Autopsy Liked, Learned, and Hated Round 18, 2019

Chief

Admin
Dec 1, 1999
76,528
46,274
Brisbane
AFL Club
Carlton
All the weekend's results
Date
Home v Away Teams
Result
Venue
Crowd
Fri 19 Jul 7:20pm​
Adelaide v Essendon
10.15 (75) – 15.6 (96)​
Adelaide Oval​
47735​
Sat 20 Jul 1:45pm​
Richmond v Port Adelaide​
15.11 (101) – 9.9 (63)​
MCG​
41642​
Sat 20 Jul 2:10pm​
Carlton v Gold Coast​
15.9 (99) – 11.9 (75)​
Marvel Stadium​
31765​
Sat 20 Jul 4:35pm​
GWS v Collingwood​
19.8 (122) – 11.9 (75)​
Showground Stadium​
15467​
Sat 20 Jul 6:10pm​
Fremantle v Sydney​
7.10 (52) – 7.9 (51)​
Optus Stadium​
33594​
Sat 20 Jul 7:25pm​
Brisbane v North Melbourne​
12.15 (87) – 12.3 (75)​
Gabba​
23833​
Sun 21 Jul 1:10pm​
Geelong v Hawthorn
8.13 (61) – 12.13 (85)​
MCG​
53636​
Sun 21 Jul 2:50pm​
Melbourne v West Coast
11.12 (78) – 14.7 (91)​
TIO Traegar Park​
7164​
Sun 21 Jul 4:40pm​
St Kilda v Western Bulldogs​
17.14 (116) – 14.5 (89)​
Marvel Stadium​
21705​



Team
P
W
L
D
%
From Rd 17
1
Geelong Cats​
17​
13​
4​
0​
135.80%​
0​
2
Brisbane Lions​
17​
12​
5​
0​
114.87%​
1
3
West Coast Eagles​
17​
12​
5​
0​
113.53%​
1
4
Collingwood Magpies​
17​
11​
6​
0​
111.90%​
-2
5
Richmond Tigers​
17​
11​
6​
0​
107.52%​
0​
6
GWS Giants​
17​
10​
7​
0​
123.60%​
0​
7
Essendon Bombers​
17​
10​
7​
0​
103.86%​
1
8
Adelaide Crows​
17​
9​
8​
0​
110.16%​
-1
9
Port Adelaide Power​
17​
8​
9​
0​
102.27%​
0​
10
Hawthorn Hawks​
17​
8​
9​
0​
101.95%​
1
11
Fremantle Dockers​
17​
8​
9​
0​
96.24%​
2
12
Western Bulldogs​
17​
8​
9​
0​
93.36%​
-2
13
North Melbourne Kangaroos​
17​
7​
10​
0​
98.68%​
-1
14
St Kilda Saints​
17​
7​
10​
0​
82.92%​
1
15
Sydney Swans​
17​
6​
11​
0​
95.40%​
-1
16
Carlton Blues​
17​
5​
12​
0​
85.57%​
1
17
Melbourne Demons​
17​
5​
12​
0​
80.65%​
-1
18
Gold Coast Suns​
17​
3​
14​
0​
64.81%​
0​

Rd 19 Previews:

Collingwood v Richmond, 19:50 Jul 26
Hawthorn v Brisbane Lions, 1:45 Jul 27
Carlton v Adelaide, 2:10 Jul 27
West Coast v North Melb, 2:35AWST Jul 27
St Kilda v Melbourne, 7:25 Jul 27
Port Adelaide v GWS Giants, 7:10ACST Jul 27
Western Bulldogs v Fremantle, 1:10 Jul 28
Sydney Swans v Geelong Cats, 3:20 Sun Jul 28
Gold Coast v Essendon, 4:40 Sun Jul 28
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Coaster2012

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 10, 2012
5,825
6,421
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Manchester City, Lakers
Liked: Geelong and Collingwood losing.
Learnt: I know nothing. We all know nothing.
Hated: I'm not one to bag on umpires because there are others that do it enough for all of us, but that Westhoff 50m penalty was horrendous.
 

mike123

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 13, 2013
27,289
23,521
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Juventus
Learnt: taller players have an advantage against smaller players in marking contests.
 

dean33

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 10, 2007
7,893
9,749
melb
AFL Club
Richmond
Liked - the jack Tom combo is going to be quite the handful for opposition defences, especially when you throw dusty down there.

Learnt - Unlike 2018 we might just be timing our run to perfection.

Hated- the end to the north lions game.
 

Stopher

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 19, 2012
9,056
13,679
Gippsland
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Liverpool
Liked- Conor's solo. Such a unique player and would be fast becoming a headache for opposition to work out.

Learnt- West Coast and Richmond looking ominous. Getting the bulk of their best teams together at the right time of year.

Hated- So much said about the free at the end of the Bris v North game, but the Westhoff 50 was every bit as atrocious. 'Razor' Ray has had to assume a number of different things to justify that decision, despite on face value the player performing a perfectly acceptable act.
 

Bastyy

All Australian
Sep 18, 2015
743
931
Launceston, TAS
AFL Club
Fremantle
Liked: Andrew Brayshaw, GWS, Saints under Ratten, Reilly O'Brien carrying my Fantasy side

Learnt: Richmond and WC should be premiership favourites, injuries the only thing stopping eagles from going B2B, Dockers still have some chance of making finals, Hawthorn will be top 4 next year

Hated: SA Teams, Umpiring
 

Ambrose Burnside

Club Legend
Dec 8, 2006
2,187
2,096
WA
AFL Club
West Coast
Liked- Conor's solo. Such a unique player and would be fast becoming a headache for opposition to work out.

