I agree with you, but it wouldn't be the first time a player trade could not be organised and a third party came in who could match the trade demands to sign the player. Im not sure Crameri has the option of entering the Pre Sean Draft because he would end up at Melbourne who seem about two years behind the Bulldogs. If a deal can't be done then Crameri may have a choice between us and Melbourne (GWS will probably use their PSD pick on Mumford). Again, if we have a decent offer on the table I definitely think we have a chance. Michie and our first pick would get the deal done in my view (Bulldogs have reportedly offered pick 22)
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Key Forward
- Thread starter Kunna17
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Jan 14, 2008
- 14,827
- 31,831
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Sherrif, Bond has repeatedly stated that our first pick is not negotiable.
Your reasoning on drafting Crameri is valid but giving up our first pick and a player on a 190 cm third tall doesnt make sense
I'm still failing to understand why Reid would want to come to Perth. If he is to leave Sydney, surely it would be back to a Melbourne based club?
I think Pods would be a great addition for a couple of seasons, which would allow us to bridge a gap while we continue to develop the next tier. Cheap insurance and by all accounts has been a great contributor to the Cats.
I think Pods would be a great addition for a couple of seasons, which would allow us to bridge a gap while we continue to develop the next tier. Cheap insurance and by all accounts has been a great contributor to the Cats.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
but he could get good coin in Melbourne and also be closer to family, plus for the Swans there would be more players in the field lobbying for his services.
Reid would have to agree to the trade of course.
Hard to imagine another KPP like Reid + Colin Sylvia both in the starting 22 line-up.
Just with Colin at the present a couple of current starting 22 players stand to find themselves out of the fringe.
Just with Colin at the present a couple of current starting 22 players stand to find themselves out of the fringe.
My view is that the 190cm Crameri (same height as Darling)is super strong and could play key forward very well in our playing system. The bloke did kick three goals playing on Mcpharlin in that role. (remember the awesome running goal). In my view he has played his best for Essendon when they have played him deep as this position allows him can use his strength and speed. I think he will be able to play the key forward role, while at the same time adding to the fanatical forward pressure our team is famous for.
BTW I hope all is well with you Salim. Don't worry about the bloke taking pot shots at you, he is a deadset waste of space and has zero footy intelligence. Cheers
Kunna17
Club Legend
- Oct 9, 2012
- 2,047
- 668
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Thread starter
- #1,813
simple ... need a kpf. Can't give up engine room, difure it out from there.
1st Rounder should be available UNLESS we presume Marsh/Mcarthy will fall to our pick.
Hill CAN be traded,but we need to win the deal quite easily as he is the reason D. Pearce gets free. Rekon Crozier will be asking a few questions though and maybe we see Hill as tradable because of depth in that position.
JUST GET ME A BEST 22 KPF.
Gumby's good enough, Pod's good enough.
Reid is excellent, Crameri just as good.
Thorpe good option as well.
As you can see, i will take anyone
1st Rounder should be available UNLESS we presume Marsh/Mcarthy will fall to our pick.
Hill CAN be traded,but we need to win the deal quite easily as he is the reason D. Pearce gets free. Rekon Crozier will be asking a few questions though and maybe we see Hill as tradable because of depth in that position.
JUST GET ME A BEST 22 KPF.
Gumby's good enough, Pod's good enough.
Reid is excellent, Crameri just as good.
Thorpe good option as well.
As you can see, i will take anyone
simple ... need a kpf. Can't give up engine room, difure it out from there.
1st Rounder should be available UNLESS we presume Marsh/Mcarthy will fall to our pick.
Hill CAN be traded,but we need to win the deal quite easily as he is the reason D. Pearce gets free. Rekon Crozier will be asking a few questions though and maybe we see Hill as tradable because of depth in that position.
JUST GET ME A BEST 22 KPF.
Gumby's good enough, Pod's good enough.
Reid is excellent, Crameri just as good.
Thorpe good option as well.
As you can see, i will take anyone
4 drinks and I am anyones too , still doesn't make it right
TweeBeard
Team Captain
- Aug 7, 2012
- 409
- 414
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
simple ... need a kpf. Can't give up engine room, difure it out from there.
1st Rounder should be available UNLESS we presume Marsh/Mcarthy will fall to our pick.
Hill CAN be traded,but we need to win the deal quite easily as he is the reason D. Pearce gets free. Rekon Crozier will be asking a few questions though and maybe we see Hill as tradable because of depth in that position.
JUST GET ME A BEST 22 KPF.
Gumby's good enough, Pod's good enough.
Reid is excellent, Crameri just as good.
Thorpe good option as well.
As you can see, i will take anyone
This is coming up on this forum far too much IMO.
I agree, you don't trade out guys like Stephen Hill. He's critical to a shot at the title.
and you JUST DON'T SHOOT BAMBI, EVER!!!
WARNING, kids don't read this.
I wont lie, although the source is from facebook, which as well be my butt crack, reading that we've spoken to his management and hes open to the idea did give me a bit of a hard on.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
. Otherwise we would of picked him up by now, considering he's a delisted free agent.
- Jun 6, 2010
- 4,039
- 12,888
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Dillon Panthers
Crameri isn't contracted, Reid is.
- Dec 17, 2003
- 18,590
- 13,191
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Glasgow Rangers, Liverpool, Storm.
He's contracted for another 3 or 4 years. So we could probably hold out for a bit more. KPF's are fairly expensive so i'd say we'd want a youngster thrown in.
He's contracted for another 3 or 4 years. So we could probably hold out for a bit more. KPF's are fairly expensive so i'd say we'd want a youngster thrown in.
Plus an AFL compensation pick.
- Banned
- #1,825
At the end of the day you arent going to get a quality key forward without giving up a quality player. I like Hill as much as anyone, but we have a surplus of outside mids, and he's the only one with real currency.
Consider the guys on our list now who could take Hill's spot either now or in the future:
Morabito, Crozier, Sheridan, Sylvia, Simpson
At least 3 of those guys won't be getting a game next year, meanwhile we have Matt De Boer as a key forward.
