Movie Left-Wing Agenda in Cinema/TV

Bostonian

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 9, 2015
10,871
10,204
AFL Club
Carlton
Which one was that now? Because Captain Marvel has been a women in the comics for some time and the Jane Foster Thor story is from the comics as well.
Annette Benning played Mar-Vell or Dr Walter Lawson. The original and best Captain Marvel(in comics).

But they gender flipped it.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

bourbons

Norm Smith Medallist
Mar 1, 2007
8,506
5,603
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
So women have to be portrayed as strong independent types for it to count?

Men are portrayed as a vast majority of all super evil characters, that a problem?
Not at all. Nice to have some variety though - you seriously suggesting there have been an abundance of those character types traditionally in movies?

Not for me - they're probably on an equal percentage with good/hero male characters. Outside of comic book movies and the latest Star Wars triology I can't really think of too many other movies that are consistently pushing female heroes.

Except the over the top representations when it comes to male characters aren't done so as to empower anyone or to make any kind of statement. It's their character that is the focus, not their gender.

Nobody ever went to a Captain America movie and was thinking "oh you go boy, look at you being all male and strong and independent".

That would be some super lame garbage. Just like anything that's pushing a "girl power" angle is super lame garbage.
Well yeah - of course it isn't done with male characters for the pupose of empowerment. There isn't any need as blokes have generally, traditionally, been empowered for pretty much the entire history of cinema. We've been conditioned over a long period with huge range strong independent male characters. Its not like male and female representations have been on roughly equal footing previously.

You could argue that these type of representations of women are sometimes being shoe-horned in or clumsily executed, although I see far less examples of that than others would claim. I guess essentially studios are trying to fast-track it. No doubt for some working on the movie it would be an ideology thing, but I still reckon at the macro level its more about $$$.
 
Last edited:

Bostonian

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 9, 2015
10,871
10,204
AFL Club
Carlton
Not at all. Nice to have some variety though - you seriously suggesting there have been an abundance of those character types traditionally in movies?


Not for me - they're probably on an equal percentage with good/hero male characters. Outside of comic book movies and the latest Star Wars triology I can't really think of too many other movies that are consistently pushing female heroes.
The problem is that these identity politics types only have a very narrow view of what they accept as being a strong woman. They don't count women who chose a more traditional lifestyle choice as strong women. In fact they s**t on those women often for their choices. So any mothers or wives in movies don't get counted as strong characters. even if they are exactly that, strong characters.

Resident Evil, Underworld, Alien, Terminator, Kill Bill, Hanna, Fifth Element, La Femme Nakita off the top of my head however are movies that have been made without the 2019 lame arse girl power rubbish tied to them.

Then there's the crapload of movies that have women cast as strong characters simply a peg below the main character.

It's a false narrative being pushed.


Well yeah - of course it isn't done with male characters for the pupose of empowerment. There isn't any need as blokes have generally, traditionally, been empowered for pretty much the entire history of cinema. We've been conditioned over a long period with huge range strong independent male characters. Its not like male and female representations have been on roughly equal footing previously.
No need? I reckon the male suicide rates might contradict your view males don't need any empowerment in life.

For every "strong male" character there's 100 that are weak and dead.


You could argue that these type of representations of women are sometimes being shoe-horned in or clumsily executed, although I see far less examples of that than others would claim. I guess essentially studios are trying to fast-track it. No doubt for some working on the movie it would be an ideology thing, but I still reckon at the macro level its more about $$$.
If it was about the $$ they'd be playing it differently as in they'd not be wanting to drive away the goose that lays the golden egg for these kinds of movies, male customers. For all its girl power, it was still the power of the male $ that made CM as much money as it pulled in. 55/45 I think was the audience split.
 

Geelong_Sicko

Brownlow Medallist
Jun 11, 2007
16,625
13,705
Melbourne
AFL Club
Geelong
Cillian Murphy has refused the role of James Bond because as a proud Irishman he does not want people to think he is English. Come on Idris see how many ******* Incels you can p**s off - even more than when you appeared as a non Aryan in Asgard.
Pierce Brosnan is Irish too, incidently. He's from Navan!! (Louth according to his wiki but I always heard it was Navan? Oh well)
 

bourbons

Norm Smith Medallist
Mar 1, 2007
8,506
5,603
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
The problem is that these identity politics types only have a very narrow view of what they accept as being a strong woman. They don't count women who chose a more traditional lifestyle choice as strong women. In fact they s**t on those women often for their choices. So any mothers or wives in movies don't get counted as strong characters. even if they are exactly that, strong characters.

