Luckiest AA Player

[Brent24]

Judd.

 

[hendo8888]

i'd say Harley
have never seen him do much
never takes one of the top 2 or 3 forwards and gets help in every contest he goes for
Enright had a very good year and deserved his spot

i thought they pretty much got it right this year
3 most surprising were Harley, Richo (ok not surprising just not really deserved) and Morris (thoroughly deserved just didn't expect it)

 

[Helfarch]

Harley for sure, only in the team through the selection panel's mutual masturbation over defensive marks.

 

[Knife Wrench]

[Original quote: Judd....plenty of better midfielders this year, e.g. mitchell, kirk, etc
and let alone the captaincy! ]

I wish Judd was half as talented your AA players or Selwood.

Especially Enright.

Do you have a mental deficiency?
Did i say that Selwood should have got in? I just said Mitchell or Kirk should have got in over Judd (if you haven't noticed, they don't play for Geelong, so obviously not stroking my ego) who wasn't that spectacular this year. Also Enright plays in the back line and was well-deserving of his place, Judd could have played -3 games and and still would have been selected even though there were better players than him this year.

 

[DarwinRoo]

Pavlich.

 

[Gozz]

People who think Judd or Enright were lucky obviously don't watch much footy. And the only people who think Judd didn't deserve a gig are jealous of his amazing football ability and they hate Carlton.

So keep your Judd hatred to the Hawthorn, Richmond and Bay 13 boards.

 

[AGC]

Buddy, twice.

Don't think Moore has been beaten all year. The most he coughed up was 4 against Fev despite killing him in nearly every 1 on 1.

Well Josh Gibson is the only AFL defender to have Buddy's measure- does that mean he should have been in?

 

[Swanny36]

Medhurst.

Jamison pantsed him twice this year.

Not an AA player...

I wish Judd was half as talented your AA players or Selwood.

Especially Enright.

once.....douche
In the second game Medhurst had:

Kicks: 18
Marks: 11
H/Balls: 3
Disposals: 21
Goals: 4
Behinds: 2


hardly call that "pantsed", do your research! bafoon!

 

[Bubba_5]

Who was the luckiest AA player to make the team?

More like which idiot started the thread and made Cooney one of the options.

 

[Perth Swans]

More like which idiot started the thread and made Cooney one of the options.

More like which 16 idiots voted him

 

[Bubba_5]

More like which 16 idiots voted him

Yea because you made him an option, I guarantee you that if you didn't have him up there, there wouldn't be 16 people selecting other and specifying Cooney. Why don't you go get a proper memory, instead of that of a goldfish, so you can remember what Cooney did in the first two thirds of the season and respect the champion that he is becoming.

 

[Richo is God]

people that are sayin sandilands was lucky are wrong. averages more hitouts than any other ruckman, and correct me if im wrong but was said to have 20 hitouts to advantage more than any other ruckman.

no way should judd of gotten the captaincy

 

[MIDDO]

sandilands for me
i would rather have hille in the team is patto man serious
kelvin moore before fisher or morris
does anyone else think moore is not that good

Might have meant Kelvin Moore from Hawthorn like twenty years ago !!
Fisher and Morris way ahead of the Richmond bloke .

 

[cSylvia]

Sandilands was deserving, but Hille had a better year.

My answer though is Pavlich. He was alright, but there were better KPF's this year.

 

[Rgs011]

Fev!

As far as I knew he plays full forward...and that spot went to Franklin!
Or maybe any of the others picked in the side out of position (....like the wings). Aren't they both on-ballers?

Putting the team into positions is meaningless. Just name the 22 in alphabetical order...it would make more sense on paper that way.

 

[AsianWithAFro]

Harley how did he get VC if anything his captaincy is more of a title when you have guys like Ablest, Bartel, Ling and Scarlet playing around you. He only got it because of Geelong's success other than that there's was no way he would of got it. I do believe Mitchell was very very harsh not to get in.

 

[undies37]

sandilands i think but they got it mostly right
morris is an absolute gun and deserved his spot. he is much better than kelvin moore and i no who i would want in my team
most unlucky were probably kirk, hille and even petrie. i cant believe people havent said him yet
he had an awesome second half of the year
i spose its correct that u need to have 2 consistently good years in order to be considered and thats why they didnt get picked except for kirk
they didnt want a "run with" player. thats y he didnt

 

[RU486]

I'am an advid football fan put dident even know who Dale Morris was till AA Night

 

[wheels4]

I'am an advid football fan put dident even know who Dale Morris was till AA Night

you obviosly arent an advid footy fan if you dont no who morris is.
morris is a gun.
and cooney was not lucky, he will finish top 5 in the brownlow, whoever made this thread shame on you. and enrights position was well deserved and so was judds he played a ripper season