlett Egan
HB: Milburn Harley Rooke
C: Wojinski Bartel Chapman
HF: Kelly Mooney G Ablett
F: S Johnson N Ablett Hawkins

Foll: Ottens, Ling, JUDD


Thats imagining we traded Corey + Enright + Maybe an Early draft pick + Even a hack for good luck ( Gardinar/ Playfair)
 
Danb said:
Judd is an awesome player, but i cant think of anyone I'd want to let go. This team has been building for a few years, we don't need a ring in to go all the way. Have faith and save some cash!
Click to expand...

Agree,remember all the angst the Moloney trade created, just imagine if Chappy,Ablett or Bartel were used, I for one would give them away.p.s. Moloney wasn't even an established player.
 
As mentioned earlier Geelong has more depth than anyone in the league, I am sure we can easily fill 2 departures of one paced quality.For a superstar.

Not to mention the off field benefits of JUDD
+ Memberships
+ Attendances to see him
+ ( Pressure of Bartel, and especially Ling )
 
If Geelong knew they were a chance to get Judd, they would be derelict in their duties if they did not offer AT LEAST Joel Corey plus a first round pick, or something similar. I would even reconcile myself to the idea of trading Jimmeh, though I would be saddened, given he is our best pure midfielder and a tough one at that. Corey and a first rounder would be a dream deal come to think of it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom