Remove this Banner Ad

Lachie Whitfield

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I wouldn't either if I was a Collingwood supporter, some stuff is purely perspective driven don't you think?

Well you would Call it a Win/Win Trade but We will get more out of Adams then you will Heater as well
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

The age difference is obvious but we needed a leader and player the caliber of heater more than another mid

Well you got so many in the Draft and Thru your Academy. That you have a never ending of Mids coming thru the Draft
 
Well you got so many in the Draft and Thru your Academy. That you have a never ending of Mids coming thru the Draft
Agreed, that's why Heater was seen as a win for us, we desperately needed his experience, whereas we have multiple first round draft picks in the mids who couldn't or can't get games
 
Agreed, that's why Heater was seen as a win for us, we desperately needed his experience, whereas we have multiple first round draft picks in the mids who couldn't or can't get games

and Helped that Heater Grew Up when he went to you guys as he was not Behaving well at Collingwood
 
and Helped that Heater Grew Up when he went to you guys as he was not Behaving well at Collingwood
I think the reality of being dumped by the pies was a huge factor in him growing up. He still has his cheeky moments that we love but he looks like he has outgrown his tantrums.

Easily one of my favourite players at the club
 
Not going to be your search engine.
Most of us thought he was always going because of his actions when he got drafted.

Its pretty straight forward. The only trade the playing group got involved in and also commented negatively on was Boyds. Not rocket science.

Edit. If you want to discuss Boyd further then do it in a Boyd thread.

So you just made something up
 

Remove this Banner Ad

IIRC we essentially got Bastinac, Keays, Hipwood, and Mathieson for Aish, pick 17 and 26.

Redden (pick 17) and Aish (Aish got us pick 26) for Bastinac, Keays, Hipwood, the Saints 2nd rounder and NM's 3rd rounder.

IMO that looks even better. :D Mathieson roughly maps to our own third rounder and/or pick 41 that we got back in the Bell trade.
 
Not at all. Has been discussed numerous times by giants fans.
Im not your bitch to go look for you

lol, so because a couple of gws fans discuss it on bf makes it true?

You know you can't find any evidence to back up your fanciful claims because it doesn't exist.
 
Sorry to be the one to break it, but Lachie is going nowhere, spent a lot of time at Tom Wills and it would be hard to find a guy more committed to the Giants
Sounds very similar to what GWS fans were saying about Treloar this time last year.

For what it's worth, as a Saints fan, I think he's worth a pick around the 5 mark. Very talented kid.
 
Sounds very similar to what GWS fans were saying about Treloar this time last year.

For what it's worth, as a Saints fan, I think he's worth a pick around the 5 mark. Very talented kid.
Treloars management has already stated that the reason he left was because we wouldn't meet his monetary demands. From what I know he was offered the same deal as Shiel and the club wouldn't budge. End of the day footy is business and he has to look out for his own interests. Also helps that the pies helped his girlfriend land a sweet job.
 
Treloars management has already stated that the reason he left was because we wouldn't meet his monetary demands. From what I know he was offered the same deal as Shiel and the club wouldn't budge. End of the day footy is business and he has to look out for his own interests. Also helps that the pies helped his girlfriend land a sweet job.
I'm sure the Saints could get Lachies mrs a job pouring beers at the Espy on a Friday night...
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Treloars management has already stated that the reason he left was because we wouldn't meet his monetary demands. From what I know he was offered the same deal as Shiel and the club wouldn't budge. End of the day footy is business and he has to look out for his own interests. Also helps that the pies helped his girlfriend land a sweet job.

Do you have 100% Proof of Collingwood help his Girlfriend a Good Job?
 
Do you have 100% Proof of Collingwood help his Girlfriend a Good Job?

That's quite a bar to clear for an online discussion forum. I'm sure all your posts are made with 100% proof available on request?
 
That's quite a bar to clear for an online discussion forum. I'm sure all your posts are made with 100% proof available on request?

Well IF you making a Accusation you need to have something to back you up.

It's like me Saying. Beams signed with the Lions before the Season Ended 2 years ago
 
Lachie is a solid player with tremendous running ability.

His weakness at the moment is his propensity to produce clangers which seems to happen a bit but you can forgive him because he works incredibly hard and gives consistent effort so they are most likely fatigue errors.

I believe he never lifted a weight before going into the draft and has had shoulder issues which have inhibited his physical development.

He is a best 22 player at any club and if he went onto the market would require a high 1st round pick as he will only get better with more experience and a better physical base.

That said I believe he enjoys Sydney and I think any delays are more due to management trying to ensure they get the best deal for their client. Seems the norm these days.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top