Longmuir should get a rest.

[rgauci]

Since Kosi isn't playing (due to injury) i really think Longmuir should get a rest. Longmuir is obviously carrying an injury, since our ruck division is so shallow we need to keep him fit and injury free. Sandilands could ruck the game against the Saints ruck division.

He could be backed up by Johnson, Murphy or Polak. All of which are taller than the Saints back up in Blake.

 

[TP3_Freo]

Since Kosi isn't playing (due to injury) i really think Longmuir should get a rest. Longmuir is obviously carrying an injury, since our ruck division is so shallow we need to keep him fit and injury free. Sandilands could ruck the game against the Saints ruck division.

He could be backed up by Johnson, Murphy or Polak. All of which are taller than the Saints back up in Blake.

this is definately the week to rest jlo. i think if we were to leave him out this week then johnson would be used as the second ruckman, but we will have to wait and see what the selection board decide to do

 

[Wizard]

Bring back Koopsy he can ruck, remember his massive leap.

Does anyone remmeber Trent Ormond Allan rucking for the Crows against Peter Everitt one day and actually beatng him a few times?

 

[dominguez]

I agree. In- Duffield, Murphy. Out- JLo, Hasleby.

Matthew Carr, Medhurst and Hayden given 1 more week to find form.

Johnson on Gehrig and Parker can cover him when Johnson is in the ruck. Grover on Hamill. Hayden on Milne. McPharlin to CHB on Riewoldt and Murphy at FF.


B- Mundy Johnson Hayden
HB- Grover McPharlin Schammer
C- Dodd Crowley Black
HF- McManus Pavlich Polak
F- Farmer Murphy Headland
Ruck- Sandilands J. Carr Bell
Int- Medhurst Duffield Parker M. Carr

 

[Ripper]

We really missed Justin last time He didn't play.

If it was up to me I would bring in Warren & Duffman for Justin & Haze. Scham , Crowley , Medders & Duffman can all get a run on ball at some stage.

 

[TP3_Freo]

I agree. In- Duffield, Murphy. Out- JLo, Hasleby.

Matthew Carr, Medhurst and Hayden given 1 more week to find form.

Johnson on Gehrig and Parker can cover him when Johnson is in the ruck. Grover on Hamill. Hayden on Milne. McPharlin to CHB on Riewoldt and Murphy at FF.


B- Mundy Johnson Hayden
HB- Grover McPharlin Schammer
C- Dodd Crowley Black
HF- McManus Pavlich Polak
F- Farmer Murphy Headland
Ruck- Sandilands J. Carr Bell
Int- Medhurst Duffield Parker M. Carr

i think polak will play full forward and move medhurst into the half forward position, murphy to start on the interchange

 

[malpaso]

Agree with resting JLo, he has to be fit to be effective.

With Haselby out, I'd bring back Cookie, him and McManus will put some hard hits on the Saints' midfield.

Is it just me or is the Saints midfield slow? After Dal Santo and Ball, they dont move too well..

IN: Cook, Murphy, Duffield
OUT: Haselby, Longmuir, Medhurst

 

[hoss]

I'd be happy to rest JLo this week. We need some more tacklers in the team. This is one facet of St Kilda's game which is top notch - probably best in the AFL.

Call me Capt. Obvious but we need to break even in the clearances and win the tackle count.

 

[dockers_bengals]

I hate coaches playing injured players.they shouldn,t do it if they are less than able to play at full pace.Opposition coaches either no anyway or work out quickly and exploit it.The players get trashed for playing rubbish and cant say anything.

 

[FreoFury]

deleted

 

[kanabar]

is he truly injured i reckon we should not drop Jlo and just tell him to rest in the forward line, mainly FF.

haze out and duffman in, send schammer in the middle and need way to bring in cook.