In our squad, I'd favour Lonie. In our best 22, I wouldn't take either.
The Chaplin, Wakelin, Cornes combination should work well this year. Chappy looks well suited to take the opposition's most dangerous tall forward, while I expect Wakes to take the tallest forward and perhaps be in a position to peel off his man a bit, ala Bassett. Bishop would have had no place in our side this year.
I've made my opinions on Lonie very clear. I have never had any time for players who don't naturally play a physical game of footy and go in and get their own ball. At his best you could forgive Dewy for being a receiving type of player, as he used the footy so well. Lonie has the archetypal neat-looking kick, but his decision making is not as good as Choco led us to believe when he was traded for, and his ability to hit teammates has never been tested in pressure situations (something Dew did well).
I'd prefer to play someone else on his wing.