List of comparable players - Carlton vs Collingwood

[DidakDelight]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

 

[sr36]

Why?

 

[EB&W Pieman]

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

It makes me wonder how they thrashed us twice this season!

 

[Squida25]

It makes me wonder how they thrashed us twice this season!

Because no one can compete with McLean..

 

[Balance]

Both bolded = equal
Neither bolded = don't know

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

Almost forgot =

Malthouse vs Buckley

 

[Scotland]

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

Collingwood > Carlton I guess.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair?? Ellard not best 22
Lucas vs Sidebottom Neither is Lucas
Waite vs Cloke If Waite plays he is better, but he doesnt so probably Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

 

[Sttew]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

From an unbiased Cats supporter.

 

[Hodge is God]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe (lol who?)
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

That is, of course, all at top form.

 

[Hodge is God]

Any for a Fremantle/Essendon comparison of the players?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Any for a Fremantle/Essendon comparison of the players?

A more relevenat comparison would be Brisbane / Sydney
If there is not a Brisbane Sydney comparison within minutes then i have lost all faith in humanity

 

[Moist Biscuit]

It makes me wonder how they thrashed us twice this season!

Fasolo > Garlett

 

[Hodge is God]

A more relevenat comparison would be Brisbane / Sydney
If there is not a Brisbane Sydney comparison within minutes then i have lost all faith in humanity

Here here.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Fasolo > Garlett

Maybe if the measurement was arrogance, then yes i agree

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Waite better then cloke? What stuff you taking man ?

 

[Ambrosia]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Maybe if the measurement was arrogance, then yes i agree

If I was measuring on output rather then ability I am 100 % right

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Waite better then cloke? What stuff you taking man ?

More aerobic, better kick, not as good of a contested mark but he doesn't dissapear like Cloke does, especially this year,
I'd take a fit waite anyday but Cloke because he's more enduring.

 

[blueboy25]

If I was measuring on output rather then ability I am 100 % right

Garlett averages nearly 40 goals a season
Fasolo 22 per season

 

[PoidaCat]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swan
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey (both s**t)
Jamieson vs N.Brown (both s**t)
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo (can't vote for either peanut)
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

 

[biggiemediums]

Garlett averages nearly 40 goals a season
Fasolo 22 per season

Fasolo played a lot more midfield than Garlett this season. I'm talking a lot more.

 

[Parquet Court]

Here is a my list of comparable players from each team

Please bold who you think is better head-to-head.
Also let me know if you think certain match-ups aren't comparable

Murphy vs Pendlebury
Simpson vs Thomas
Henderson vs Reid
Judd vs Swann
Carrazzo vs Ball
Watson vs Keefe
Gibbs vs Shaw
Robinson vs Beams
Armfield vs Toovey
Jamieson vs N.Brown
Ellard vs Blair
Lucas vs Sidebottom
Waite vs Cloke
Yarran vs O'Brien
Gartlett vs Fasolo
Betts vs Krakouer
Duigan vs Maxwell

All Carlton. according to monkey king

 

[Suma Magic]

A bit harsh comparing Carlton with Collingwood isn't it?

I think Essendon/Richmond/North would be more appropriate?

 

[Parquet Court]

A bit harsh comparing Carlton with Collingwood isn't it?

I think Essendon/Richmond/North would be more appropriate?

Agree, hasn't been done before either.

 

[blueboy25]

Fasolo played a lot more midfield than Garlett this season. I'm talking a lot more.

Bit of a worry that he is only averaging 2 more disposals than Garlett especially as like you said he played a lot more in the midfield this year.