- Banned
- #1,401
He wouldn't man.Yep. He’d be a great addition - but is in leadership group and freo is on the up - why would he move now?
Logue is the key defender from Freo that might be gettable however.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
He wouldn't man.Yep. He’d be a great addition - but is in leadership group and freo is on the up - why would he move now?
WCE are in a world of painThe other issue facing the Hawks is West Coast will be cleaning out their list so I would have to think Gaff would be shopped , Shoey may retire or again be shopped.
Nic Nat on his huge contract might not have any takers....but there are some silly clubs out there.
So come seasons end Tom, JOM and Worpel will see their values drop even more.
Tigers and Cats will be the next clubs facing the reality check.
Worpel will probably be the one that gets us the best deal as he very sound in body and the Crimmins medal.
The fact he has played along side 2 slow mid fielders might see his worth be very tempting for other clubs.
Especially geelong.
Hartigan is contracted next year?He wasn't contracted for 2023 unlike Hartigan.
YesHartigan is contracted next year?
That is abysmal list management, how did that occur...
He has a trigger for next year - no idea if he already met it last yearHartigan is contracted next year?
Wright/Clarkson. They were horrific at the endThat is abysmal list management, how did that occur...
Singing a FB for 3 years on a pittance, when we didn't have one is abysmal list management now?That is abysmal list management, how did that occur...
From the tv it looks like he’s doing a lot directing and organising on the field. He’s always pointing and directing.Far too early to be seriously considering a trade for Worpel - will need a 'senior' player to guide the young mids if Tom and JOM depart and I'm backing Worps to step up in this scenario
That is abysmal list management, how did that occur...
3 years is an extremely long time in football. Now he's taking up the list spot of a kid we could potentially draft in the MSD.Singing a FB for 3 years on a pittance, when we didn't have one is abysmal list management now?
Glad you've got nothing to do with the club, bud.
Your take is a really bad one.3 years is an extremely long time in football. Now he's taking up the list spot of a kid we could potentially draft in the MSD.
We still don't have a FB considering he's playing in the twos, so don't really see what your point it. The current football department must not rate him very highly in terms of where we are heading?
No matter which way you spin it, our list was massively overrated during the last few years of the Clarko era and some of the decisions made are costing us dearly now.
Take your Clarko koolaid elsewhere champ...
Cmon man, giving 3 years to a bloke the Crows ( bottom club at time) delisted is abysmal list management no matter which way you spin it. Yeah 1 year maybe 2 years would of been ok. But 3???Your take is a really bad one.
This is not about Clarko Kool-Aid, abysmal list management would have been retiring Frawley and then not replacing him with anyone, in the hope that Frost could hold down Fullback for the next 3 years with Hartley in reserve. What a mess that would’ve been.
He was a FA, he was not delisted.Cmon man, giving 3 years to a bloke the Crows ( bottom club at time) delisted is abysmal list management no matter which way you spin it. Yeah 1 year maybe 2 years would of been ok. But 3???
Your take is a really bad one.
This is not about Clarko Kool-Aid, abysmal list management would have been retiring Frawley and then not replacing him with anyone, in the hope that Frost could hold down Fullback for the next 3 years with Hartley in reserve. What a mess that would’ve been.
But ‘Clarko kool-aid’ was ok, yeah?Isn’t that what has essentially happened this year and will for next as Hartigan is not good enough for the ones? People are suggesting he retire to get an MSD pick.
On a side note, I don’t that saying things like ‘your take is a really bad one’ when there see pros and vibe on both sides is really great for fostering discussion.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I'd prefer to have Hartigan than not. Frosty's knee was looking a little sore against Essendon and he will need a break at some point soon I would suggest.Isn’t that what has essentially happened this year and will for next as Hartigan is not good enough for the ones? People are suggesting he retire to get an MSD pick.
On a side note, I don’t that saying things like ‘your take is a really bad one’ when there see pros and vibe on both sides is really great for fostering discussion.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
The point is not about whether it was wise or not for insurance. I agree at the time he was a good addition as we had no other options.But ‘Clarko kool-aid’ was ok, yeah?
Hartigan is good enough for the seniors, Sam’s just choosing not to play him as he wants games into DGB and also likes a more mobile defence.
He was more than servicable last year it’s worth remembering, we were the 5th ranked defence in the comp for stopping scores from inside 50’s, and Hartigan/Frost/Hardwick we’re collectively outmarked 5 times for the year.
He was a FA, would he have joined for 2 years? maybe, maybe not. Can't remember seeing too many move for a 2 year contract.The point is not about whether it was wise or not for insurance. I agree at the time he was a good addition as we had no other options.
My problem is the length of the contract. If they truly understood where our list was at, 3 years would not have been considered.
I think in 2023 he’s just a waste of a list spot, but that’s my opinion.He was a FA, would he have joined for 2 years? maybe, maybe not. Can't remember seeing too many move for a 2 year contract.
You give him 3 years to get him across for free, and on low salary. Makes complete sense, and even in 2023 should we not play him much, he's going to be very handy should Frost or Sicily get injured for a spell, because DGB is still raw.