I know you guys are desperate to win something. I can understand that, losing a semi final the way you guys did cuts deep, we know all about it. Walker's mark was a ripper and nobody really could split all three marks. But to say Krak's mark was shit and ordinary is below even Carlton supporters. Were you all screaming shananigans when Judd won a highly contentious brownlow last year, knocking off Ablett & Swan who had better years?? Nope! Krak took a fantastic pack mark and deserves his award. I'm not looking to start a email fight here, it is not my style, just give some credit where it is due, it is just common courtesy.
I think only Posiedon has given Krak some credit, very intelligent poster.
The hatred for collingwood sometimes seems endless and often uncalled for. There is a time to have a go and a time to dip your hat.....
First bold- That has nothing to do with it. Andrew Walker's mark should have been mark of the year. Krak's mark was good, but Walkers was better. If a collingwood player had taken the mark instead of Andrew Walker, I would still say the mark deserves mark of the year.
Im not saying Krak's mark wasn't good. it was pretty good, to get up that high in a pack was impressive, but i just feel , as do A LOT of AFL supporters, that Walkers was better.
Second Bold- And to say that we didnt scream shananigans when Judd won his brownlow, has nothing to do with MOTY.
Judd won the brownlow fair and square. The impact he had on games was impressive, not to say that Ablett and Swan's years werent good, I believe Judd's was better. A lot of people say Judd deserved his brownlow.
Judd was best on ground in a lot of games, where Swan had the likes of Pendlebury, Thomas, etc to take votes off him and Ablett had the likes of the whole midfield to take votes off him.