I have for a long time defended Sam Butler.
However after his game tonight, at crucial moments when he continually turned the ball over - I might add he's played over 100 games - he should've played his last game.
Both him and Brennan were the two most insipid players from one of the most awful wins in our clubs history.
On a positive Sheed started well.
From what I have seen of Brennan, he would struggle to perform even in the WAFL.
I agree with you about Butler, he isn't the worst player on the list, but at his age now he is a list clogger who is never going to be anything more than a bit part player when there are injuries, this has to be his last year.
I have been a big critic of Smith, but I actually thought he did ok last night, maybe a forward role is where he needs to play as he makes way too many mistakes as a defender.
It was a poor standard game, but given the outs from both sides, a win is a win I guess.