Juddy v Maxwell

[goalpie]

To be honest, Judd is the better player but at least Maxwell earnt the position not like Judd.

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

To be honest, Judd is the better player but at least Maxwell earnt the position not like Judd.

Exactly and Judd was pushed into being captain at West Coast in the first place so Judd probably doesn't think himself as captain material anyway.

 

[Gozz]

That was obviously an embarassing selection. Just another example of a player living on past glory rather than on current form. Judd is quite an average player these days, which is a shame, because he was awesome to watch at his best.

Oh... Jesus...

magpie militia You are an idiot

 

[magpie_militia]

Oh... Jesus...

magpie militia You are an idiot

Wait...this was a serious thread?

 

[blues4flag]

To be honest, Judd is the better player but at least Maxwell earnt the position not like Judd.

Maxwell wouldn't be captain at 15 other clubs. He was just fortunate that the Magpies were scraping the end of the barrel and his name was drawn out of the hat.

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

2008 Dane Swan>2008 Chris Judd
If you go by stats, Swan wins in avg. disposals, kicks, marks and goals.
Judd is still a very good player but he is nothing like what he use to be.

 

[blues4flag]

Fortunately for us, Judd can "pinpoint" the ball within 20 metres of his intended target.

The reason Swan averages so much of the footy is because half the time he kicks it 20 metres, misses the target, runs after it, handballs it to a teammate under pressure, gets it back, then proceeds to do another dinky pass. If he's lucky, the process will repeat.

 

[magpie_militia]

Fortunately for us, Judd can "pinpoint" the ball within 20 metres of his intended target.

The reason Swan averages so much of the footy is because half the time he kicks it 20 metres, misses the target, runs after it, handballs it to a teammate under pressure, gets it back, then proceeds to do another dinky pass. If he's lucky, the process will repeat.

Yeah I agree, Swan sucks. Easily one of our worst midfielders.

Its a wonder we made the finals again with so many hacks on our list. We even managed to win one, and with the youngest list to do so since Brisbane before their dynasty.

Must just be luck I guess.

 

[blues4flag]

Yeah I agree, Swan sucks. Easily one of our worst midfielders.

Steady Eddie. Swan's one of your few half decent midfielders. I do actually rate him, but unless he significantly improves his footskills, he could average 35 touches a game and still not be considered an elite.

 

[magpie_militia]

Steady Eddie. Swan's one of your few half decent midfielders. I do actually rate him, but unless he significantly improves his footskills, he could average 35 touches a game and still not be considered an elite.

So you rate him even though he can't pinpoint the ball within 20 metres of his target He sounds like a hack to me.

FWIW, I couldn't care less how he is viewed by people outside of Collingwood. I know how good he is and how important he is to our club. He shanks the occasional kick, but generally he is a very good kick.

 

[Juddys_navy_blues]

So you rate him even though he can't pinpoint the ball within 20 metres of his target He sounds like a hack to me.

FWIW, I couldn't care less how he is viewed by people outside of Collingwood. I know how good he is and how important he is to our club. He shanks the occasional kick, but generally he is a very good kick.

If you dont care why are you in here defending him? Go back to your centrelink board.

 

[magpie_militia]

If you dont care why are you in here defending him? Go back to your centrelink board.

Nah, they already know how good he is. I actually like the Blues board, you generally get some good discussion on here (apart from this rubbish thread).

 

[Juddys_navy_blues]

Nah, they already know how good he is. I actually like the Blues board, you generally get some good discussion on here (apart from this rubbish thread).

Well you got that part right

 

[magpie_militia]

Well you got that part right

I get every part right mate

I cant believe the poll result though, Maxwell is getting cained!!

 

[blues4flag]

So you rate him even though he can't pinpoint the ball within 20 metres of his target He sounds like a hack to me.

FWIW, I couldn't care less how he is viewed by people outside of Collingwood. I know how good he is and how important he is to our club. He shanks the occasional kick, but generally he is a very good kick.

