Remove this Banner Ad

Justin Sherman

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

amcre said:
Completely disagree suggesting your young mids that you have talked about have shown as much as the Tigers. Martin, Cotchin ect are much more accomplished.
Click to expand...

In what way. Because they were higher draft picks?
 
Azzleberry said:
Skill, Poise, Class, Aggression, Attack on the Football, Ability, Leadership, Decision Making, Fend off :), Athletic abilities...need I go on?;)
Click to expand...

No, I think you've gone on quite long enough...!!! :D Lions supporters usually find that followers of Melbourne-based clubs seldom watch Brisbane play. No one ever wins these kinds of arguments - reminds me of the old "My Dad's better than your Dad" sprays in Grade 2. Everyone's a little biased.

Anyway, what about Shermo, hey? ;)
 
Sherman for Tambling surely.

Certainly consistent with Voss' trading record.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

If we take on his ridiculously high wage it should really only be a third rounder. A second rounder and 400k a year to pay is the shittest deal and I would be pissed if we did that.
 
Azzleberry said:
Skill, Poise, Class, Aggression, Attack on the Football, Ability, Leadership, Decision Making, Fend off :), Athletic abilities...need I go on?;)
Click to expand...
Ability to be injured and miss games.

As I mentioned before you obviously never watch any of the Lions matches. Taking those two I am happy to stack Rich and Rockliff up against them now and in the coming season.

I like Martin but always thought Cotchin was very overrated. Time will tell.
 
Quigley said:
Ability to be injured and miss games.

As I mentioned before you obviously never watch any of the Lions matches. Taking those two I am happy to stack Rich and Rockliff up against them now and in the coming season.

I like Martin but always thought Cotchin was very overrated. Time will tell.
Click to expand...

I enjoy both Rich and Rockliff, but Rockliff in particular has nowhere near the impact that Cotchin or Martin has on a game.
Rockliff has shown that he is an accumulator without overly damaging the opposition, hence teams letting him run free and rack up the touches.
But agreed, time will tell.
 
amcre said:
If we take on his ridiculously high wage it should really only be a third rounder. A second rounder and 400k a year to pay is the shittest deal and I would be pissed if we did that.
Click to expand...

I don't think the salary is a problem. Sherman is apparently dead keen on the move and I imagine he would be very willing to renegotiate his contract with his new club.
 
The amount of ignorance shown in this thread about our list is quite staggering, but still not unexpected.
 
TheBrownDog said:
I don't think the salary is a problem. Sherman is apparently dead keen on the move and I imagine he would be very willing to renegotiate his contract with his new club.
Click to expand...

I agree, and I get the feeling that the tigers will offer him a re-packaged 3 year deal which will keep him happy and save a club paying him 400k
 
lions_den said:
The amount of ignorance shown in this thread about our list is quite staggering, but still not unexpected.
Click to expand...

The amount of optimism shown in this thread about Brisbanes list is quite staggering, but still not unexpected.

:D:D:D:D

X Clarke
Black
Brown
Fev
Power
Raines
Buchanan
Johnson


Lets be honest.

All with their best well and truly behind them and basically playing to top up their super funds.;)

Not to mention the massive legal battle about to start between Fev and the club.

And to top it off 3 of the better players are leaving have left, two of them top line mids.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Axel. said:
You've lost all credibility here.
Click to expand...
Not really. Rischa won your B&F for goodness sakes. And Brennan all of a sudden is a spud now he has walked out. Brisbane have the worst list in the AFL, just behind Essendon.
 
Good edit BACCS.

Risha did win our B&F but most of our better players were out injured. Like Mcphee won Essendons' B&F in 04? but there was about 10 other players who were better than him. I never really rated Brennan and i never called him a spud. He's one of the most inconsistent midfielders in the league but we should get a decent pick for him.

Our list can easily get us into the top 8 if injuries go our way. We're no different to Adelaides' list.
 
Axel. said:
Good edit BACCS.

Risha did win our B&F but most of our better players were out injured. Like Mcphee won Essendons' B&F in 04? but there was about 10 other players who were better than him. I never really rated Brennan and i never called him a spud. He's one of the most inconsistent midfielders in the league but we should get a decent pick for him.

Our list can easily get us into the top 8 if injuries go our way. We're no different to Adelaides' list.
Click to expand...

We made the finals that year, so not quite a fair comparison.
 
BACCS said:
Not really. Rischa won your B&F for goodness sakes. And Brennan all of a sudden is a spud now he has walked out. Brisbane have the worst list in the AFL, just behind Essendon.
Click to expand...

Hey don't forget West Coast!!!!
 
How? :D

We both have good kids coming through and we'll have good draft picks this season to get even more quality kids. The small difference is we have more potatoes than you do. Expect them to be gone at the end of next season unless they turn their careers around.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Axel. said:
How? :D

We both have good kids coming through and we'll have good draft picks this season to get even more quality kids. The small difference is we have more potatoes than you do. Expect them to be gone at the end of next season unless they turn their careers around.
Click to expand...

I must say, the Crows have young guns in Sloane, Tippett, Vince, Douglas, Walker, Otten, Davis, & armstrong...I can only think of a few young lions players worth a mention
 
Balony_pony16 said:
I must say, the Crows have young guns in Sloane, Tippett, Vince, Douglas, Walker, Otten, Davis, & armstrong...I can only think of a few young lions players worth a mention
Click to expand...

Rich, Redden, Rockliff, Banfield, Clark, Leuenberger, Cornelius, Bartlett, Harwood, Hanley, Polkinghorne... plus a likely swag of early draft picks this year.
 
TheBrownDog said:
Rich, Redden, Rockliff, Banfield, Clark, Leuenberger, Cornelius, Bartlett, Harwood, Hanley, Polkinghorne... plus a likely swag of early draft picks this year.
Click to expand...

A bit generous putting abrlett (never played afl), Polkinghorne (useless), Hanley (mmm...a fe good games),Cornelius (obvious he won't be play mch with Fev in the team)?
 
TheBrownDog said:
Rich, Redden, Rockliff, Banfield, Clark, Leuenberger, Cornelius, Bartlett, Harwood, Hanley, Polkinghorne... plus a likely swag of early draft picks this year.
Click to expand...

Only player worth his salt in that bunch is Rich.

Talk about over rating your players much.:confused:

Early picks won't have much effect next season, kids take time.
 
Balony_pony16 said:
A bit generous putting abrlett (never played afl), Polkinghorne (useless), Hanley (mmm...a fe good games),Cornelius (obvious he won't be play mch with Fev in the team)?
Click to expand...

It's only fair. You put Armstrong in. :cool:

Retzlaff, McCauley and O'Brien look like they're going to be decent players also.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top