Lake vs Scarlett

[Lunchlady Doris]

Lake went into the game injured + the flu and hurt himself during the game moron.

Nice though jump on him when he has all that going against him he shouldn't of even played last night.

Brad Johnson said no one was sick this week, stop trotting that crap out.

 

[charcoalchicken]

Brad Johnson said no one was sick this week, stop trotting that crap out.

Rodney Eade said there were quite a few players sick and I know for a fact that there were. Lake>Scarlett for the last few years. Hurts doesn't it.

 

[DO IT TO IT]

Rodney Eade said there were quite a few players sick and I know for a fact that there were. Lake>Scarlett for the last few years. Hurts doesn't it.

last few months actually

scarlett was better 09 and every previous year

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Rodney Eade said there were quite a few players sick and I know for a fact that there were. Lake>Scarlett for the last few years. Hurts doesn't it.

Look at the little baby.

 

[JUBJUB]

Difference is Scarlett wasn't playing when he was injured so he couldn't put in an average performance which could make him look bad so we couldn't take pot shots at him like you lot have when he's playing hurt. Scarlett's good form was most definitely fresh in everybody's mind so it didn't matter that the thread was started at that time as the poll shows quite a few people have voted in it a fair few from opposing clubs and Lake is winning it so the people have already spoken. Sorry.

It's the only thing the pitiful Dogs will win this year

BTW - Scarlett 2 premierships > Bulldogs 1

 

[Rioli magic]

You don't watch Geelong much do you?

Did you watch the game on Saturday night? Between the Dogs and Cats?

How about Cats v Sydney? Bris?

Pretty sure he was expressing his opinion Lady, which can differ from yours. They tend to hold more weight coming from a neutral supporters, which generally seem to be going Lake's way, mine included.

Look at the little baby.

Interesting comment coming from you.

 

[Slattery_20]

Scarlett > daylight > Lake.

 

[charcoalchicken]

last few months actually

scarlett was better 09 and every previous year

Poor attempt at trolling.

 

[maximus steel]

Im still amazed when commentators call Scarlett Geelongs most important player.


He hasn't had a tight role for a couple of years.


More inclined to be the loose-man or grab the third tall, and has done so for a while now.

Lonergan usually takes the second best forward, with Taylor taking the first.


Lake is easily one of the most influencial backman ive seen, certainly in the last decade.

taylor takes the centre half forward, scarlett/lonergan rotate through full back, with scarlett taking the most dangerous one. reason why that hasn't happened much this year is because scarlett has been working back to full fitness.

 

[Werewolf]

Brad Johnson said no one was sick this week, stop trotting that crap out.

It must have had some effect, I admit Geelong is a better side than us, but not by 101 points.

 

[BONG RIPS MKII]

Poor attempt at trolling.

2009 aa fb - matthew scarlett

2009 aa bp - brian lake

 

[charcoalchicken]

2009 aa fb - matthew scarlett

2009 aa bp - brian lake

Scarlett got that off reputation alone EVERYBODY knows and accepts that.

 

[tazhawk]

Pretty sure he was expressing his opinion Lady, which can differ from yours. They tend to hold more weight coming from a neutral supporters, which generally seem to be going Lake's way, mine included.



Interesting comment coming from you.

Don't you know LLD is never wrong and the only good players in the AFL are Geelong players.

ON the OP....... Lake for me.

 

[donbooger]

Scarlett got that off reputation alone EVERYBODY knows and accepts that.

This isnt the bulldogs forum, the word EVERYBODY accounts for more people out here.

 

[wombat01]

For mine Scarlett is the Best Full back to have ever played let alone better than Lake.

Does Scarlett ever get beaten? If he gets 2 goals kicked on him it's considered a poor game.

 

[charcoalchicken]

Brad Johnson said no one was sick this week, stop trotting that crap out.

Well we found out what you wrote here was a load of crap Selwood, Ottens & Bartel all have the flu and likely to miss after playing us.

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

And my vote ties it at 128 all . Both extremely good players, but Scarlett is a gun, verey, very rarely gets beaten and is the best backman of the last 20 years.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Pretty sure he was expressing his opinion Lady, which can differ from yours. They tend to hold more weight coming from a neutral supporters, which generally seem to be going Lake's way, mine included.

I was just telling him the facts that he based his opinion on were incorrect. Thus, his opinion is incorrect also.

Interesting comment coming from you.

He thought I would be hurt by the fact that he thinks Lake is better. I mean, come on.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Well we found out what you wrote here was a load of crap Selwood, Ottens & Bartel all have the flu and likely to miss after playing us.

Yeah, right on. Myself and several of my friends and family in the past 2 weeks must have also played the Bulldogs.

 

[maximus steel]

Scarlett got that off reputation alone EVERYBODY knows and accepts that.

keep telling yourself that, as scarlett goes and adds AA number 5 to the trophy cabinet. as lake wipes the dust off the cabinet, finds the key, and puts in number 1

 

[GrandBlue]

Why hasn't this thread been moved to Bay 13 yet?

 

[BONG RIPS MKII]

i know

some of the stuff charcoalchicken comes out with

 

[grizzlym]

Closed for cleaning.



Edit: Closed for good.