Justin Reid

Remove this Banner Ad

1970crow said:
FFS, Reid is only 1 person on a List Management committee that included such luminaries as Brett Burton, Mark Ricciuto and Don Pyke. Campo probably pushed his influence into there as well. Such was his power at our club. 2 of that crew were sacked, even though it went against our grain. Reid is the least of our problems, it’s Chappo and Rooo that are crippling our club.
Click to expand...
Totally agree. Until Chapman and Roo piss off nothing will change. I would also throw in Hass, Hart and Reid. While we are at it I would tip the board as they have been pathetic and allowed Chapman and Roo to run the club into the ground. The fact neither have resigned after the review is pretty shameful imo. Getting rid of Pyke, Burton and Campo was a good start but they only went half way in cleaning up the mess. I remember Roo's bs words when he stated eveeyone at the club were being reviewed. Within 48 hours this was changed by Chapman and himself to no one was safe in the football department. Those that oversaw and hired the football dept were strangely not being reviewed. How can you review one without the other? You can't.
 
Last edited:
It’s gonna be categorised more that he doesn’t have the intestinal fortitude like his old man to handle our list more so because of this scrambling Tete a tete with St Kilda and Crouch. Good list managers get it done. Seriously doubt turning into gtfo.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Red mist said:
It’s gonna be categorised more that he doesn’t have the intestinal fortitude like his old man to handle our list more so because of this scrambling Tete a tete with St Kilda and Crouch. Good list managers get it done. Seriously doubt turning into gtfo.
Click to expand...
His old man did well with that Tippett deal.
 
Mego Red said:
His old man did well with that Tippett deal.
Click to expand...
Exactly, passed the buck to our loyal coffee carrier for the repercussion.
Biggest nepotism flaw in our Club is Roo and Reid sitting in his office shuffling magnets. We are so poor for it.
 
Mego Red said:
His old man did well with that Tippett deal.
Click to expand...
He did pretty well landing us Malcolm Blight through their close friendship and the 2 Premierships that followed, something that gets regularly overlooked.
 
Mutineer said:
He did pretty well landing us Malcolm Blight through their close friendship and the 2 Premierships that followed, something that gets regularly overlooked.
Click to expand...
It’s not regularly overlooked. It was great thing for its time in the mid nineties. You just can’t do the mid nineties now.
 
Red mist said:
It’s gonna be categorised more that he doesn’t have the intestinal fortitude like his old man to handle our list more so because of this scrambling Tete a tete with St Kilda and Crouch. Good list managers get it done. Seriously doubt turning into gtfo.
Click to expand...
What exactly is Reid supposed to when it comes to St Kilda lodging contracts with the AFL?
 
Look, Gags came in to St Kilda and shifted five trades last year.
I don’t think it’s on him to sort this. It’s us shifting around waiting. Pretty haphazard and not reading the show.
Roo and Reid in the list management room is sending us down the shithole esp regarding how much we are paying players for playing for someone else. It sucks balls.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ad victoriam said:
Were does this Greenwood being a top contest mark come from, he was lucky to take 1 a game, funny how poeple only remember the marks he took but forget the bad games
Fogarty is a better contested mark full stop.
Click to expand...
In our forward line he was. And his tackling craft has gone on to show. You know where it comes from. Actuality.
 
MRB37 said:
What exactly is Reid supposed to when it comes to St Kilda lodging contracts with the AFL?
Click to expand...

If you talk to people at clubs it seems like in this case the value of a good list Manager was 12 months ago more so than where we are now.

That's was when Crouch was testing the market and Reid would of got a sense at that point if we should of traded him or hung onto him until this trade period.

Knowing the market in terms of what players are worth and what clubs will need is the skill set years in advance.

I think where we are now is fairly straightforward. He would know (or should) with the right contacts if we are getting pick two or not and what the Saints plan to do.
 
Last edited:
Mutineer said:
He did pretty well landing us Malcolm Blight through their close friendship and the 2 Premierships that followed, something that gets regularly overlooked.
Click to expand...
well heres to nicksy being the next blighty
 
Redline said:
If you talk to people at clubs it seems like in this case the value of a good list Manager was 12 months ago more so than where we are now.

That's was when Crouch was testing the market and Reid would of got a sense at that point if we should of traded him or hung onto him until this trade period.

Knowing the market in terms of what players are worth and what clubs will need is the skill set years in advance.

I think where we are now is fairly straightforward. He would (or should know) with the right contacts know if we are getting pick two or not and what the Saints plan to do.
Click to expand...
It’s not there. And for it to get there the idiots we trust are gonna get it over the line?
 
JackBero said:
well heres to nicksy being the next blighty
Click to expand...
Maybe, but that’s not the point. Maybe it is, let’s just win the next two premierships.What John Reid did in the nineties is a special and we love that.
what Reid did before he left the crows sucked hey.
 
MRB37 said:
What exactly is Reid supposed to when it comes to St Kilda lodging contracts with the AFL?
Click to expand...
Well if Dodoro can manage to negotiate with Brisbane to adjust Daniher's offer well before the FA period started so they got Band 1 and it was lodged on day one, I'd think that's the benchmark we should hold Reid to.
 
ltdamn said:
Well if Dodoro can manage to negotiate with Brisbane to adjust Daniher's offer well before the FA period started so they got Band 1 and it was lodged on day one, I'd think that's the benchmark we should hold Reid to.
Click to expand...
Nah hang on we can’t compare to the DoDo, he’s an imbecile apparently...
 
Red mist said:
It’s gonna be categorised more that he doesn’t have the intestinal fortitude like his old man to handle our list more so because of this scrambling Tete a tete with St Kilda and Crouch. Good list managers get it done. Seriously doubt turning into gtfo.
Click to expand...

Ball is in saints court, there’s nothing yet got Reid to do except posture. Which is being done. He can’t sign Brad and lodge the document with the AFL on behalf of St Kilda.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top