Whether or not Faith has a good track record or an inside source is irrelevent to posts which suggest
Sydney lose Reid for pick 4 (Ignoring the fact that Melb would be stupid to trade Dawes + 17 for pick 4)
then send Pick 4 and 22 to Adelaide for Tippett...
So the assumption they go with, is that a promising 20 year old who is contracted and whose output is not far behind that of 25 year old Tippett is only worth pick 4. Whilst the uncontracted player that walked out on their club will somehow fetch 4 and 22.
Just a sheer lack of logic from them, then this sort of suggestion is praised as being "a good idea" or likely scenario by such luminary's as Faith.