Player Watch #?: Kaiden Brand - signed as DFA

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Tedeski

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 2, 2006
16,370
18,166
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Sunnybrook Farm
Will replace melican with ease
I remember Richards & Grundy being so reliant on each other down back & perhaps when Melican lost that transition of playing alongside strong & confident defenders in Reg, Smith & Ramps, he came along quite nicely as that 3rd big. He misses a year then whammo, he is suddenly the big knob & no doubt he failed at coping with that.

So I feel that having defenders like Brand, Aliir & Rampe as fellow talls around him & Mills also there with a little more experience, 2020 can become that year where this back 6 can begin to gel into that strong defence that all know where each other wil be & how they play. This is the year where they'll need to stabilise. Melican will thrive in that scenario & with less repeat entries week after week due to weak ruck scenarios in 2019, he will not be under the pump all match. That is also confidence sapping.

If prople think he is no good well so be it.
 

Punts

Brownlow Medallist
Nov 11, 2012
21,305
21,022
AFL Club
Sydney
10m of his opponent Melican was , even Tex was beaten him across the ground.

If we had depth he would have played 2s most of the year

He was a complete liability, played forward which was even funnier
 

SGBeach

Team Captain
Jul 19, 2019
557
701
AFL Club
Sydney
I remember Richards & Grundy being so reliant on each other down back & perhaps when Melican lost that transition of playing alongside strong & confident defenders in Reg, Smith & Ramps, he came along quite nicely as that 3rd big. He misses a year then whammo, he is suddenly the big knob & no doubt he failed at coping with that.

So I feel that having defenders like Brand, Aliir & Rampe as fellow talls around him & Mills also there with a little more experience, 2020 can become that year where this back 6 can begin to gel into that strong defence that all know where each other wil be & how they play. This is the year where they'll need to stabilise. Melican will thrive in that scenario & with less repeat entries week after week due to weak ruck scenarios in 2019, he will not be under the pump all match. That is also confidence sapping.

If prople think he is no good well so be it.
You may be right.. Im interested in your starting back 6 and the 2-3 others that would rotate through defence
 

Mick Oxlong

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 27, 2007
11,469
13,084
AFL Club
Sydney
Brand’s signing says a bit about where Melican is at.

Reckon he’s a prudent signing as he fills a real need.
So delisting a big man in Maibaum just in time to pick up Brand doesn’t ring a few bells? I think that correlation says more than where Melican is at (which is entrenched in the Senior team).
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

cadsky

Premium Gold
Jun 14, 2011
4,781
5,785
Vic
AFL Club
Sydney
Ideally we have Melican, Brand locking down the key defensive posts with Rampe third tall and Aliir floating. Reckon Mills will end up staying in defence.
Pretty much how I see it. I do wonder if there's any chance Thurlow could improve and cement a spot in the back line.

FB: Melican, Brand, Rampe
HB: Aliir, Thurlow, Dawson

Mills to play mid and shift back if required
Aliir & Rampe can rotate
Dawson and McCartin car rotate back and forward as required. Dawson could also play wing if required.
 

Kiama Chris

All Australian
May 10, 2016
619
920
Kiama
AFL Club
Sydney
I remember Richards & Grundy being so reliant on each other down back & perhaps when Melican lost that transition of playing alongside strong & confident defenders in Reg, Smith & Ramps, he came along quite nicely as that 3rd big. He misses a year then whammo, he is suddenly the big knob & no doubt he failed at coping with that.

So I feel that having defenders like Brand, Aliir & Rampe as fellow talls around him & Mills also there with a little more experience, 2020 can become that year where this back 6 can begin to gel into that strong defence that all know where each other wil be & how they play. This is the year where they'll need to stabilise. Melican will thrive in that scenario & with less repeat entries week after week due to weak ruck scenarios in 2019, he will not be under the pump all match. That is also confidence sapping.

If prople think he is no good well so be it.
Everything you say is true. What is not said is that Melican is far too often beaten on the lead, failing to get to the contest and create pressure. His other skills are OK and he may well get back to his earlier form, just as Aliir did after his glitch. Hope so.
As some other posters gave noted perhaps Brand will be more relaxed in our back set up with Rampe running the show. Hope we see his best footy.
 

Millky95

Starchild > You
Jul 6, 2014
26,777
25,845
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Renegades
would love to see Dawson on the wing. Good mark coming out of defence. Good decision maker from transition from defence to attack. Great kick to the forwards inside 50. Can kick a goal from 55 out
Would love to see Buddy bait some defenders to that 30m out range just for Dawson to take it long from 55m over everyone's head
 

mtooler

Premiership Player
Feb 5, 2012
3,881
3,845
AFL Club
Sydney
I remember Richards & Grundy being so reliant on each other down back & perhaps when Melican lost that transition of playing alongside strong & confident defenders in Reg, Smith & Ramps, he came along quite nicely as that 3rd big. He misses a year then whammo, he is suddenly the big knob & no doubt he failed at coping with that.

So I feel that having defenders like Brand, Aliir & Rampe as fellow talls around him & Mills also there with a little more experience, 2020 can become that year where this back 6 can begin to gel into that strong defence that all know where each other wil be & how they play. This is the year where they'll need to stabilise. Melican will thrive in that scenario & with less repeat entries week after week due to weak ruck scenarios in 2019, he will not be under the pump all match. That is also confidence sapping.

If prople think he is no good well so be it.
I doubt Melican will be in the firsts. If Brand, Rampe and Aliir are the three talls and Mills plays tall, doubtful we'd play Melican.
 

cadsky

Premium Gold
Jun 14, 2011
4,781
5,785
Vic
AFL Club
Sydney
Pretty much how I see it. I do wonder if there's any chance Thurlow could improve and cement a spot in the back line.

FB: Melican, Brand, Rampe
HB: Aliir, Thurlow, Dawson

Mills to play mid and shift back if required
Aliir & Rampe can rotate
Dawson and McCartin car rotate back and forward as required. Dawson could also play wing if required.
Slight amendment


FB: Melican, Brand, Rampe
HB: Aliir, Lloyd, Dawson

Thurlow starts on the bench but can still see him as a best 22 player.
 

Top Bottom