Learnt- West Coast and Richmond looking ominous. Getting the bulk of their best teams together at the right time of year.

Hated- So much said about the free at the end of the Bris v North game, but the Westhoff 50 was every bit as atrocious. 'Razor' Ray has had to assume a number of different things to justify that decision, despite on face value the player performing a perfectly acceptable act.
I wish the Eagles were getting their best team together :( Just last week we lost Nic Nat and Cripps, the week before Duggan, dunno when Hutchings is back and who knows if Gov and Hurn will play this week :( Kennedy is in poor form too. We played something like 8 or 9 players with less than 50 games experience vs Melbourne.

Richmond are looking ominous I'll grant you that!
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Do the Dew

Team Captain
Feb 14, 2019
366
494
US and A
AFL Club
Richmond
Liked: Geelong and Collingwood losing.
Learnt: I know nothing. We all know nothing.
Hated: I'm not one to bag on umpires because there are others that do it enough for all of us, but that Westhoff 50m penalty was horrendous.
Agreed, it was. But's let conveniently leave out the Gawn htb decision that helped ice the game your way huh
 

Dee Train

Team Captain
Aug 17, 2017
367
579
AFL Club
Melbourne
Liked- Conor's solo. Such a unique player and would be fast becoming a headache for opposition to work out.

Learnt- West Coast and Richmond looking ominous. Getting the bulk of their best teams together at the right time of year.

Hated- So much said about the free at the end of the Bris v North game, but the Westhoff 50 was every bit as atrocious. 'Razor' Ray has had to assume a number of different things to justify that decision, despite on face value the player performing a perfectly acceptable act.
Absolutely appalling decision.
 

Coaster2012

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 10, 2012
5,825
6,421
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Manchester City, Lakers
Agreed, it was. But's let conveniently leave out the Gawn htb decision that helped ice the game your way huh
How did I conveniently leave it out? It's not something I learnt, liked, or hated so why on Earth would I include it you numpty?
 
Last edited:

DontArgue4

Premium Platinum
May 3, 2013
15,518
45,441
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Houston Rockets, Arsenal, PhiEagles
Liked: Tigers showing some great signs, Lynch is finally training twice a week and his recent form is showing that. Jack started looking more dangerous also this week.

Learnt: The lions are legit, dons depth is better than advertised

Hated: Ridiculous call against Thompson at the end of the North v Lions game, shocker. Jarman Impeys injury, looked nasty.
 

MCG-Unit

Club Legend
Oct 28, 2003
2,094
260
Round Table
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Chelsea
Liked: Lyons, O'Brien, Marshall

GWS Giants, Brisbane Lions & WC Eagles wins. Loved Saints over WB media darlings ->

Learnt: There are Giants in the land

Disliked: Umpiring in general :oops: Losing the free kick count by about 10 & inconsistency
 

pazza

Hall of Famer
Feb 18, 2003
31,539
5,458
Hoppers Crossing
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Liverpool
Liked: Carlton under Teague. Sign him up now. Has them going well.

Learned: Richmond's tall forwards may just be the best in the comp when they combine.

Hated: Impey's knee.
 

jason pm

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 31, 2015
17,251
32,034
By the Gabba.
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Valleys. Chelsea.
No suprise that your team was the one who won a game off the back of poor, no make that horrendous umpiring
Yep, that was the only umpiring mistake in that game according to most apparently. Result should have been overturned and the Kangas awarded the points as they obviously would have gone on to win it, the fix was in, time for a royal commission. :rolleyes:
 

Asapartyhat

Hat wearer
Apr 25, 2012
614
717
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
stirling senators
Liked - Trager Park AFL in the Northern Territory.Not just because we won(we being the Eagles) but the whole vibe the feel of the place Melbourne have done a good service to the AFL being a national league thing with that.
Learned - not a lot changed this week
Hated -North Melbourne being dudded.They will be hard to beat next game.
 
Last edited:

00Stinger

Duel Group 1 winner
May 8, 2007
20,822
20,281
@ HOME
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Liverpool & San Francisco 49ers
Yep, that was the only umpiring mistake in that game according to most apparently. Result should have been overturned and the Kangas awarded the points as they obviously would have gone on to win it, the fix was in, time for a royal commission. :rolleyes:
that free kick didn't have an impact on the result?
 

jason pm

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 31, 2015
17,251
32,034
By the Gabba.
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Valleys. Chelsea.
that free kick didn't have an impact on the result?
Off course it did as did numerous other free kicks during that game and in every game that has ever been played. As I've said before IMO the free kick was a mistake... and nobody has any idea how it would have impacted the result, IMO we would have still went on the win, in others opinion the Kangas would have.

What would you like the Lions to do, knock back the 4 points and forfeit the game?
 

Le Grille

Brownlow Medallist
Feb 14, 2005
12,419
20,233
Perth
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Off course it did as did numerous other free kicks during that game and in every game that has ever been played. As I've said before IMO the free kick was a mistake... and nobody has any idea how it would have impacted the result, IMO we would have still went on the win, in others opinion the Kangas would have.

What would you like the Lions to do, knock back the 4 points and forfeit the game?
Well not spit, pinch and dive would be a good start
 

Top Bottom