Libba

[Forrest Gimp]

Your team is a disgrace, coach a disgrace.

Disgusted to know your in the same league as our club which has sweat and bled to keep games alive, striving for success and re-constructing sides from low to mid range draft picks.

Yes we had one year where we finished 14th, that year we played our youngsteres but we didnt play to lose.

Your mob was a bit of a joke before this, now it has been confirmed.

Your a disgrace.

KAMAKAZE ATTACK!!!! LOL. (Please don't card me)

 

[Donstuie]

Typical Libba dog act, he will fit in well at Sunbury

http://talkingcarlton.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=20344&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=60

I have it on the HIGHEST authority because I live in the district and am very close to this football club - that he has already lost the playing group of the Sunbury Football CLub - (where he is senior coach).

There has already been a mass exodus of players there and the season hasn't started.

 

[TCB-1935]

Forgetting Libba,(yes please!) what is it with Gary Lyon?

On Footy Classified and TFS he brought the move of Judd to Carlton into the tanking debate.

Does he not comprehend that Judd was a trade. He has been on Carlton's case since last year and shows no inclination to be evensided and talk about other teams such as Port and the Roos sending players for surgery prior to season end.

 

[RAPPA]

How can everyone be posting crap about Carlton be living behind a veil of ignorance. Does it take a sensationalised piece of contrived crap (anything by Craig Hutchison is crap to me) to alert the football world that clubs 'tank'. The Roos in '06 put their guns into surgery late in the year to "get ready for '07" - that's deliberately not fielding your best side with vested interests. Every side does it and if Hutchison could have the decency to use better examples than Jamieson - the guy will be a permanent fixture in the backline and by the way, if anyone picked up on it:
Hutchison: "Thornton went off and was replaced by Jamieson who isn't on the list this year"
The guy doesn't do his research which was evidenced by the long list of housekeeping issues he disclosed at the end of the interview. Someone fire him to end the misery.
Many teams have tanked and to be perfectly honest, it's not as if Carlton had the resources or had massive stars waiting on the sidelines. So get the F$%K off our cases.

 

[smasha]

actually I Hope Carlton takes it in and make a Lier out Of Libba good riddence to Bad Rubbish glad His Former club kicked him out wonder if he will rubbish the Bulldogs? hope all afl clubs steer Clear of him His Comments are not warrent

and has anyone said about Richmonds Match fixing yet nooooo

I think Libba wants that too.

Smokescreen imo.

Still saying the truth though.

 

[MacMum]

Typical Libba dog act, he will fit in well at Sunbury

Cant stand the man, BUT, was he telling the truth????.....never ceases to amaze me, when someone is honest, the messenger is the one to get shot!.....Lets look at what he was saying first, and if he is right.....and I'm sure he is..Thats what needs to be addressed by the AFL, not denied........Just the same I think his days in footy are numbered....

 

[Thrawn]

Cant stand the man, BUT, was he telling the truth????...

Did he flat out say: "Yes, Carlton tanked" ?

Apparently his 6th sense said yes. But then again, when asked directly... he stumbled and didn't say "yes".

 

[Godfrey Jones]

Forgetting Libba,(yes please!) what is it with Gary Lyon?

On Footy Classified and TFS he brought the move of Judd to Carlton into the tanking debate.

Does he not comprehend that Judd was a trade. He has been on Carlton's case since last year and shows no inclination to be evensided and talk about other teams such as Port and the Roos sending players for surgery prior to season end.

did you see how he ended the judd interview on the footy show?? is he really upset that judd didnt choose melbourne or was he just playing around

 

[Goldust]

Thomas & Pendlebury? How did you get them? Pot, kettle, Black.

FAR be it for me to praise the Magpies....I don't like doing it...but the selection of Pendlebury was a pretty astute decision from where I sit.

Hadn't played a lot of football beforehand and think the choice was pure genius as it turns out as not many clubs would have rathed him that highly!

Be that as it may, you're sidestepping the issue. Libba has exposed you!!! No need for bitterness at someone who has told the truth!

The issue is not what a supposed dog Libba is, what Collingwood did, or what anyone else did, the issue is Carlton tanked!!!