Resident Evil, Underworld, Alien, Terminator, Kill Bill, Hanna, Fifth Element, La Femme Nakita off the top of my head however are movies that have been made without the 2019 lame arse girl power rubbish tied to them.

Then there's the crapload of movies that have women cast as strong characters simply a peg below the main character.

It's a false narrative being pushed.
Yep thats a fair point re: traditional lifestyle choice not typically portrayed as 'strong' on screen - dunno if there's much room for that angle in your average action/comic movie though, which seems to be genre most have an issue with.

And yeah there are examples of the good for sure, just as there are examples of the bad. More recently, I'd add Wonder Woman, Mad Max Fury Road, Edge of Tomorrow and Atomic Blonde (know it wasn't that well received but I liked it) to that list. For a variety of reasons, movies are pronounced good and bad all the time - I'm just not sure its worth getting bent out of shape about a poorly executed insertion of girl power. We wouldn't if it was bad because of (for example) humour that doesn't work - we just say "oh well that was crap" and move on without any dissection of ideology and society.

I'm still unclear on what exactly is the false narrative - its false that women traditionally have been over-represented in a weaker roles compared to men? Its false that those roles are considered weak in the first place? Sorry if I'm being particularly dense about this.

No need? I reckon the male suicide rates might contradict your view males don't need any empowerment in life.

For every "strong male" character there's 100 that are weak and dead.
Male suicide has been an issue since long before movies were even a thing, bit disingenuous to make that link.

But the one 'strong male' would typically be the focus of the movie, yeah? If you're counting extras, yeah of course there'll be heaps more that are weak or dead, but that's just the mechanics of a typical action movie - lone hero up against a horde of disposable bad guys. They're not setup for you to relate to the bad dead guys obviously, you're supposed to relate to the hero.

If it was about the $$ they'd be playing it differently as in they'd not be wanting to drive away the goose that lays the golden egg for these kinds of movies, male customers. For all its girl power, it was still the power of the male $ that made CM as much money as it pulled in. 55/45 I think was the audience split.
What do you reckon the split would have been for a comic book movie 15 years ago? I'd guess it would have been nowhere near 55/45.

What you're describing re: driving away male customers simply isn't happening, at least not yet. CM had the 6th best opening of all time and has now made well over $1bn. When (if?) it does start happening, thats when you'll see a change in direction - like I said, ultimately the market decides.
 
Last edited:

Demonic Ascent

Brownlow Medallist
Feb 21, 2006
14,438
9,943
Muckertal
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Eltham Turtles, NY Jets, Celtics
It's all Hollywood has left, there are no original ideas just reboots, remakes and franchises. So all they've got is "hey, what if James Bond were....A BLACK WOMAN 😲 "
 

Demonic Ascent

Brownlow Medallist
Feb 21, 2006
14,438
9,943
Muckertal
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Eltham Turtles, NY Jets, Celtics
I'm about as leftie as they come these days, but the blatant 'girl-power' in modern TV and cinema does nothing for me really. How about writing great stories where the female is a strong protagonist for the right reasons, rather than replacing male roles with females to show girl-power, which I find a bit patronizing to women anyway. The classic example recently is that moment in Avengers Endgame where all the superhero ladies get together for a girl power moment in the battle. But why highlight it, why not just treat the female superheros the same as the male ones. Give them equal time. That's called equality.
Agreed, I'm on the left politically (some would say extreme left) but I hate this kind of stuff as much as far right conservatism. It's so corny, it's cringeworthy.
 

Ed_Gein

You are nex !
Dec 17, 2003
15,230
5,930
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
LFC, BVB, Rangers, Valencia, Storm
How about this one in the video game Borderlands 3?

 

SM

Bigfooty Legend
Aug 3, 2008
86,524
47,429
North Shore
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Hull City, Adelaide United, EH
It's all Hollywood has left, there are no original ideas just reboots, remakes and franchises. So all they've got is "hey, what if James Bond were....A BLACK WOMAN 😲 "
But she's not playing James Bond. And this is the issue I took with GG's OP because he's repeated this false narrative several times. It's painful.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Top Bottom