Traded Liam Ryan [Traded with 2027 R3 to St Kilda for 2026 R2 (Stk)]

[billings2paddy]

How many flags does Ryan have in our lifetime

Same as Zaine Cordy
Same age as Ryan
We will do a fair trade

 

[txbyhull]

Same as Zaine Cordy
Same age as Ryan
We will do a fair trade

Ah yes premiership icon and 9-game player in 2016. Elite comparison to Liam Ryan.

 

[jumperfan]

Ah yes premiership icon and 9-game player in 2016. Elite comparison to Liam Ryan.

Ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer.

 

[billings2paddy]

Ah yes premiership icon and 9-game player in 2016. Elite comparison to Liam Ryan.

We will do a fair trade if he selects us
Personally, I think he goes to Collingwood as backup for Hill for their 2nd which will probably be pick 38ish

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Owens Marshall Ryan with Hall rotating forward and midfield
Sharman King Higgins

One forward will be on the bench as the forward rotate.

That couldn’t stop a crap after taking 4 laxatives never mind a footballer

That’s a horrid forward line

 

[txbyhull]

Ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer.

Implying Ryan can’t play is even stupider mate. Obviously he’s not NAS but there’s a list of about 10 blokes that are as good as NAS so you’re not really breaking new ground. Ryan easily makes your side better on and off field. Wouldn’t be going after him if he couldn’t play, don’t blame you for not watching the Eagles but he’d kick a hell of a lot more goals if he had any with a half decent kick delivering to him (NAS).

 

[billings2paddy]

Implying Ryan can’t play is even stupider mate. Obviously he’s not NAS but there’s a list of about 10 blokes that are as good as NAS so you’re not really breaking new ground. Ryan easily makes your side better on and off field. Wouldn’t be going after him if he couldn’t play, don’t blame you for not watching the Eagles but he’d kick a hell of a lot more goals if he had any with a half decent kick delivering to him (NAS).

Probably similar to the Stribger trade Except stringer can seriously play and plays key position

 

[txbyhull]

Probably similar to the Stribger trade Except stringer can seriously play and plays key position

lmao

 

[Obeanie1]

Steele doesn’t want to leave. F3 or 43. Or you can huff and puff and treat a legend of you club like garbage and deny his request.

How are we treating him like garbage. We want him to stay,

So are the Saints going to allow club legend Marshall his wishes to go to Geelong for a F3rd or 43?

Nah. Didnt think so.

 

[Obeanie1]

Nah we're just doing the right thing and taking a spud off your hands to help your rebuild. You're welcome

Geez the ignore button gets a workout this time of year.

Bye! Wont miss ya.

 

[ghostbat12]

Maybe.

But for example if we don’t think he is worth a second rounder. We won’t do the deal.

Ala Brodie Kemp last year.

If you were keen on him and paying him the salary you nominated. I’d assume you just bid for him yourself.

Yes, st kilda said no to Brodie kemp and that now means every trade is purely based on what st kilda wants.

It’s as though clubs are desperate to trade players to st kilda and will cry if it doesn’t happen.

Wonder how many of these saints can do before it pisses managers off and no players get offered up.

Woo him with big cash, pay up.

 

[billings2paddy]

Yes, st kilda said no to Brodie kemp and that now means every trade is purely based on what st kilda wants.

It’s as though clubs are desperate to trade players to st kilda and will cry if it doesn’t happen.

Wonder how many of these saints can do before it pisses managers off and no players get offered up.

Woo him with big cash, pay upup.

600k isn't big cash nowadays

 

[eaglevision]

600k isn't big cash nowadays

$2.4M over 4 years for a decomposed corpse is pretty good though.

 

[billings2paddy]

$2.4M over 4 years for a decomposed corpse is pretty good though.

it's not 4 years
It's 3 years with a games trigger
he's 29
2nd round pick to a 3rd

 

[Sheepey]

I wouldn't be paying overs for this one given his age and decline in form (albeit with fair less access to the ball given he's in a poor side). He'd make our side better for sure, but I have concerns about his longevity.

F2 and an exchange of F3s at best. If the Eagles demand anything more then let him stay, as is his right.

 

[BrutThough]

$2.4M over 4 years for a decomposed corpse is pretty good though.

Is he a corpse? Or is he so good he's worth a decent 2nd round pick?

We are getting mixed messages here.

 

[eaglevision]

Is he a corpse? Or is he so good he's worth a decent 2nd round pick?

We are getting mixed messages here.

Depends almost dichotomously on which team you support, as does his age it seems.

 

[stavro#4]

Depends almost dichotomously on which team you support, as does his age it seems.

Well we were saying he is worth a second round pick.

 

[eaglevision]

Well we were saying he is worth a second round pick.

Too broad. Pick 19 in an uncompromised draft sure. Pick 38 in a compromised draft no thanks.

Don’t know what our list team are planning on doing but I’d be handing STK a list of 5-6 players we’re interested in and that’s it.

 

[stavro#4]

Too broad. Pick 19 in an uncompromised draft sure. Pick 38 in a compromised draft no thanks.

Don’t know what our list team are planning on doing but I’d be handing STK a list of 5-6 players we’re interested in and that’s it.

You won’t ensure your premiership player is out of pocket nearly $2m dollars.

So they won’t be doing that and likely settling for an F2. Which addresses your compromised draft concerns.

If you were interested in actually retaining him, you would have matched the deal. Not a lot else to pay at your club right now. Probably trading him 12 months too late to get best value right now aswell. We made the same mistake with Jack Steven.

 

[eaglevision]

You won’t ensure your premiership player is out of pocket nearly $2m dollars.

So they won’t be doing that and likely settling for an F2. Which addresses your compromised draft concerns.

If you were interested in actually retaining him, you would have matched the deal. Not a lot else to pay at your club right now. Probably trading him 12 months too late to get best value right now aswell. We made the same mistake with Jack Steven.

Or we can retain him for the final year of his contract and let him explore FA next year and he can choose his club.

 

[stavro#4]

Or we can retain him for the final year of his contract and let him explore FA next year and he can choose his club.

Sure.

Then he does his knee and misses out on close to $2m.

Unless you contract him yourself. I just can’t see you treating your player this way.

And 600k would be like band 3 aswell

 

[eaglevision]

Sure.

Then he does his knee and misses out on close to $2m.

Unless you contract him yourself. I just can’t see you treating your player this way.

And 600k would be like band 3 aswell

Treating our player like both parties seeing out a two year contract that was mutually agreed to in the absence of a satisfactory offer?

 

[stavro#4]

Treating our player like both parties seeing out a two year contract that was mutually agreed to in the absence of a satisfactory offer?

The actual act of not taking a future second, to take at best a f3 in free agency is kinda mind boggling if I’m honest.

 

[stavro#4]