I've watched Swan very closely, and that flat out ain't true. I was obviously being facetious earlier (though anyone who's watched him as closely as I have will know that the second part of my original post on him is based in fact).

I don't think he's an average player though - he's got excellent hands for a player his size, has a brilliant work ethic and is capable of going forward and have an impact if it's not working for him through the midfield. Racks it up and seldom plays a quiet game.

Average by foot though and is prone to the odd shocker.

 

[T4P]

LOL!!!!
You have sunk to a new low.
It is the most rediculous thread ever, Judd is a brownlow medallist for crying out loud and Maxwell, well put it this way, I've barely heard of him.

The person who created this thread is a sad person who just wants to reinforce to his or herself that it was worth two first round picks and an ex-first rounder for him.

 

[magpie_militia]

I've watched Swan very closely, and that flat out ain't true. I was obviously being facetious earlier (though anyone who's watched him as closely as I have will know that the second part of my original post on him is based in fact).

I don't think he's an average player though - he's got excellent hands for a player his size, has a brilliant work ethic and is capable of going forward and have an impact if it's not working for him through the midfield. Racks it up and seldom plays a quiet game.

Average by foot though and is prone to the odd shocker.

Agree with that assessment. He will never be an elite kick but he doesn't need to be, as he has other strengths that make up for it.

 

[Equus]

Yeah.... I voted Judd.

 

[THE AISSASSIN]

LOL!!!!
You have sunk to a new low.
It is the most rediculous thread ever, Judd is a brownlow medallist for crying out loud and Maxwell, well put it this way, I've barely heard of him.

The person who created this thread is a sad person who just wants to reinforce to his or herself that it was worth two first round picks and an ex-first rounder for him.

Me a sad person ?....or you a total drongo for not appreciating the humour on Carlton board.

xxxx off....masturbate about ur new drug addict recruit....and dont come back.

And if you barely have heard of Maxwell it shows ur lack of knowledge re AFL players

go on now Fxxx off

 

[Fadge]

Judd led Carlton to 11th in his first year as skipper of the Blues. Let's see where the Pies finish this year, then we can use some cold hard facts to help us make an assessment.

 

[The Coach]

How can Maxie still be getting so many votes - must check the magpie board for a rally call

Just think of what a great Xmas Maxie is going to have - imagine how good you would feel if you were made captain of your club

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

I reckon Swan looks more the goods to me. Oh, and the Duddy Juddy thing?

Playing Honours
Carlton Captain 2008; Brownlow Medal 2004, 3rd 2006; Best & Fairest 2004 & 2006, Runner-up 2003 & 2005, 3rd 2002; All-Australian 2004 & 2006; International Rules series 2002; AFL Players Association MVP 2006; Norm Smith Medal 2005; Premiership Captain 2006; Club Captain 2006 & 2007; AFL Rising Star nominee 2002.

Please God, make me a Duddy for Xmas.

Wow, weren't West Coast lucky!

 

[Juddys_navy_blues]

Wow, weren't West Coast lucky!

Yeah they where, but we will be luckier in the long run.

 

[THE AISSASSIN]

Wow, weren't West Coast lucky!

Yeah, they got Notte, Masten and Kennedy.

We got a bloke that has raised the spirit of pur club, increased revenue by millions through increased membership and merchandise sales, has set and an awesome example in terms of leadership to the club and was AA captain and B&f winner in his 1st season at the club while not fully fit

What did the Tigers get with the amped up Cousins ?.....a bloke that gonnna take Cotchin under his wing and show him all of Melbourne's wildest nightspots, introduce him to some suppliers ,give a few youngsters a "taste" of how to really enjoy life on the wild side,

Basically the same indemic drug culture that was at WC will now be introduced at Ninthmond, but anything is worth the risk with a 30 year old drug addict when u r Bitchmond

 

[magpie_militia]

54-32

Maxwell coming back.....a lot of votes for someone that hasn't even captained the club yet.