By using tye word "pot-keetle-black" you are agreeing that you did. End of story!

From where I stand, not all that big an issue anyway........it's what the rest of the AFL world already knew!!!

 

[as0l0]

Cant stand the man, BUT, was he telling the truth????

i think he was telling the truth;

"Asked if he thought Carlton coach Brett Ratten had deliberately lost the last game to Melbourne, he responded: Maybe"

 

[as0l0]

pendles taken at pick 5 thats shit tanking then if u ask me

well, you do suck.

 

[D Mitchell]

This is up there with O'Reilly. Any wonder he can't get a job in the industry. Why did we ever ....

Working as an assistant coach at a club which lost 11 in a row is far more damning on his CV than whistle blowing.

 

[Thrawn]

To the opposition supporters who have posted on this thread:

Did you watch the ****ing interview? Honestly?

 

[DIG]

Liberatore's become such a bitter little man. Good riddance.

 

[freodog]

No doubt Carlton tanked. But a floored drafting system which needs an overhaul. Can't blame them. Big D needs to pull his head out of the sand and make some changes.

 

[blues2010]

Its sour grapes by Libba, he did the same to Footscray and they hate him as well. Do people think that maybe we win or lose whenever we feel like it and could have won the premiership but decided to tank and get Kreuzer instead? I just think we weren't that good but things are looking better this year, Judd will rebuild our great club

 

[as0l0]

But a floored drafting system which needs an overhaul.

maybe we could put it on a shelf, or a table, or just something to get it off the floor.

 

[Bee]

The carlton football club where deliberately picking the worst youngsters to go out week after week. thats a disgrace. not putting anyone on travis johnstone in that final match against melbourne. theres nothing wrong getting your players prepped for the next year but you play your best youngsters not crapy one and leaving gr8 player of the opposition run free and for someone in the coaches box say "i cant beleive their taking off travis johnstone". this is a disgrace it's match fixing. Its a petty carlton will not be punished by the afl.

Then believe you are about to be punished by me!

 

[sosos]

We'll see you in court little man.

 

[freodog]

maybe we could put it on a shelf, or a table, or just something to get it off the floor.

Well done. Good pick up. I can spell TANK though.

 

[CarterS]

If it's true then what kind of culture would that be creating at the club?

Weak and spineless, negativity, long term it would do nothing but bad. How could you (Ratten) look yourself in the eye?

 

[Johnny Utah #9]

Libba is just bitter he got the ar$e. I'm sure any person that gets sacked is going to say bad things about their former employer.

As for Hutchy the guy is a clown. The only player who he could actually mention that got a game who should not have was Michael Jamieson and his proof of this was "he is not even on the senior list this year either". Clearly, he didn't watch any of Jamieson's games last year, otherwise he would have seen a young kid who tried his guts out and more than held his own in the games he played. Hardly tanking in my book.

Furthermore, Hutchy comments about Jammo's list status is also flawed. Jammo is our nominated rookie, which we are allowed to have because we have no Veterans, therefore he can player every game in the seniors so he is in effect a senior list player. It's good list management if you ask me, as his base contract is that of a rookie not senior list player and we can have a full quota of 38 on the senior as well.

I am still yet to see anyone prove to me there were blokes in our reserves who should have been playing seniors. We simply weren't good enough and didn't have the talent. End of story.

 

[legendtofski]

Hey lets not get too upset about Libba, it's patently obvious he was doing a nationwide on-air audition for season 2 of UNDERBELLY!

 

[Bee]

Spot on
Cheated

Lets see what big lance has to say

You should be more worried about what I have to say!

 

[BlueBelle]

The carlton football club where deliberately picking the worst youngsters to go out week after week. thats a disgrace. not putting anyone on travis johnstone in that final match against melbourne. theres nothing wrong getting your players prepped for the next year but you play your best youngsters not crapy one and leaving gr8 player of the opposition run free and for someone in the coaches box say "i cant beleive their taking off travis johnstone". this is a disgrace it's match fixing. Its a petty carlton will not be punished by the afl.

So does that mean Collingwood tanked the prelim because they didn't have anybody on Jimmy Bartel?

He ran riot in their back half and nobody manned up on him! DISGRACEFUL!